TLDR
Classic UES neighborhood Italian with reliable pastas, standout gluten-free options, and charming outdoor seating. Great for a casual, crowd-pleasing dinner.
Details
A staple of the Upper East Side, this neighborhood spot offers a classic Italian dining experience known for its appealing private room and pleasant outdoor seating [2], [11]. The menu features casual Italian fare, including a variety of pastas and pizzas [2], [13]. While widely recommended for its atmosphere and food, opinions on the overall quality remain divided among some patrons [16], [18].
Food Overview
The restaurant serves classic Italian cuisine with a focus on pasta and pizza [13], [14]. It is highly regarded for its ability to accommodate diners with celiac disease or gluten sensitivities, offering excellent gluten-free pasta and pizza options [7]. While the lamb ragu is frequently highlighted as a favorite dish, some customers feel there are superior Italian dining options available elsewhere in the city [3], [18].
The lamb ragu is consistently cited as a standout pasta dish [3]. Additionally, their gluten-free pizza and pasta offerings are highly praised for being celiac-safe and delicious [7].
Overall sentiment is generally positive, with many diners enjoying the neighborhood atmosphere, though some debate the consistency of the food quality compared to other city options [10], [16], [18]. Guests also appreciate the restaurant's attentiveness regarding specific dietary requirements and allergies [8], [17].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01sarti spritz2 mentions
Caveats
Reservations are often necessary due to the restaurant's popularity [10]. Some patrons have expressed conflicting opinions regarding the food quality, suggesting it may not be the top choice for every diner [16], [18].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About UVA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: After Looking At Every Menu On Restaurant Week I
"The user has saved this restaurant as a potential option to try based on research."
NeutralFrom post: Do Any Bars Or Restaurants In Nyc Serve A Sarti
"Customer confirms having a Sarti spritz at the restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Do Any Bars Or Restaurants In Nyc Serve A Sarti
"The restaurant announced on social media that they have started serving Sarti spritzes."
PositiveFrom post: What Is A Good Italian Place In The Upper East
"Responding to a defense of Uva, this commenter reiterates their opinion that the food quality is not good and there are many better Italian options in NYC."
NegativeFrom post: What Is A Good Italian Place In The Upper East
"The commenter defends Uva, stating they have had delicious meals and good service there multiple times."
Positive