Charming East Village bakery w/ viral sweets. Think dessert fairytale!
This East Village bakery is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. It's a charming spot that feels like stepping into a fairytale, serving up a delightful array of pastries, cookies, and cakes. From their renowned chocolate chip cookies with crisp edges and gooey centers to their moist and perfectly spiced carrot cake, every bite is a treat. They also offer unique options like vanilla cake with earl grey frosting and fresh blackberry compote, making it a true gem for dessert lovers.
This bakery specializes in a variety of baked goods, with a strong emphasis on cookies and cakes. The chocolate chip cookie is frequently mentioned and highly praised for its texture and flavor, though some find it too salty or too sweet. The carrot cake also receives consistent acclaim for its moisture and spice. Other popular items include banana bread, choux puffs, and various cakes, with most reviews indicating a very positive reception to the food.
"The chocolate chip cookie and carrot cake are consistently highlighted as must-try items. Other recommended desserts include vanilla cake with earl grey frosting and blackberry compote, banana bread, and choux puffs."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the bakery for its delicious and beautifully crafted desserts, with many highlighting specific items like the chocolate chip cookies and carrot cake as standouts.
Important Note
There are conflicting opinions regarding the chocolate chip cookies, with some finding them too salty or too sweet, and others loving their texture. One review also mentioned dry cakes and chewy icing, and another found the store had an unpleasant odor.
"After purchasing the cookbook, the visit to the bakery was rewarding. The chocolate chip cookie was just okay, but the carrot cake was the star, earning a perfect score of 9."
Positive"This user stated that the carrot cake from Lucie was the best they've ever had, though they hadn't tried the others on the list."
Positive"This user finds the carrot cake from Lucie phenomenal and thinks about it frequently, noting it's not the most traditional but excellent."
Positive"This user listed the carrot cake from Lucie as one of the top 5 best they've had."
Positive"This user listed the carrot cake from Lucie as one of their top 5."
Positive"This user recommended the carrot cake from Lucie."
Positive"This user mentioned that Lucie is planning to add a rhubarb lemonade to their menu soon."
Neutral"For lunch as part of a hypothetical 'day of last meals,' the commenter would get a sweet pastry from Lucie after a pizza slice."
Positive"Responding to a question about salt, this user confirms that From Lucie's cookie had too much salt, even for someone who likes salted desserts."
Negative"This user dislikes overly salted cookies and asks if From Lucie's cookie has too much salt. They prefer salt incorporated into the batter."
Neutral"This user liked the texture of From Lucie's cookie, even though they were not aware of the hype beforehand."
Positive"This user was not a fan of From Lucie's cookie, finding it did not live up to the hype."
Negative"In response to a negative review, this user asks about preferred cookies and notes they didn't find From Lucie's cookie overly sweet."
Neutral"This commenter strongly dislikes From Lucie's cookie, finding everything to taste generic, overly sweet, and designed for Instagram."
Negative"This user also did not enjoy From Lucie's cookie, stating it did not live up to the hype."
Negative"This user and their husband preferred The Pastry Box's cookie over From Lucie's, finding the latter tasted only of sugar and lacked depth."
Negative"This user lists From Lucie's cookie as one of their top 5 favorites."
Positive"This commenter declares From Lucie's cookie as their favorite."
Positive"This user wants to try From Lucie but notes they are often sold out by the time they visit."
Neutral"This user enjoyed the cookie from From Lucie and also mentioned The Pastry Box."
Positive
