Last Updated: 3 days ago
Phone: (646) 338-1189
Address: 212 WEST 80 STREET 10024
Known for its unique pie crust cookies and highly praised baked goods, this bakery is a must-try for dessert lovers.
Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods is a highly recommended bakery, particularly celebrated for its innovative 'pie crust cookies.' While reviews indicate that not every item hits the mark for every customer, the general sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with many customers expressing obsession over their unique cookie creations. The bakery, with locations in Manhattan, is a staple for those seeking delicious and distinctive baked treats.
This bakery is highly acclaimed for its cookies, especially the unique 'pie crust cookies.' While one reviewer found the 'Half Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie' underwhelming, the consensus is that the pie crust cookies are a standout item, with other cookie flavors like 'S'mores' and 'Coffee Toffee' also receiving positive mentions. The bakery is recommended for its American baked goods.
"The 'pie crust cookies' are consistently recommended and praised for their unique texture and flavor. Other recommended items include the 'S'mores Cookie' and 'Coffee Toffee Cookie.'"
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Janie's, with many praising their unique pie crust cookies and overall baked goods.
Important Note
One reviewer found the 'Half Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie' to be underwhelming.
"Janie's is mentioned as a place offering pie crust cookies."
Positive"The commenter highly recommends Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods for its amazing pie crust cookies, noting its location a block away from L'Industrie."
Positive"Janie's Pie Cookies are recommended as a unique and delicious sweet treat for visitors to NYC."
Positive"Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods is strongly recommended for its "absolutely delicious pie crust cookies," and is located near L'Industrie in West Village."
Positive"A Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods location is noted to be nearby the Natural History Museum, offering a snack option."
Neutral"This user recommends Janie's for their cookies."
Positive"The user mentions having tried cookies from Janie's Life Changing, along with others, but still found Bear Mountain's cookies to be 'excellent,' implying Bear Mountain's were preferred."
Neutral"Janie's pie crust cookie was enjoyable."
Positive"Asking if the original poster tried the pie crust cookies at Janie's."
Neutral"Recommends the coffee toffee cookie at Janie's, describing it as similar to a chocolate chip cookie with ideal texture."
Positive"Obsessed with Janie's, but prefers their pie crust cookies."
Positive"Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods' chocolate chip cookies were one of four they tried, with Hani's being their favorite."
Neutral"User lists Janie's among their top 5 chocolate chip cookie choices."
Positive"Janie's has great pie crust cookies and cookies in general"
Positive"The original poster regrets not trying one of Janie's pie cookies along with the half-baked chocolate chip."
Neutral"A commenter recalls Janie's pie cookie being recommended as an alternative when they asked about cheesecake."
Neutral"Commenter notes Janie's has been recommended for years, mainly from its UWS location, with a recent boost from opening in the West Village."
Neutral"Commenter highly praises Janie's 'pie cookies'."
Positive"Commenter notes the recent increase in mentions of Janie's on the subreddit, possibly due to a new West Village location supplementing the original UWS spot."
Neutral"Ranked #10 out of 15 NYC chocolate chip cookies. Although seemingly matching the reviewer's preferences on paper, the cookie was found underwhelming."
Negative
