Next.js logo

AMORE PIZZA CAFFE

Updated

Phone: (201) 232-2491

Address: 370 WEST 58 STREET 10019

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Nostalgic, classic NY pizza near Columbus Circle. Beloved for traditional pies and a taste of childhood.

Reddit Sentiment for AMORE PIZZA CAFFE(based on 4 Reddit opinions)

100% Positive

Tags

italian 3new york 3pizza 4View All

Neighborhoods

Hell's Kitchen

Details

A long-standing pizza joint near Columbus Circle, this spot is a local favorite reminiscent of childhood favorites. It's lauded for its traditional New York-style pizza, with one patron specifically mentioning a fondness for their 'deluxe stuff'.

Food Overview

This establishment serves classic New York-style pizza and is praised for its traditional approach. One reviewer specifically mentioned enjoying the 'deluxe stuff'.

Highlights / Recommended

"The 'deluxe stuff' has been specifically mentioned as a favorite by a satisfied customer."

Customer Sentiment

Customers express strong positive sentiment, with many reminiscing about it being a childhood favorite and a reliable local option.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About AMORE PIZZA CAFFE

Best Pizza near Columbus Circle
This post highlights Amore Pizza Caffe as a popular and good option just a block or two from Columbus Circle, with multiple users expressing support for the restaurant.
Old school vs new school NYC pizza
A commenter highly praises Amore Pizza Caffe, comparing it favorably to their childhood pizza and other recently tried places.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Old School Vs New School Nyc Pizza

"Amoré in Flushing is highly praised, reminding the commenter of their childhood pizza and being preferred over most recently tried pizza places."

Positive
Dec 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle

"This comment is another vote of support for Amore."

Positive
Oct 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle

"This user is a big fan of Amore and likes their 'deluxe stuff'."

Positive
Oct 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle

"Amore was popular when this user lived in the area and is described as a good option just a block or two from Columbus Circle."

Positive
Oct 26, 2025View Comment →

More in Hell's Kitchen

See all

More italian in NYC

See all