TLDR
Exceptional Neapolitan and fried pizzas with a cult-favorite crust, conveniently located for quick, high-quality bites in Midtown.
Reddit Sentiment for DON ANTONIO RESTAURANT(based on 28 Reddit opinions)
Details
Renowned for its textbook Neapolitan crust and distinctively sweet-and-acidic sauce, this spot serves up pies that offer a welcome escape from the Midtown tourist rush [1]. It is frequently praised by locals and visitors alike for its high-quality, authentic pizza and efficient service, making it a reliable destination for a quick, delicious meal [2], [3]. While most diners consider it a top-tier choice for Neapolitan and fried pies, it also stands out for offering highly-regarded gluten-free options [4], [5].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, with the dough achieving an ideal balance of chew and char [1]. The signature pies are celebrated for their unique sauce profile, described as both sweet and acidic [1], and the restaurant is specifically highlighted for its excellent gluten-free crust and traditional fried pizza [4], [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"The Neapolitan pies are highly recommended for their authentic, charred crust [1], and the fried pizza is frequently singled out as a standout, nostalgic item [2]. Additionally, the gluten-free pizza is widely considered one of the best options in the area [3]."
Customer Sentiment
Patrons generally hold the restaurant in high regard, frequently praising the authentic pizza and quick service that accommodates busy schedules [1], [2]. While the overwhelming majority of feedback is positive, there are isolated instances of diners who feel the experience is overhyped [3].
Caveats
The restaurant does not accept reservations, so guests should be prepared for potential wait times or to utilize bar seating [1]. Some visitors find the overall popularity of the location to be overhyped compared to other local options [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About DON ANTONIO RESTAURANT
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Wheres The Good Food In Midtown Thats Not 50 And
"Indicated a negative opinion."
NegativeFrom post: Wheres The Good Food In Midtown Thats Not 50 And
"Recommended for excellent cheap Neapolitan pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Best Neapolitan Italian Restaurants In The New
"A native of Napoli claims this is the best spot for pizza, outperforming others listed."
PositiveFrom post: Best Neapolitan Italian Restaurants In The New
"Listed as a favorite spot that serves fried pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Gluten Free Spots While On A Day Trip
"The commenter believes Don Antonio's likely has separate ovens for gluten-free items but advises calling to confirm."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Gluten Free Spots While On A Day Trip
"The user is inquiring about whether Don Antonio's has dedicated ovens or if cross-contact is a concern for their gluten-free needs."
NeutralFrom post: Best Neapolitan Pizza Places Apart From Una Pizza
"This user expressed disappointment with the hype around Don Antonio, suggesting seeking out other options instead."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For Gluten Free Spots While On A Day Trip
"This restaurant in Midtown is recommended for gluten-free pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Best Neapolitan Pizza Places Apart From Una Pizza
"This user recommended Don Antonio as a good Neapolitan pizza place."
PositiveFrom post: Best Neapolitan Pizza Places Apart From Una Pizza
"This user stated that Don Antonio's pizza is closer to the original Keste than Keste's current offerings, specifically mentioning the pizza fritte."
PositiveFrom post: Best Neapolitan Pizza Places Apart From Una Pizza
"This user listed Don Antonio as one of their next choices for Neapolitan pizza, alongside Il leone, pizzeria fantastica, song e napule and salsa pizzeria."
PositiveFrom post: Best Neapolitan Pizza Places Apart From Una Pizza
"This user stated that Don Antonio is amazing. They also mentioned that Song e Napule and Ribalta are fantastic, with Ribalta being the easiest to get a table."
PositiveFrom post: Best Cheeseless But Not Necessarily
"This user noted that Don Antonio offers similar cheeseless pizza options to Keste."
NeutralFrom post: Walk Up To Don Antonio At 5pm And Make It To The
"The original poster asked for clarification on "Don who?" after another user's comment."
NeutralFrom post: Walk Up To Don Antonio At 5pm And Make It To The
"The commenter recommended Sama za pizza in Hell's Kitchen, stating it takes reservations and might be even better, with a thinner and crispier crust."
NeutralFrom post: Walk Up To Don Antonio At 5pm And Make It To The
"The commenter suggested alternatives if pizza is not the sole reason for choosing Don Antonio, mentioning Senza Gluten or La Traviata as options."
NeutralFrom post: Walk Up To Don Antonio At 5pm And Make It To The
"The commenter believed the original poster would be okay and recommended the bar seating, which they preferred for its spaciousness, comfortable chairs, and guest spacing, in addition to dining room seating. They also suggested letting the staff know about the departure time and ordering quickly, recommending looking at the menu online beforehand."
PositiveFrom post: Walk Up To Don Antonio At 5pm And Make It To The
"The commenter advised the original poster not to stress too much about the wait time at 5pm and that the riskier part would be lingering over the meal, not the wait itself. They estimated that being seated by 5:20pm would still leave plenty of time."
PositiveFrom post: Walk Up To Don Antonio At 5pm And Make It To The
"Regarding bar chairs for older individuals, the commenter confirmed they are full, bulky chairs with cushioned backs."
PositiveFrom post: Walk Up To Don Antonio At 5pm And Make It To The
"The original poster confirmed that Don Antonio does not take reservations and that they have a backup idea but are eager to try Don Antonio due to many positive reviews."
Positive