Top-tier bagels w/ great variety. Expect a busy spot known for its superior dough.
This establishment is celebrated for its exceptional bagels, which are considered a top contender in the city. While the bagels themselves receive high praise, opinions on specific sandwich preparations, like the pork roll, can vary. Some appreciate the traditional approach, while others have preferences for simpler or more customized ingredients.
This restaurant is highly regarded for its outstanding bagels, frequently cited as among the city's best. While the quality of the bagels is consistently praised, there are divided opinions on sandwich constructions. Some users have strong preferences regarding the addition of ingredients like mayonnaise, lettuce, and tomato, with one user noting that the restaurant can accommodate requests for simpler preparations.
"The bagels are consistently highlighted as a must-try item. While specific sandwich recommendations are less clear, the quality of the base product, the bagel, is universally praised."
Customers generally praise the quality of the bagels, calling them some of the best in the city. However, there are mixed opinions on specific sandwich preparations, with some finding them less ideal.
Important Note
Opinions on sandwich customizations, particularly for items like the pork roll, can vary, with some customers preferring simpler preparations.
"Responding to a user's complaint about Liberty Bagels' preparation, this user advised that the restaurant can make the sandwich as requested without the unwanted ingredients."
Positive"This user found that Liberty Bagels ruins pork roll sandwiches by adding mayo, lettuce, and tomato, and they prefer just egg, cheese, and pork roll with salt, pepper, and ketchup."
Negative"This user recommended Liberty Bagels for pork roll and stated they correctly call it Taylor ham. They later edited to note they received downvotes for their comment."
Neutral"The Bagel Shop is listed as one of the best bagel options on the Upper East Side. This recommendation is part of a broader list of bakery suggestions."
Positive"Liberty Bagel is noted for making a solid bagel."
Positive"The commenter suggests Best Bagels on 36th in Midtown West for superior bagels compared to Russ and Daughters, depending on whether one prioritizes bagels or smoked fish."
Positive
