Next.js logo

CARMINE'S

Updated

Phone: (212) 362-2200

Address: 2450 BROADWAY 10024

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Ginormous family-style Italian portions perfect for groups. A lively UWS spot that won't disappoint.

Reddit Sentiment for CARMINE'S(based on 2 Reddit opinions)

50% Positive

Tags

italian 2italian-american 2american 2italian-american 2family style 2View All

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
Eater’s Guide to New York City Restaurant Closures in May 2026
very negative

Edgar's Cafe, a neighborhood staple on the Upper West Side known for its breakfast and comfort food, has closed after nearly 40 years in operation. The owner cited inability to afford rent as the reason for the closure.

n/a • May 1, 2026
Read More →
Eater

Details

This Italian-American gem on the Upper West Side is renowned for its colossal family-style portions that are perfect for sharing. It's a go-to spot for celebrations and large gatherings, ensuring no one leaves hungry. The atmosphere buzzes with energy, making it a lively choice for any occasion.

Food Overview

This Italian-American restaurant is celebrated for its incredibly generous, family-style portions. While specific dishes aren't highlighted, the overall feedback points to a positive experience, especially for those looking to share large, hearty meals.

Customer Sentiment

Customers rave about the huge, family-style portions and the restaurant's ability to accommodate large groups. It's consistently suggested for celebrations and big gatherings.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About CARMINE'S

https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1jrhuqo/dinner_for_11_people_in_manhattan/
This user suggests Carmine's, noting it should be able to accommodate a large group of 11 people. Another comment confirms the UWS location has a private room suitable for large groups.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1srsao9/graduation_dinner/
A user recommended Carmine's for its excellent Italian food, specifically mentioning the ginormous family-style portions and assuring it would not disappoint.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Graduation Dinner

"This user suggested Carmine's for its excellent Italian food, emphasizing the ginormous family-style portions. They believe it would not disappoint."

Positive
Apr 21, 2026View Comment →

More in Upper West Side

See all

More italian in NYC

See all