Unassuming Tribeca spot serving up a classic, unhyped pizza slice that locals want to keep secret.
This Tribeca gem is a celebrated spot for authentic Italian-American cuisine, particularly its pizza, which many describe as a standout classic slice. It's the kind of unhyped neighborhood establishment that locals cherish and wish to keep somewhat under wraps.
Known for its excellent classic pizza slices and Italian-American dishes like eggplant parm, this restaurant is a cherished, unhyped neighborhood gem.
"The classic pizza slice is frequently highlighted as a must-try, with eggplant parm also receiving a positive mention."
Customers rave about the authentic Italian-American fare, especially the pizza, viewing it as a beloved neighborhood secret.
Important Note
One user expressed a desire to keep the restaurant somewhat secret, implying it's a hidden gem they don't want to become too popular.
"This user recommended il Mattone on Beach Street for pizza."
Positive"Recommends Il Mattone for an excellent classic slice, located near L'Industrie."
Positive"This user listed Il mattone as a potential option for cheap eats."
Neutral"A commenter recalled getting eggplant parm from Il Mattone during late nights at the office pre-COVID."
Positive"User expresses a desire to keep Il Mattone somewhat secret, implying it's a valued spot they don't want overrun by reviewers."
Positive"A commenter shouted out Il Mattone in Tribeca as an unmentioned spot fitting the theme of good neighborhood pizza."
Positive
