Coal-fired, thin-crust pizza perfection. A true NYC classic w/ a history stretching back to '33.
This East Harlem institution is a true old-school titan of New York pizza, celebrated for its thin-crust, coal-fired pies. With a history dating back to 1933, it's a place that champions simplicity and quality. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice from the takeout window or enjoying a full pie in the adjacent sit-down restaurant, Patsy's delivers a classic New York pizza experience that has earned it a loyal following and a spot in the hearts of pizza aficionados.
Patsy's is renowned for its classic New York-style pizza, specifically its thin, coal-fired crust and flavorful toppings. Many consider it a must-try for pizza lovers, with particular emphasis on the East Harlem location's authenticity. While overwhelmingly positive, one review mentioned a less satisfying experience with a lukewarm pizza and cardboard-like crust.
"Patsy's is most highly recommended for its classic, thin-crust, coal-fired pizza, with the 'Patsy Special' and 'vodka pie with pepperoni' being specifically praised. The fried zucchini is also noted as a good appetizer."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the classic, thin-crust, coal-fired pizza, often referring to it as the best in NYC. There's a strong sentiment that the East Harlem location is the authentic original, with some debate about the quality of other branches.
Important Note
There's a recurring discussion about whether the East Harlem location is the only authentic Patsy's, with some users suggesting other locations are 'knockoffs' and may have different crust thickness.
"The commenter simply stated 'Ubereats bogo', possibly referring to a promotion for Patsy's."
Neutral"The author stated they will try the fried zucchini next time."
Positive"The author expressed that the food in NYC is a blessing."
Positive"The author responded to a comment about a slice's appearance by saying they bet it tasted good and that they always hear great things about Patsy's."
Positive"The author expressed excitement, calling the pizza a 'dream'."
Positive"In response to a comment about the pizza's appearance, the author admitted it wasn't aesthetically ideal but still tasted great."
Positive"The author humorously commented on the appearance of a slice in a picture, but acknowledged hearing great things about Patsy's."
Neutral"The author shared that Patsy's was their go-to for office events when they first moved to NYC and still holds a special place in their heart for its classic NY style pizza."
Positive"The author praised Patsy's and commented on the abundance of great pizza in NYC, considering living there a blessing for pizza lovers."
Positive"The author stated that it is not far for them, implying convenience in visiting Patsy's."
Positive"The author expressed nostalgia for Patsy's, mentioning it used to be their local spot and that they miss it."
Positive"The author agrees that Patsy's used to be better and while still good, it's not quite what they remember from years ago."
Neutral"The author states that Patsy's is the best and also mentions that they have excellent fried zucchini."
Positive"The author mentioned that driving out to Patsy's fries their nerves."
Negative"The commenter reminisced about their father getting a pie from Patsy's every Friday, specifying the location as Second Ave and 117 St."
Positive"The author simply states that Patsy's is great."
Positive"The author used to frequently eat pizza from Patsy's when working nearby and still makes an effort to visit when in the area."
Positive"The commenter advised against driving in Manhattan."
Negative"The author has only visited the Harlem location and states that it consistently meets expectations."
Positive"The commenter wished the other user "Buon appetito" in response to their plan to visit Patsy's."
Positive
