Brooklyn's Italian charmer: Chef-elevated classics, a transportive backyard, and generous wine pours. Perfect for families and any pasta lover.
Amber Sutherland-Namako reviews Cafe Spaghetti, an Italian restaurant in Brooklyn, praising its welcoming atmosphere and standout dishes like orecchiette with salsiccia and broccoli rabe.
This Italian gem in Brooklyn offers a charming escape with its transportive ambiance, especially its delightful backyard setting. The menu features classic Italian-American dishes with a touch of elevated preparation, making it a standout choice for both families and those seeking a relaxed yet refined dining experience. It's a place where generous wine pours and warm hospitality complement a menu of well-executed favorites.
This Italian restaurant is celebrated for its classic dishes, particularly its pasta. Standouts include the orecchiette with salsiccia and broccoli rabe, spaghetti pomodoro, and cacio e pepe rice balls. While many dishes are highly praised for their execution and flavor, one comment noted a past negative experience, though this was countered by other diners who found the food consistently good.
"The orecchiette with salsiccia and broccoli rabe is frequently mentioned as a standout dish, as are the cacio e pepe rice balls and meatballs in sugo. Spiadini is also noted as a favorite 'anti-signature' dish."
Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, frequently recommending it for its Italian dishes and pleasant atmosphere. While most feedback is favorable, there are isolated comments suggesting it might be overpriced or that not all meals have been consistently outstanding.
Important Note
One commenter suggested that the restaurant might be overpriced for its location, and another user reported never having had a good meal there across three visits.
"Responding to a recommendation for Cafe Spaghetti, this user noted it looks 'chef elevated' and will add it to their rotation."
Positive"This user recommended Cafe Spaghetti in Cobble Hill, advising against Marco Polo and describing Cafe Spaghetti as more chef-elevated than a traditional red-sauce joint."
Positive"Cafe Spaghetti is mentioned as having spumoni and is described as an incredible restaurant overall."
Positive"This user recommended Cafe Spaghetti or Frankie's Spuntino in Brooklyn."
Positive"Spiadini at Cafe Spaghetti is listed as an 'anti-signature' favorite dish."
Positive"Cafe Spaghetti was recommended as a dining option."
Positive"This user noted that Cafe Spaghetti is a popular spot that books out a month in advance and suggested using the Resy standby list."
Positive"Cafe Spaghetti was recommended as a great Italian restaurant option."
Positive"Cafe Spaghetti was recommended as a good option."
Positive"The user collects matchbooks from various NYC restaurants and Cafe Spaghetti is one of them."
Neutral"This user enjoys Cafe Spaghetti, describing it as consistently serving solid red sauce Italian dishes in a chill atmosphere."
Positive"Cafe Spaghetti is suggested as a potential place for seasonal pasta specials."
Positive"This restaurant was simply listed as a suggestion for lunch."
Neutral"This establishment was recommended as a red sauce joint similar to Bamonte's."
Neutral"Cafe Spaghetti is suggested as a perfect Italian restaurant for families with kids."
Positive"Cafe Spaghetti is recommended as a place that takes reservations for solo outdoor diners."
Neutral"Cafe Spaghetti in Carroll Gardens was mentioned as a place with good outdoor seating."
Neutral"The user recommends this restaurant as a great option for weekday dining, suitable for the original poster's request for places that are hard to get into on weekends."
Positive"The commenter personally liked this restaurant for pasta."
Positive
