CARMINE'S

"Reflecting on the 1990s at the UWS location, the commenter recalls tasty classics like Caesar salad, calamari, veal Parmesan, pasta specials, and tiramisu, and would recommend it if the quality has remained the same."

"Several locals love it and use the Upper West Side location for birthday dinners because it is designed for large groups and serves as a crowd-pleaser."

"The commenter enjoyed the veggie sides but described the experience as being like catered food for an Italian-American wedding, noting there are better options elsewhere."

"It is rated 5.5/10 for locals; while decent for groups, it is not considered good Italian food in NYC."

"It is perfect for feeding large groups at a reasonable price, though the commenter would never choose to dine there normally."

"The wings are described as excellent, and the food is better than the surrounding area would suggest."

"It is categorized as family-style Italian-American rather than proper Italian, and the local commenter would only go if specifically requested by guests."

"The commenter notes that it is a top spot when dining outside of NYC, offering very good value and solid food for groups."

"Years ago, it was a great, affordable spot for families on the Upper West Side; while the commenter hasn't been back since, they would still consider it for grandkids who aren't into other ethnic cuisines."

"The food is mediocre and locals do not go there."

"It is considered a fun place for large groups, though the experience is described as feeling more like an amusement park than a typical restaurant."

"This establishment offers a great meatball parm hero."

"This user suggested Carmine's for its excellent Italian food, emphasizing the ginormous family-style portions. They believe it would not disappoint."