TLDR
Iconic 1933 East Harlem coal-oven institution, famous for legendary thin-crust slices and old-school NYC charm.
Reddit Sentiment for PATSY'S PIZZERIA(based on 86 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Patsy's Pizzeria is celebrated for offering one of the reviewer's favorite pizza slices in New York City. The pizza is particularly noted for its incredibly thin crust and generously oozing cheese, signifying a classic and high-quality slice. The restaurant even had a celebrity encounter, with Owen Wilson apparently wanting a slice.
Details
Established in 1933, this historic East Harlem landmark remains a quintessential New York City destination for coal-fired pizza [1]. Visitors can enjoy an old-school atmosphere featuring dark wood and tile, with many noting it as a top-tier slice experience that has stood the test of time [1][2]. While fans celebrate its consistency and classic appeal, diners often note that the experience can vary depending on whether one chooses the quick-service window or the traditional sit-down dining room [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic New York-style Italian fare, with a primary emphasis on thin-crust, coal-fired pies and slices that are widely regarded as among the best in the city [2][4]. The establishment is also praised for its excellent meatballs and red-sauce dishes [5][6]. While the pizza is highly acclaimed, some diners suggest that the pies do not travel well for takeout, and it is recommended to enjoy them fresh to ensure the best quality [3][7].
Patrons overwhelmingly view this establishment as a top-tier, classic pizza destination with a nostalgic atmosphere [2][4]. While many adore the historic charm, some guests debate the consistency between the counter service and the sit-down experience, occasionally noting issues with pizza texture [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PATSY'S PIZZERIA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Pizza Options For A Group Of 25 In A Week And A
"The original location at 117th is praised as having some of the best slices and a great red sauce menu."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza On The Upper East Side Just Moved To
"Noted that the original location's pizza does not travel well."
NeutralFrom post: Best Pizza On The Upper East Side Just Moved To
"Mentioned as a pizza spot in East Harlem."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Simple Delicious Meatballs Of Any
"Recommended for having great meatballs, noting that good pizzerias often produce excellent versions of the dish."
PositiveFrom post: Since When Did Joes Pizza Increase To 57 A Slice
"The user highlights getting a perfect, inexpensive pie here, considering it superior to Joe's."
Positive