TLDR
Iconic, no-frills East Harlem bakery famous for dense, moist carrot cake and velvety, sweet red velvet slices.
Reddit Sentiment for LLOYD'S CARROT CAKE(based on 43 Reddit opinions)
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Lloyd's Carrot Cake, an East Harlem bakery famous for its dense, moist carrot cake with tangy cream cheese frosting. The article praises their red velvet cake and the bakery's iconic status in NYC.
Details
Established in 1986, this iconic East Harlem bakery is celebrated for its dense, moist carrot cake, a family recipe featuring twice-grated carrots and a tangy cream cheese frosting [1]. While the signature dessert remains a local staple, the bakery is also highly regarded for its soft-crumbed red velvet cake [1]. The small, utilitarian storefront focuses purely on its baked goods, lacking formal seating while offering a variety of customizable cake options [1].
Food Overview
The bakery specializes in American-style desserts, with the signature carrot cake receiving widespread acclaim for its flavor profile, especially when ordered with nuts and raisins for added texture [1], [2]. While the carrot cake is the primary draw, customers often recommend the red velvet cake as an exceptional alternative [1], [2]. Some negative reviews point to an imbalance in the frosting-to-cake ratio or a lack of desired cream cheese tang [2].
Customer Sentiment
Customer feedback is sharply polarized; many patrons consider it the best in the city and a transformative experience for non-carrot cake eaters, while others criticize the cakes for being dry or having overly sweet frosting [2]. Some visitors have noted the establishment's 'B' health rating as a factor in their impression of the business [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LLOYD'S CARROT CAKE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Trendypopular Coffee Shopdessert Spot Did
"They love the cake and didn't find it too dry."
PositiveFrom post: Bakerycake Shop Recos Within Manhattan Where I
"Recommended as a potential bakery choice."
PositiveFrom post: What Trendypopular Coffee Shopdessert Spot Did
"The plain cake is meh, but the carrot cake with nuts and raisins is much better."
NeutralFrom post: What Trendypopular Coffee Shopdessert Spot Did
"A slice was terrible due to buttercream frosting, but the whole cake was great."
NeutralFrom post: What Trendypopular Coffee Shopdessert Spot Did
"Thought there was too much frosting."
Negative