TLDR
Consistently stellar American fare w/ amazing pasta & a cult-favorite sticky date cake. A go-to for many, beloved for years.
Details
A long-standing favorite in Brooklyn, this American restaurant has consistently impressed diners for over a decade. It's celebrated for its delicious pasta dishes and a standout sticky date cake that has garnered a loyal following. While the food is generally highly praised, some patrons note that the menu could benefit from more frequent updates or specials to keep things fresh.
Caveats
One long-time patron mentioned that the menu has lacked evolution over 14 years and suggested a desire for daily or weekly specials.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About COLONIE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Dinner Suggestions Cobble Hillish Area
"The original poster was looking for dinner suggestions in the Cobble Hill area and mentioned Colonie as a place they had wanted to go to."
NeutralFrom post: Best Bite You Had In 2025
"The sticky date cake at Colonie (RIP) was mentioned as a 'real version' compared to Le Bernardin's lobster."
PositiveFrom post: Watching Cookingkitchen From The Bar
"Colonie in Brooklyn is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Good Spots In West Bk That Take Walk Ins
"Colonie was included in a list of recommendations."
PositiveFrom post: Best Turkish Eggs
"This user simply mentioned Colonie as a place for Turkish eggs."
PositiveFrom post: Best Turkish Eggs
"This user recommended Colonie in Brooklyn Heights for Turkish eggs."
PositiveFrom post: Help Choosing Birthday Dinner Spots In Wburg Or
"The commenter expressed enjoyment of their recent dinner experience at Colonie."
PositiveFrom post: Help Choosing Birthday Dinner Spots In Wburg Or
"This commenter stated that Colonie is good but hasn't been the same since a previous chef left. They also gave a negative review for River Deli and recommended alBadawi as a great birthday spot."
PositiveFrom post: Help Choosing Birthday Dinner Spots In Wburg Or
"This commenter found Colonie to be a solid choice. They also recommended Chama Mama in BK Heights, noting impressive food and service that feels reasonably priced despite not being a bargain."
PositiveFrom post: Pretty Or Coolest Neighborhood In Manhatten For
"Colonie is one of several restaurants located on Atlantic Ave in Brooklyn Heights."
NeutralFrom post: Best Restaurants To Try In Brooklyn Queens
"Colonie was recommended as a place to try by a user."
PositiveFrom post: Weekday Brunch Spot Within Walking Distance Of
"A user clarified that Colonie only serves brunch on weekends, which is important context for the original poster's weekday request."
NeutralFrom post: Weekday Brunch Spot Within Walking Distance Of
"A user highly praised Colonie on Atlantic Avenue, stating their Turkish Eggs would be part of their dying meal."
PositiveFrom post: What Brooklyn Restaurant Wowd You Recently
"User stated Colonie is consistently amazing."
PositiveFrom post: What Brooklyn Restaurant Wowd You Recently
"User described Colonie as stellar and consistently excellent for 14 years, having dined there around 50 times. Their only critique is the menu's lack of evolution and wished for daily/weekly specials."
PositiveFrom post: What Brooklyn Restaurant Wowd You Recently
"User expressed surprise Colonie wasn't mentioned more, calling it the best by far among many restaurants they've tried."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Restaurants To Get Just Desserts In
"Expresses love for the sticky date cake at Colonie, highlighting it as a favorite dessert."
PositiveFrom post: Can Yall Weigh In On The List I Made For
"Reiterates that Colonie is their favorite restaurant even after visiting many top spots, and mentions that everyone they bring there loves it."
PositiveFrom post: Can Yall Weigh In On The List I Made For
"Expresses strong positive sentiment for Colonie, noting they love the place and are surprised it's not mentioned more often."
PositiveFrom post: Can Yall Weigh In On The List I Made For
"Recommends Colonie in Brooklyn as a favorite restaurant, suggesting it as a good fallback option if other reservations are hard to get. They state it's their favorite among top spots and everyone they take there loves it."
Positive