Next.js logo

THE ONION TREE PIZZA CO.

Updated

Phone: (516) 633-7240

Address: 214 1 AVENUE 10009

TLDR

An inventive fusion of Neapolitan-style pizza topped with authentic Indian flavors, formerly a go-to for East Village foodies.

Reddit Sentiment for THE ONION TREE PIZZA CO.(based on 25 Reddit opinions)

40% Positive24% Neutral36% Negative

Tags

indian 16neapolitan 12pizza 2pizza 22chaat 2View All

Neighborhoods

East Village

Instagram Posts References

The Onion Tree Pizza Co. has closed its doors. The restaurant was located on the southeast corner of 13th Street and 1st Avenue. This closure was reported as part of a series of business closures in the Gramercy, Union Square, and Flatiron districts of New York City.

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
Eater’s Guide to All the New York City Restaurants, Bars, and Cafes That Closed in February 2026

Eater • Date unknown

Details

Known for a pioneering fusion of traditional Neapolitan pizza and bold Indian spices, this spot offered a unique culinary experience in the East Village [1]. Fans frequently praised the high-quality crust and innovative toppings [2], though it unfortunately ceased operations in early 2026 after two years in Manhattan [3]. Its original flagship location in Long Island remains open for those looking to experience its distinct flavor profiles [3].

Food Overview

The restaurant specialized in Indian-Italian fusion, gaining recognition for its Masala Neapolitan pizza and burrata chaat [1], [2]. While the crust was widely lauded, opinions on the toppings were mixed, with some noting a need for more flavor intensity [2].

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally held the establishment in high regard, frequently mourning its closure and praising the staff and atmosphere [2]. While the majority of feedback was positive, some diners felt that while the crust was excellent, the toppings occasionally lacked sufficient depth of flavor [2].

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    burrata chaat
    3 mentions

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About THE ONION TREE PIZZA CO.

This thread serves as a comprehensive hub for the community to discuss the restaurant's unique fusion concept, share favorite dishes, and express sadness over its recent closure.
This post highlights specific menu favorites such as the chicken tikka pizza and burrata chaat, showcasing the restaurant's fusion identity.
A enthusiastic recommendation of the Masala Neapolitan pizza, identifying it as one of the most unique and delicious dining experiences of the year.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Anywhere To Get Curry Pizza Google Maps Yielded

"A follow-up comment stated that Onion Tree Pizza Company recently closed."

Negative
Jun 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Anywhere To Get Curry Pizza Google Maps Yielded

"This user recommended Onion Tree Pizza Company in the East Village for curry pizza."

Neutral
Jun 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Do Indians Like To Get Their Indian Food

"This user clarifies that The Onion Tree Pizza is only in Long Island, sharing a link."

Neutral
Mar 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Do Indians Like To Get Their Indian Food

"This user questions when The Onion Tree Pizza shut down, as they believe it's still open in the East Village."

Neutral
Mar 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Do Indians Like To Get Their Indian Food

"This user used to love The Onion Tree Pizza but was bummed to see they shut down."

Negative
Mar 14, 2026View Comment →

More in East Village

See all

More Indian in NYC

See all