All-bar seating seafood haven w/ oysters that'll blow your mind. Great wine list & service.
This Manhattan establishment is a celebrated spot for seafood lovers, with many praising their oyster selection as the best they've ever had. The restaurant is noted for its inviting atmosphere, particularly its all-bar seating, which makes it accessible for solo diners and those seeking a more interactive experience. It's also recognized for excellent service and a great wine list, with some even suggesting it rivals high-end seafood destinations.
The restaurant is highly acclaimed for its seafood, with many singling out the oysters as exceptionally good, some even calling them the best they've ever had. Razor clams are also recommended, and the general consensus is that all seafood dishes are expertly prepared. While most feedback is positive, one reviewer found the portions small for the price, and another felt the food wasn't unique enough to justify the cost.
"The oysters are frequently highlighted as exceptional, with some calling them the best ever. Razor clams are also specifically recommended, and general praise is given to the overall seafood selection."
Overall, customers express high satisfaction, particularly with the exceptional seafood, especially oysters, and the quality of service. Some note it's a bit pricey for the portion sizes, but generally, the experience is considered outstanding.
Important Note
One reviewer found the price to portion ratio to be unfavorable, and another felt the food lacked sufficient uniqueness to justify the high cost. There was also a mention of it being closed for a specific week.
"Penny is suggested as a seafood dining option."
Positive"This is listed as a recommendation."
Neutral"This restaurant is listed as a repeat spot."
Positive"The user recommended Penny as a potential dining option."
Positive"This user recommends Penny for its delicious food, great service, and accommodating nature towards gluten-free diets. They also note it has a great wine list."
Positive"This commenter has a negative view of Penny, criticizing the service, materials used for plating, and the overall atmosphere, comparing it unfavorably to more established restaurants."
Negative"Penny is liked for its top-notch lighting, interactive bar seating, and seafood selection, making it ideal for summer."
Positive"Penny is suggested because it exclusively offers bar seating, making it easy for solo diners to get a spot."
Positive"Penny is mentioned as a restaurant."
Neutral"The user suggests Penny as a recommendation."
Positive"This user loves Penny and compares it to Le Bernardin, stating both offer different yet equally wonderful dining experiences."
Positive"This user noted that Penny, along with Bridges and Borgo, are all new restaurants."
Neutral"Penny is suggested for those who enjoy seafood, but unfortunately, it is closed for the current week."
Neutral"This user recommends Penny as a suitable option for the casual fine dining request."
Positive
