TLDR
Exceptional sommelier-led wine program paired with hit-or-miss menu items. Unique destination for adventurous diners and wine lovers.
Instagram Posts References
Herald Haus is a new indoor stall at Macy's Holiday Square, located on 36th Street. It's described as a warm and inviting space with cute decor and high tops for seating. The stall serves German food and cocktails, making it a comfortable spot to enjoy a break from the outdoor market.
Details
Renowned for its exceptional wine list and knowledgeable sommeliers, this establishment attracts diners looking for a sophisticated, bottle-forward experience [1], [2]. While the menu features standouts like celtuce, pasta, and unique sticky toffee pudding, it is noted for being somewhat inconsistent across the board [4], [8]. Despite having earned a James Beard award, some patrons find the overall experience fails to meet their expectations [7].
Food Overview
The menu highlights include refreshing vegetable and root vinegar preparations, celtuce, and well-regarded pasta dishes [6], [8]. Guests particularly recommend the eight treasure sticky toffee pudding, though some diners have reported inconsistency in the overall menu quality [4], [8], [9].
Caveats
Some visitors report inconsistency in the menu and do not plan to return without significant updates [8], [9].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CRUMBL
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Are Some Unusual Things That Restaurants In
"The user agrees there are misses on the menu and does not plan to return."
NegativeFrom post: What Are Some Unusual Things That Restaurants In
"The user believes the menu overall is not consistent, though they enjoyed the celtuce, pasta, and wine selection. They do not plan to return without menu updates."
NeutralFrom post: What Are Some Unusual Things That Restaurants In
"The user felt the experience was mediocre and was surprised by the restaurant's James Beard award."
NegativeFrom post: What Are Some Unusual Things That Restaurants In
"The restaurant features refreshing vegetable and root vinegar dishes. It has a specific dish involving jelly that is quite tasty."
PositiveFrom post: On The Hunt For Warm And Gooey Desserts With Ice
"The eight treasure sticky toffee pudding is a specific dessert mentioned."
Positive