Solid bagels & pork roll sandwiches in Midtown. Go-to for a classic NYC breakfast.
This Midtown Manhattan bagel spot is a go-to for a solid, well-made bagel. While some may find the ordering process a bit chaotic, the quality of the bagels, including options like the bagel and lox, is frequently praised. They are also known for their pork roll sandwiches, which can be customized to your liking.
The bagels at this establishment are consistently praised as being solid and well-made. The pork roll sandwich is a point of discussion, with some enjoying it and others having specific preferences for its preparation. The bagel and lox also received a positive rating.
"The bagels, including the bagel and lox, are highly recommended. The pork roll sandwich is also a popular choice, with the ability to customize ingredients."
Customers generally agree that the bagels are well-made and a highlight, though the ordering process can be a bit chaotic. There's a specific debate around their pork roll sandwich preparation.
Important Note
The ordering process can be chaotic. There's a specific preference variation for the pork roll sandwich preparation.
"The bagel and lox from Liberty Bagels was rated 8/10 and found to be nice, though the ordering process was described as chaotic."
Positive"Responding to a user's complaint about Liberty Bagels' preparation, this user advised that the restaurant can make the sandwich as requested without the unwanted ingredients."
Positive"This user found that Liberty Bagels ruins pork roll sandwiches by adding mayo, lettuce, and tomato, and they prefer just egg, cheese, and pork roll with salt, pepper, and ketchup."
Negative"This user recommended Liberty Bagels for pork roll and stated they correctly call it Taylor ham. They later edited to note they received downvotes for their comment."
Neutral"The Bagel Shop is listed as one of the best bagel options on the Upper East Side. This recommendation is part of a broader list of bakery suggestions."
Positive"Liberty Bagel is noted for making a solid bagel."
Positive"The commenter suggests Best Bagels on 36th in Midtown West for superior bagels compared to Russ and Daughters, depending on whether one prioritizes bagels or smoked fish."
Positive
