A beloved East Village institution serving classic Italian pastries & desserts since the 1890s.
Step into a piece of New York's history at this beloved East Village Italian bakery, a true institution since the 1890s. It's a place where nostalgia meets delicious tradition, offering a delightful escape with its old-school charm and extensive selection of classic Italian pastries and cakes. From their highly acclaimed cheesecakes to beloved strawberry shortcake and a wide variety of cookies, there's a treat to satisfy every sweet tooth, making it a quintessential stop for dessert lovers.
Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe is celebrated as an iconic Italian bakery, renowned for its wide array of traditional Italian pastries and desserts. Customers frequently recommend the New York cheesecake, strawberry shortcake, tiramisu cake, and various cookies, noting their high quality and classic preparation. While most feedback is positive, a few reviewers found specific items like sfogliatelle to be less appealing, though this is largely attributed to personal preference for different styles of Italian pastries.
"Customers frequently rave about the New York cheesecake, strawberry shortcake, tiramisu cake, Italian rainbow cookies, and chocolate lobster tails. The Oreo cheesecake mounds are also noted as a unique and highly praised item."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the bakery, highlighting its classic Italian charm and consistently delicious desserts, particularly the cheesecakes and strawberry shortcake. While some find certain items like sfogliatelle less impressive, the overall sentiment is highly positive, with many expressing nostalgia and long-standing affection for the establishment.
Important Note
One user found the sfogliatelle to be dense and dry, contrasting with expectations of a lighter filling, though this seems to be a matter of personal preference and not a widespread complaint.
"States the chocolate raspberry cake is incredible, even for someone who isn't a big chocolate person."
Positive"Identified the chocolate cream lobster tail as a miss due to soggy pastry, though the filling was excellent. They prefer Mia's for lobster tails."
Negative"Asserts that Veniero's has the best cheesecake in NYC."
Positive"Responds to a comment questioning Veniero's quality by listing other bakeries but asserting Veniero's is Manhattan's number one, especially their Sicilian cheesecake."
Positive"Veniero's holds a special place due to being their first NYC memory, and they've rarely had a disappointing experience there."
Positive"Finds the chocolate raspberry truffle pretty good, but prefers their strawberry shortcake."
Positive"Recommends trying the Oreo cheesecake 'mounds' sold Thursday to Sunday nights, which are made from leftover cheesecake. The commenter praises the perfect cookie to cheesecake ratio."
Positive"Considers Veniero's a source of nostalgia, with many items being hit or miss, but their cheesecake remains a great comfort food that instantly recalls their first visit to NYC."
Positive"Inquires about the chocolate raspberry cake."
Neutral"This user suggests Veniero's as a pasticceria option for those who don't want to travel to Brooklyn."
Positive"Veniero's is mentioned as a cheesecake option with a heavier style, preferred by the user over Eileen's."
Positive"This commenter praised the sfogliatelle from Veniero's and asked for recommendations for other NYC bakeries with good sfogliatelle."
Positive"The commenter identified the fruit tart as their preferred item from Veniero's, though they noted visiting more for nostalgia than consistent quality."
Positive"The commenter chose cake from Veniero's as their last meal, largely for nostalgic reasons related to their childhood neighborhood bakery."
Positive"This commenter suggests Veniero's for their awesome chocolate cake, available in two sizes."
Positive"Previously frequented Veniero's in the East Village, but Rocco's has been a revelation since moving neighborhoods."
Neutral"Veniero's in lower Manhattan has a great vibe, although Rocco's pastries are preferred."
Neutral"The user recommended Veneiro’s."
Positive"The user states they love Veniero's."
Positive"Veniero's is declared to be the best."
Positive
