Old-school titan of NY pizza, famed for its thin, coal-fired pies and classic slices.
This classic pizzeria is a beloved spot for its traditional Italian-American pizzas, particularly its thin, coal-fired pies. Many patrons consider it a go-to for an authentic New York slice, with some even touting it as the best in the city. It's a place that evokes nostalgia and a sense of timeless quality, making it a must-visit for pizza aficionados.
The pizza here is a standout, with many Redditors highlighting its thin crust and coal-fired preparation. It's frequently cited as one of the best New York slices available, with some even recommending it as the 'Greatest Of All Time'. The 'Patsy's Special' is also mentioned positively for its savory and crunchy texture.
"The coal-fired pizzas, particularly the thin crust varieties and the 'Patsy's Special', are highly recommended. The restaurant is also noted for offering excellent New York-style slices."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, often calling it the best in NYC. Some note that the original East Harlem location is the most authentic, though other branches are also appreciated.
Important Note
One commenter suggests that only the original East Harlem location is truly authentic, and other branches may simply be licensing the name without matching the quality. Another user noted a decline in quality at one location after COVID.
"Responding to a question about dine-in pies, this user stated that dine-in pies are made by the same oven and people as the slices. They also mentioned they go to Patsy's simply for being nearby."
Positive"This user had not been to Patsy's but hoped the original poster had a good experience."
Neutral"This user ordered Patsy's and was underwhelmed, noting the pizza was delivered lukewarm with a cardboard-like crust and bland cheese."
Negative"This user has never been to Patsy's but found the pizza pictured in the post to look very appealing."
Positive"This user coincidentally had Patsy's pizza on the same day they watched the movie."
Positive"This user was unaware of the movie connection but was inspired to plan an itinerary of Harlem activities."
Neutral"This user discovered that Patsy's has a takeout window and mentioned a very negative experience at Uncle Vinny's Pizza, which they visited instead."
Neutral"This user commented that every restaurant in NYC has rats."
Neutral"This user used to get slices from the takeout window at the Harlem location, finding the sauce vibrant and crust good on good days, though slices were inconsistent. They asked if dine-in pies taste different."
Neutral"This user stated that even the Midtown East location of Patsy's is great."
Positive"Responding to a comment about other locations, this user expressed liking the other two Patsy's locations, finding them similar to the now-closed Angelo's 2nd Avenue."
Positive"This user considers Patsy's among their top 3 pizza places and finds it odd that the 'Patsy special' is exclusive to the East Harlem joint."
Positive"This user humorously added that it wouldn't be the 'real special' unless one arrived on foot from Chinatown and walked back to the seaport."
Neutral"This user planned to order the 'quiet place special' and report back on their experience."
Neutral"This user had Patsy's pizza over the weekend and found it amazing, even when eaten cold."
Positive"This user typically passes by the Upper East Side location but prioritizes visiting the Harlem location first. They later clarified that they were referring to Patsy's Italian Restaurant, not the pizza place."
Neutral"This user stated that the East Harlem location is the only authentic one, with other locations merely licensing the name and not matching the quality."
Negative"This user had a slice from the Harlem location earlier in the summer and found it to be solid."
Positive"This user had not gone to Patsy's because of the movie but thought it was a good idea."
Neutral"This user used to frequent the 60th street location before COVID but felt the quality declined afterward."
Negative
