Renowned for its exceptional cookies and cakes, this bakery offers a delightful escape into sweet indulgence.
This East Village bakery has quickly become a go-to spot for expertly crafted sweet treats, with a particular standout being their chocolate chip cookie, often lauded for its perfect chewy texture and crisp edges. Beyond cookies, their cakes, including a notable vanilla cake with earl grey frosting and a rich chocolate cake, also garner significant praise. While most feedback is overwhelmingly positive, one outlier mentioned a dry and stale cake, though this seems to be an exception to an otherwise stellar reputation.
From Lucie is celebrated for its baked goods, with a particular emphasis on its cookies and cakes. Customers rave about the chocolate chip cookie, often describing it as thin, chewy, and delicious, with some even calling it the best in NYC. The cakes also receive high praise, with mentions of a vanilla cake with earl grey frosting and blackberry compote, and a chocolate cake being particularly good. One negative review described a cake as dry and stale, but this was an isolated comment.
"Customers highly recommend the chocolate chip cookie, often citing it as a top-tier choice. The vanilla cake with earl grey frosting and blackberry compote, as well as the chocolate cake, are also frequently praised."
Customers overwhelmingly praise From Lucie, with many specifically calling out their cookies and cakes as exceptional. Some negative feedback mentioned a cake being dry and stale, but this was an outlier.
Important Note
One user described a cake from the establishment as dry and stale.
"The user strongly recommended From Lucie."
Positive"This commenter suggests Lucie for cakes but notes that they would be significantly over the $100 price point."
Neutral"The user added From Lucie to the list of bakery recommendations."
Neutral"This user lists From Lucie as a recommendation for birthday cakes."
Positive"From Lucie is mentioned as a place to get carrot cake."
Neutral"A user recommends From Lucie."
Positive"The original poster acknowledges From Lucie makes a great all-around cookie but finds its edges a bit crisp, which does not meet their strict 'zero crisp' requirement."
Negative"A user expresses great satisfaction with From Lucie's cookies, stating they fit the ideal chewy, no-crisp preference."
Positive"From Lucie is recommended as a place for good thin cookies."
Positive"From Lucie is recommended for its cookies."
Positive"From Lucie is recommended for its cookies."
Positive"The user strongly believes From Lucie's cookie sucks compared to Culture Espresso."
Negative"The user states that From Lucie's cookies are significantly better than Culture Espresso's."
Positive"from Lucie is included in a list of recommended bakeries for the user's bucket list before leaving NYC."
Positive"The user humorously noted a sense of déjà vu, believing they met the original poster at From Lucie on Sunday and recognized a photo of chocolate cake from the same spot."
Neutral"The original poster mentioned visiting From Lucie as part of their Sunday dining itinerary."
Neutral"This user recommends From Lucie for chocolate chip cookies."
Positive"From Lucie is in their top 3 chocolate chip cookies along with Culture Espresso and Hani's Bakery."
Positive"Everything in From Lucie's display case looked amazing, and the free lemon bar bites were delicious."
Positive"Loves the chocolate chip cookies at From Lucie, but thinks their chocolate cake is amazing."
Positive
