TLDR
An inventive fusion of Neapolitan-style pizza topped with authentic Indian flavors, formerly a go-to for East Village foodies.
Reddit Sentiment for THE ONION TREE PIZZA CO.(based on 25 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The Onion Tree Pizza Co. has closed its doors. The restaurant was located on the southeast corner of 13th Street and 1st Avenue. This closure was reported as part of a series of business closures in the Gramercy, Union Square, and Flatiron districts of New York City.
Details
Known for a pioneering fusion of traditional Neapolitan pizza and bold Indian spices, this spot offered a unique culinary experience in the East Village [1]. Fans frequently praised the high-quality crust and innovative toppings [2], though it unfortunately ceased operations in early 2026 after two years in Manhattan [3]. Its original flagship location in Long Island remains open for those looking to experience its distinct flavor profiles [3].
Customer Sentiment
Customers generally held the establishment in high regard, frequently mourning its closure and praising the staff and atmosphere [2]. While the majority of feedback was positive, some diners felt that while the crust was excellent, the toppings occasionally lacked sufficient depth of flavor [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE ONION TREE PIZZA CO.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Anywhere To Get Curry Pizza Google Maps Yielded
"A follow-up comment stated that Onion Tree Pizza Company recently closed."
NegativeFrom post: Anywhere To Get Curry Pizza Google Maps Yielded
"This user recommended Onion Tree Pizza Company in the East Village for curry pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Where Do Indians Like To Get Their Indian Food
"This user clarifies that The Onion Tree Pizza is only in Long Island, sharing a link."
NeutralFrom post: Where Do Indians Like To Get Their Indian Food
"This user questions when The Onion Tree Pizza shut down, as they believe it's still open in the East Village."
NeutralFrom post: Where Do Indians Like To Get Their Indian Food
"This user used to love The Onion Tree Pizza but was bummed to see they shut down."
NegativeFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Best Spicy Fried Chicken
"This user mentioned that Onion Tree Pizza did a pop-up fried chicken place which was the best they'd had in the city, but unsure if it's still operating."
PositiveFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter expressed their fondness for the restaurant upon hearing of its closure."
NegativeFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter is sad about the closure, mentioning they ordered from the restaurant weekly and particularly enjoyed the masala pizza."
NegativeFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"After a recent visit, the commenter rated the experience 7/10, noting that while the pizza crust was great, the toppings lacked flavor, possibly due to insufficient salt or umami."
NeutralFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter expressed disappointment about the closure, stating they had always intended to visit."
NegativeFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter found the restaurant delicious and unique but expensive compared to other pizza options in the city."
NeutralFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter was dismayed by the closure, praising the restaurant's great food, staff, and atmosphere, and hoping the owners would open something else in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter is upset about the closure, noting that they frequently recommended this restaurant to out-of-town visitors."
NegativeFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter enjoyed the restaurant, noting its unique concept and good execution, but observed that it was often empty, which is unfortunate."
PositiveFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"This commenter noted that the Onion Tree in Sea Cliff (Long Island) is worth visiting for those in that area."
PositiveFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter expressed sadness upon hearing the news of the restaurant's closure and thanked the original poster for sharing."
NegativeFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter expressed sadness about the closure of this unique restaurant."
NegativeFrom post: Onion Tree Pizza Co Neapolitanindian Fusion In
"The commenter shared previous positive experiences and linked to posts highlighting the restaurant's excellent Neapolitan pizza base and fusion Indian concept. They specifically mentioned the burrata chaat as appealing."
PositiveFrom post: Indian Pizza Desi Pizza Bites
"This user highly recommends The Onion Tree's Masala Neapolitan pizza, calling it one of the most unique and delicious pizzas they had last year."
PositiveFrom post: Date Rec Btw Tribeca And Union Square
"The user listed The Onion Tree Pizza Co. as one of their recent restaurant wins."
Positive