TLDR
Stunning rustic Mediterranean aesthetic meets phenomenal Greek classics on the UWS. A perfect, spacious pick for an upscale, non-touristy night out.
Details
Located on the Upper West Side, this spacious venue features a modern Mediterranean aesthetic with rustic whitewashed brick and wood beams [2]. The menu is highly regarded for its fresh approach to Greek classics, including grilled fish, moussaka, and a variety of flavorful dips [1][2]. It is frequently highlighted as an excellent spot for upscale dining, noted specifically for being a non-touristy choice for groups [1].
Food Overview
The kitchen excels at fresh Greek fare, with a menu featuring beef moussaka, lamb chops, and whole grilled fish [1][2]. Diners are particularly enthusiastic about the dips, specifically recommending the hummus, and the Short Rib Youvetsi is frequently described as incredible [1][3]. Fresh Greek yogurt is also available as a standout dessert option [3].
Caveats
Some visitors have noted that the restaurant can feel crowded, particularly during its earlier period of operation [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ELEA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Solo Dining Recommendations In Upper West Side
"General recommendation provided."
PositiveFrom post: Does Anyone Know Places Similar To Kyma But
"Proposed as a potential alternative to more expensive Greek restaurants."
NeutralFrom post: Places For Fresh Greek Yogurt With Toppings Sour
"They serve excellent Greek yogurt as a dessert option."
PositiveFrom post: Does Anyone Know Places Similar To Kyma But
"Suggested as a Greek dining option located within Manhattan."
NeutralFrom post: Dinner Spots For Taking Out Visiting Parents In
"Elea on the UWS is described as a great venue with phenomenal Greek food."
PositiveFrom post: Dinner Spots For Taking Out Visiting Parents In
"Elea is mentioned as a nice spot on the UWS."
PositiveFrom post: Best Greek Food Place Ie Not For A Date
"Elea is mentioned as a Greek restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: Need A Noninfluencer Infested Place For Birthday
"The user is asking for restaurant recommendations for their birthday dinner, mentioning Elea as a place they have been to many times."
NeutralFrom post: Greek Food Near Or Around Midtown
"Elea is highly recommended for excellent Greek food in a beautiful space on the Upper West Side. It's noted as not being touristy and is conveniently located near a subway line that goes directly to the theater."
PositiveFrom post: Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants
"This commenter suggested that Elea might have been working out kinks when the other commenter visited, and reiterated that the Short Rib Youvetsi is incredible."
PositiveFrom post: Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants
"This commenter was not impressed with Elea when it was new, finding it crowded and not worth it, though the other commenter mentioned the Short Rib Youvetsi is incredible."
NegativeFrom post: Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants
"Elea on the UWS is described as a great spot, with the Short Rib Youvetsi being particularly incredible."
PositiveFrom post: Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants
"The commenter heard that Elea on the UWS is great."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting This Weekend Seeking The Best Greek We
"The original poster is looking for upscale Greek dinner recommendations in NYC and mentions Elea as a potential option."
NeutralFrom post: Greek Restaurant With Large Portions
"This commenter simply recommended Elea as a Greek restaurant on the Upper West Side."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Favorite Upscale Greekmediterranean
"The commenter expresses dislike for Elea on the UWS and doesn't understand its appeal, listing other options."
Negative