TLDR
Chef-elevated Italian fare in a charming backyard setting. A must-visit, but plan ahead as tables book out weeks in advance.
Amber Sutherland-Namako reviews Cafe Spaghetti, an Italian restaurant in Brooklyn, praising its welcoming atmosphere and standout dishes like orecchiette with salsiccia and broccoli rabe.
Details
Located in Brooklyn's Cobble Hill, this spot offers a refined, chef-elevated take on Italian-American cuisine that distinguishes it from standard red-sauce joints [1], [13]. Diners frequent the space for its charming backyard, welcoming hospitality, and consistently solid menu offerings [1], [3], [4], [15]. Due to its popularity, reservations can book out as far as a month in advance [8].
Food Overview
The menu features elevated takes on Italian classics, with the orecchiette with salsiccia and broccoli rabe, and the cacio e pepe rice balls receiving particular praise [1]. Guests also highly enjoy the spumoni and the 'anti-signature' Spiadini [10], [12], while the spaghetti pomodoro is frequently cited as a 'glow-up' of a traditional staple [2], [4], [15].
Caveats
The restaurant is very popular and typically books out a month in advance; diners are encouraged to use the Resy standby list if reservations are full [8].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CAFE SPAGHETTI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: On A Hunt For Private Dining With Simple Italian
"Recommended for large parties due to its beautiful outdoor space and great food and vibe."
PositiveFrom post: Italian American Spots
"Responding to a recommendation for Cafe Spaghetti, this user noted it looks 'chef elevated' and will add it to their rotation."
PositiveFrom post: Italian American Spots
"This user recommended Cafe Spaghetti in Cobble Hill, advising against Marco Polo and describing Cafe Spaghetti as more chef-elevated than a traditional red-sauce joint."
PositiveFrom post: Spumoni Dessert Location
"Cafe Spaghetti is mentioned as having spumoni and is described as an incredible restaurant overall."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Traditional Italian Recommendations
"This user recommended Cafe Spaghetti or Frankie's Spuntino in Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Random Dish From A Random
"Spiadini at Cafe Spaghetti is listed as an 'anti-signature' favorite dish."
PositiveFrom post: Dinner Suggestions Cobble Hillish Area
"Cafe Spaghetti was recommended as a dining option."
PositiveFrom post: Dinner Suggestions Cobble Hillish Area
"This user noted that Cafe Spaghetti is a popular spot that books out a month in advance and suggested using the Resy standby list."
PositiveFrom post: Dinner Suggestions Cobble Hillish Area
"Cafe Spaghetti was recommended as a great Italian restaurant option."
PositiveFrom post: Dinner Suggestions Cobble Hillish Area
"Cafe Spaghetti was recommended as a good option."
PositiveFrom post: Collecting Nyc Restaurant Matches
"The user collects matchbooks from various NYC restaurants and Cafe Spaghetti is one of them."
NeutralFrom post: Nyc Has A New 3 Star Restaraunt
"This user enjoys Cafe Spaghetti, describing it as consistently serving solid red sauce Italian dishes in a chill atmosphere."
PositiveFrom post: Best Vegetarian Pasta Dish
"Cafe Spaghetti is suggested as a potential place for seasonal pasta specials."
PositiveFrom post: Lunch After Wedding In Bk
"This restaurant was simply listed as a suggestion for lunch."
Neutral