Offers a highly-rated traditional high tea [1], with a vibe that aligns with a whimsical tea party [2]. A lovely place with good food [8].
The Crosby Bar, part of the Firmdale Hotels, is a notable spot in Manhattan's SoHo neighborhood, celebrated for its vibrant atmosphere and well-regarded American cuisine. It's particularly recognized for its traditional high tea offerings, with multiple patrons highlighting it as a favorite in the city [1]. While many recommend the afternoon tea experience as a worthwhile alternative to more famous establishments [4], some diners have had less favorable experiences with both the food and service during afternoon tea [5].
The Crosby Bar is known for its American cuisine and is particularly lauded for its traditional high tea [1], which has been recommended as a strong alternative to other popular tea venues [4]. However, there are conflicting opinions, with one diner expressing dissatisfaction with both the food and service during their afternoon tea experience [5].
"The traditional high tea is frequently highlighted as a must-try, with many considering it a favorite in the city and a worthwhile alternative to other establishments."
Customer sentiment is mixed regarding the afternoon tea experience; while many praise it as a favorite [1] and a good alternative to pricier options [4, 6], some found the food and service disappointing [5].
Important Note
Customer experiences with the afternoon tea service are divided, with some patrons expressing dissatisfaction with the food and service.
"The Crosby St Hotel is mentioned as a lovely place with good food."
Positive"Afternoon tea at the Firmdale hotels (including The Crosby) was suggested as a lower-cost version compared to Baccarat."
Neutral"The commenter found the Whitby hotel (same owner as Crosby) to be just okay."
Neutral"In contrast to another commenter, this user did not like the food or service at the Crosby Hotel's afternoon tea."
Negative"The afternoon tea at Crosby Hotel was recommended as an alternative to The Plaza."
Neutral"The Crosby Street Hotel is suggested as a potential venue for a tea party, aligning with a whimsical vibe."
Positive"The Crosby Hotel offers an afternoon tea, noted as a possible option for the event."
Positive"This commenter identifies The Crosby Hotel as having one of their favorite traditional high teas in the city."
Positive
