Next.js logo

FISHMARKET II

Updated

Phone: (917) 363-8101

Address: 171 AVENUE A 10009

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Authentic Malaysian gems hidden inside an unassuming East Village sports bar. Expect high-quality flavor and a laid-back vibe.

Reddit Sentiment for FISHMARKET II(based on 10 Reddit opinions)

80% Positive20% Neutral

Tags

malaysian 4malaysian 3View All

Neighborhoods

East Village

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
NYC Restaurants: The Hit List
positive

Mackerel is a star at this East Village seafood spot, particularly the jerk-spiced version. Whole mackerels are grilled to crispy, fatty perfection, showcasing the underrated fish.

Bryan Kim • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Located in the East Village, this spot serves exceptional Malaysian and Chinese-Malaysian cuisine in an unassuming sports bar setting [1], [6]. While the interior may lack atmosphere, the quality of the food keeps patrons returning for more [1], [3]. Beyond Malaysian staples, the kitchen is also recognized for its impressive preparation of seafood, including a standout grilled mackerel [10].

Food Overview

This establishment specializes in Malaysian and Chinese-Malaysian dishes, with many diners considering it a go-to spot for the cuisine [4], [6]. Standout items include the curry laksa [4], Char Kway Teow [8], and a highly-regarded jerk-spiced whole mackerel [10]. Guests are occasionally treated to complimentary sake or whiskey shots [6].

Customer Sentiment

Patrons consistently praise the high quality of the food, often overlooking the dive-bar aesthetic and bright lighting to enjoy their meals [1], [2]. Service is frequently described as friendly, and the bar seating is considered a great option for solo diners [7], [9].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About FISHMARKET II

The best food with the worst vibes
This thread discusses the restaurant's mismatch between its exceptional Malaysian food and its bright, sports-bar-style interior.
Your favorite Malaysian restaurant in the city?
Users highlight the restaurant as an amazing destination for authentic Malaysian food, specifically recommending the curry laksa.
Favorite solo dining spots to sit at the bar?
The location is recommended as a reliable, comfortable spot for solo diners to eat at the bar with friendly staff.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: What Do You All Think Is The Per Se Of Nyc Sports

"Mentioned as an alternative with better food and seating, but lacking the character of the original."

Positive
Sep 5, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Your Favorite Reliablecomfylocal Eats

"Recommends Fishmarket II for its amazing Malaysian food and friendly service, noting it's usually not busy."

Positive
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Char Kway Teow

"This user mentioned that while they haven't been to Fishmarket II, they've been told it's good for Char Kway Teow."

Neutral
Mar 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For A Casualfun Restaurant For A Birthday

"This restaurant serves Chinese-Malaysian food and offers free sake shots. The original location at South Street Seaport has a dive bar vibe and offers free whiskey shots."

Positive
Jan 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Favorite Solo Dining Spots To Sit At The Bar

"FishMarket II in the East Village is suggested for solo diners, praised for its nice bartenders and reliable bar seating, though the drinks are described as uninspiring, the food is considered a favorite."

Positive
Jan 12, 2026View Comment →

More in East Village

See all

More Malaysian in NYC

See all