TLDR
A beloved destination for rare Sicilian specialties and traditional red-sauce comfort food. Known for authentic panelle, arancini, and a deep-cut menu that feels like a trip to the old country.
Details
A classic destination for authentic Sicilian specialties, this spot is celebrated by many for its unique traditional menu items [1]. While some long-time patrons remain loyal to signature dishes, recent feedback highlights a polarizing shift in quality, with some diners reporting significant declines [6], [7], [9]. Despite these mixed reviews, it remains a frequent recommendation for those seeking a genuine 'red sauce' Italian experience in Brooklyn [5], [13].
Food Overview
This restaurant specializes in Sicilian and red-sauce Italian cuisine, with panelle and arancini serving as major draws [1], [8], [11]. While the 'special' arancini served with ragu and cheese is a fan favorite [10], some recent visitors have criticized the quality, going so far as to describe the food as microwaved [6], [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About JOE'S OF AVE U
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For An Old School Red Sauce Joint Similar
"Mentioned as a place for Italian heirloom eating in Gravesend."
NeutralFrom post: Is There Any Arancini In Nyc Similar To Whats In
"Identifies the place as a Sicilian restaurant with great arancini."
PositiveFrom post: Is There Any Arancini In Nyc Similar To Whats In
"The commenter describes the arancini here as being served 'special' style with sauce and cheese, noting it is a different preparation than what is found in Sicily."
PositiveFrom post: Arancini Onion Focaccia And Sfincione From
"Mentioned as a place on the user's list to visit, known for being one of the few places to get panelle."
NeutralFrom post: First Taste Of Panelle At Visit Sicily Nyc East
"The author stated that Joe's of Avenue U is now awful."
Negative