Next.js logo

PATSY'S PIZZERIA

Updated

Phone: (212) 534-9783

Address: 2289 1 AVENUE 10035

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Historic 1933 coal-fired gem in East Harlem. Legendary thin-crust slices and classic old-school atmosphere that defines the quintessential NYC pizza experience.

Reddit Sentiment for PATSY'S PIZZERIA(based on 109 Reddit opinions)

61% Positive28% Neutral11% Negative

Tags

italian 93new york style 44new york italian 18pizza 93slices 6slice 2View All

Neighborhoods

East Harlem

Instagram Posts References

Patsy's Pizzeria is celebrated for offering one of the reviewer's favorite pizza slices in New York City. The pizza is particularly noted for its incredibly thin crust and generously oozing cheese, signifying a classic and high-quality slice. The restaurant even had a celebrity encounter, with Owen Wilson apparently wanting a slice.

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
El Barrio Restaurants: All The Best Spots In East Harlem
positive

Patsy's, a historic pizzeria in East Harlem since 1933, serves classic New York slices and pies in a timeless setting, adorned with photos of its past and famous patrons.

Neha Talreja • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Established in 1933, this historic East Harlem landmark remains a quintessential New York City institution famous for its authentic, coal-fired pizza [1], [2]. The atmosphere feels perfectly preserved in time, featuring classic dark wood and tile interiors that transport diners to a bygone era [1]. While enthusiasts frequently debate the nuances between the convenient takeout window and the full sit-down service, the restaurant is widely celebrated as one of the best spots for a classic NY-style slice [2], [3].

Food Overview

This institution is renowned for its classic coal-fired pies and slices, often highlighted for their savory, crunchy crusts [2], [3]. Diners also highly recommend the meatballs [5], while the 'Patsy's Special' is frequently cited as a standout, must-try dish [2], [3].

Highlights / Recommended

"The 'Patsy's Special' is frequently identified as a top-tier signature pie [2], [3]. Additionally, the meatballs are highly recommended by regulars [5]."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • •pizza(2)

Customer Sentiment

Overall feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with many diners praising the iconic, high-quality pizza and nostalgic charm [2], [3]. While some customers note inconsistency between the takeout and sit-down experiences, it remains a top-tier recommendation for pizza lovers [3], [4].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About PATSY'S PIZZERIA

Patsy's Harlem
The original poster and various community members praise this location as a top-tier, classic New York pizza institution that is well worth a visit.
Did anyone else go to Patsy's after watching a Quiet Place: Day One?
This thread captures the resurgence in interest for the restaurant following its appearance in a major film, with many sharing their positive experiences with the 'Patsy's Special'.
Original Patsy's: Sit down or counter slice?
An informative discussion regarding the best way to experience the pizza, debating the differences between the takeout window and the sit-down dining room.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Looking For Simple Delicious Meatballs Of Any

"Recommended for having great meatballs, noting that good pizzerias often produce excellent versions of the dish."

Positive
Jul 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Since When Did Joes Pizza Increase To 57 A Slice

"The user highlights getting a perfect, inexpensive pie here, considering it superior to Joe's."

Positive
Jul 6, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For Pizza Tonight For Family Of 5 Would

"Patsy's in East Harlem was suggested as a pizza option."

Neutral
Jun 27, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Bagel Or Slice Near Saint John The Divine

"Patsy's in East Harlem is recommended as an alternative to Mama's Too for a first-time visitor, especially if ordering a pie ahead of time to eat in the car. It is cash only."

Positive
May 2, 2026View Comment →

From post: Iconic Foods In Nyc

"Mentions Patsy's pizza is cash only and nearby Blue Sky Deli."

Neutral
Apr 16, 2026View Comment →

More in East Harlem

See all

More Italian in NYC

See all