TLDR
Authentic Sicilian fare w/ rave reviews for panelle & pasta con sarde. Unpretentious, classic Italian.
Details
This Brooklyn Italian spot is a must-visit for those seeking authentic Sicilian flavors. Customers rave about their pasta con sarde, panelle, and arancino, with many calling the panelle with ricotta the best they've ever had. While some recent reviews suggest a decline in quality, many still cherish this establishment for its unpretentious atmosphere and classic Italian dishes.
Food Overview
The restaurant specializes in Italian and Sicilian cuisine, with particular praise for its panelle (especially with ricotta) and pasta con sarde. Arancino is also frequently recommended. While most feedback is positive, a few recent comments suggest that the restaurant may be past its prime and some dishes, like the chicken parm, are not recommended.
Caveats
Some recent reviews suggest that the restaurant has declined in quality and may be past its prime.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About JOE'S OF AVE U
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: First Taste Of Panelle At Visit Sicily Nyc East
"The author stated that Joe's of Avenue U is now awful."
NegativeFrom post: First Taste Of Panelle At Visit Sicily Nyc East
"The author expressed love for Joe's of Avenue U, specifically highlighting their panelle with ricotta as the best."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"This commenter felt Joe's of Ave U has declined, mentioning their food was microwaved and is not what it used to be."
NegativeFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"This commenter had a very negative experience at Joe's of Ave U, stating it was some of the worst food they've had in NYC recently, despite good service, and that the restaurant is past its prime."
NegativeFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Joe's of Ave U was mentioned as a red sauce Italian option."
NeutralFrom post: Sicilian Calamari
"This user clarified that Joe's of Ave U is not too far for them, in response to the travel time mentioned by another user."
PositiveFrom post: Sicilian Calamari
"This user suggested Joe's of Ave U for Sicilian calamari in red sauce, noting it might be a bit of a trip."
PositiveFrom post: In Search Of Authentic Foods
"In response to a request for authentic Italian restaurant ideas for a school project, Joe's of Ave U was recommended."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Some Authentic Italian Recommendations
"Joe's of Avenue U is praised for its menu in English and Sicilian, its pasta con sarde, panelle, and arancino. They also mention vastedda as an untranslated menu item."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Some Good Red Sauce Joints In Nyc
"This establishment was recommended as a red sauce joint similar to Bamonte's."
NeutralFrom post: Is Anyone Else Tired Of The Exact Same Pasta Menu
"Joes of Avenue U is listed as a recommendation for Italian food."
PositiveFrom post: Italian Restaurant Not Pizzeria In South Brooklyn
"A user expressed their love for the panelles at Joe's of Ave U, an Italian restaurant recommended for chicken parm."
PositiveFrom post: Italian Restaurant Not Pizzeria In South Brooklyn
"Joe's of Ave U was recommended as an Italian restaurant in response to a query for good chicken parm in South Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Best Unpretentious Classic Italians Pasta Or Pizza
"Agrees with the recommendation for Joe's of Avenue U, specifically praising the pannelle and riceball special but advising against the chicken parm."
PositiveFrom post: Best Unpretentious Classic Italians Pasta Or Pizza
"Recommends Joe's of Avenue U in Brooklyn for Sicilian food."
Positive