Details
This American eatery has recently been in the spotlight for significant health code violations, leading to a shutdown by the Department of Health. While some patrons recall positive experiences with dishes like rotisserie chicken and creamed spinach, and generally reliable service, the recurring health issues have significantly impacted customer perception. Some commenters have questioned the validity of positive online reviews in light of these violations, with one user even noting the presence of mice. The restaurant has a history of similar violations, as its previous iteration under a different name also faced issues.
Food Overview
Customers have noted that the rotisserie chicken and creamed spinach are good. However, the restaurant has faced significant criticism and has been shut down due to numerous health code violations. Some customers found the pricing for sandwiches to be high, although one comment disputes this, stating a chicken italiano sandwich was $12. There are mentions of past issues with incorrect orders, but also recollections of generally good and reliable service.
Customer Sentiment
Customers have expressed significant concerns regarding health code violations, with one comment noting that the establishment was shut down by the Department of Health. This has led to a generally negative sentiment among reviewers, with some expressing disbelief at positive Google reviews and citing personal experiences or observations of unsanitary conditions, including the presence of mice. While some patrons recall positive experiences in the past, the recent health code issues have overshadowed any prior good standing.
Caveats
The restaurant has a history of health code violations, including a recent shutdown by the Department of Health and reported presence of mice.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About 72ND EATERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"Hi yes they are open again with a grade pending that’s all I know"
NeutralFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"It’s back open anyone know the deal?"
NeutralFrom post: Best Rotisserie Chicken At A Restaurant
"72nd Eatery has good rotisserie chicken and creamed spinach."
PositiveFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"they sold cheap sandwiches like $12 for a chicken italiano"
NeutralFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"OMG MICE"
NegativeFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"Those almost got me, but when i went in once to take a look, i knew something was off. Didn’t buy anything. Looked up their health record and never returned."
NegativeFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"Those google reviews must be fake. 4.7/5 with 500+ reviews"
NeutralFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"Yikes https://a816-health.nyc.gov/ABCEatsRestaurants/#!/Search/40401834"
NegativeFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"The crime was charging $25 for a sandwich."
NegativeFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"Again!!!!???"
NegativeFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"damn they were shut down then rebranded and now shutdown again?"
NegativeFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"It takes A LOT to get shut down, the place must have been disgusting."
NegativeFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"Used to be Columbus Gourmet Food and THEY ALSO HAD HEALTH VIOLATIONS."
NegativeFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"Last time I was here they totally screwed up my order, but they were good and reliable most of the time!"
NeutralFrom post: 72nd Eatery Uws Shut Down By Department Of Health
"They had endless health code violations. It was inevitable."
Negative