TLDR
Nostalgic American comfort food meets high-end scene in this notoriously difficult-to-book SoHo hotspot.
Reddit Sentiment for THE CORNER STORE(based on 151 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The author's first visit to The Corner Store in SoHo was a resounding success, with many dishes earning high marks. The ambiance is described as gorgeous, and the author is already planning a return visit. Highlights included a special 2-year anniversary caviar olive martini, lobster and caviar rolls described as a 'must-best little bite', and hamachi crudo with watermelon. A special heirloom tomato appetizer by Chef Nadav was also featured. The five cheese pizza rolls were a standout, evoking childhood nostalgia. The iconic French dip, made with 72-hour Australian ribeye, au jus, and horseradish, was a notable dish. For dessert, the apple hand pies were incredible, and the Samoa Sundae was highly recommended. The restaurant's overall experience and food quality were exceptional.
The author finally secured a coveted spot at The Corner Store after a significant wait and a bit of luck, describing the ambiance as swanky and magical. The dining experience included several notable dishes, with the lobster caviar bites being the favorite for their buttery richness and being worth the hype and price. The Samoa sundae was a close second, praised for its delightful combination of shortbread cookies, ice cream, and coconut shavings. Other highlights included the Wagyu French Dip, described as rich and delicious, and surprisingly delightful fries. The pizza rolls were the least favorite but still considered delicious. The author's first martini experience was at this establishment, with the 'Sour Cream & Onion' martini being a unique and savory recommendation for martini enthusiasts. Service was exceptional, making the overall experience worth the effort, especially on a holiday weekend.
The Corner Store in SoHo is extremely difficult to get a reservation at, but the experience is considered worth the effort. The reviewer highlights several standout dishes: mini lobster rolls with caviar, a Caesar salad featuring everything bagel croutons and fried cream cheese, pizza rolls described as superior to Totino's, a Wagyu French dip, and an apple hand pie that is an elevated version of the McDonald's classic. The dining experience is noted as expensive, averaging $200 per person when splitting dishes, but deemed worth the cost. Securing a table is challenging, requiring persistence and luck with cancellations.
This post highlights a weekend visit to The Corner Store in Soho, NYC. The author details several items enjoyed, including a Vesper martini, The Corner Store Caesar, Wagyu French Dip, NY Knicks Special Spicy Chicken Sandwich, Prime Skirt Steak, Fries with various dipping sauces (Secret Sauce, Avocado Ranch, Horseradish Aioli), and concludes with the Samoa Sundae. The images show various dishes and the restaurant ambiance.
The Corner Store is presented as an exclusive and highly sought-after dining destination in New York City, known for its extremely difficult reservations and trendy atmosphere. Despite its hype, the food is lauded for exceeding expectations. The review specifically calls out the impressive value of their 2 1/2 pound lobster frites priced at $89, contrasting it with more expensive, smaller lobster rolls found elsewhere. Other absolute must-try dishes include their distinctive Caesar salad featuring fried cream cheese and everything bagel croutons, lobster rolls topped with caviar, and the 'Samoa sundae,' which is described with high praise. The steaks and pizza rolls are also recommended as excellent choices. Furthermore, the restaurant offers remarkably priced martinis at $20, which generously serve two to three people, with the Prosciutto and Melon martini being a standout favorite.
The Corner Store is praised for its excellent mini lobster rolls, described as the 'best ever.' The martinis are also a highlight, and the Samoa sundae is called 'insane' and a must-try. The post suggests that the restaurant is an ideal place for team dinners and showcases several other dishes like lobster rolls with caviar, pizza rolls, and a Caesar salad with unique croutons. The NY strip and chicken paillard were also featured.
This post focuses on a date night experience at The Corner Store, with a strong emphasis on their martinis. The author raves about the Melon & Prosciutto Martini, describing it as tasting exactly like melon and prosciutto and calling it a favorite summer special. The Sour Cream & Onion Martini is also highlighted as unique and addictive, served with chips of the same flavor. While other dishes like Pizza Rolls, Steak Frites, French Dip, Samoa Sundae, and Apple Hand Pies are reviewed, the martinis are clearly the main attraction and are described as 'the best'. The ambiance is noted as dark and cozy, making it suitable for a date night.
The post features The Corner Store as a must-visit restaurant in NYC. The image provided showcases the restaurant's interior, with elegant seating arrangements and ambient lighting, suggesting a chic and inviting dining experience. The caption also mentions that reservations can be made by sending a direct message, indicating a service-oriented approach.
The Corner Store is a restaurant in NYC that the poster visited and found to be worth the hype. The post specifically mentions and praises several dishes, indicating a positive overall experience.
The Corner Store is noted for its Samoa sundae, with additional positive mentions of their French dip and pizza rolls, indicating a varied menu of enjoyable comfort food options.
Bryan Kim reviews The Corner Store, a Soho spot that embraces a playful, kitschy version of American classics. Despite the clubstaurant atmosphere and excess, the food consistently surprises with its quality.
Details
This trendy SoHo spot offers elevated American comfort food in a stylish, 'old New York' inspired space [3]. While the menu features nostalgic items like pizza rolls and wagyu French dip, it is most famous for being one of the city's most challenging reservations to secure [3], [20]. Many diners praise the culinary execution and celebratory atmosphere [3], [19], though some critics argue that the experience is overhyped and similar to mainstream chain dining [1], [2], [4].
Food Overview
The restaurant serves elevated American comfort food, characterized by dishes such as pizza rolls, wagyu French dip, and steak frites [3]. Diners highly recommend the Samoa sundae [15], [17], [20], Caesar salad with fried cream cheese [16], [20], and lobster rolls often topped with caviar [15], [16], [20], though some find the caviar-topped lobster to be a wasteful and overpowering trend [1].
Customer feedback is highly polarized; while many celebrate the restaurant as a magical and delicious destination worth the effort [19], [20], others condemn it as an overpriced, pretentious gimmick not worth the struggle to get a table [1], [4].
- 01Lobster Roll12 mentionsThese rolls are a luxurious and highly recommended starter, often...
- 02Samoa Sundae12 mentionsThis dessert is a highly recommended and 'insane' must-try, inspi...
- 03Pizza Rolls10 mentionsThese pizza rolls are a highly praised and craveable dish, descri...
- 04French Dip9 mentionsThis sandwich features high-quality beef, like Wagyu, on a bun wi...
- 05Caesar Salad9 mentionsThis Caesar salad is exceptionally well-regarded, with reviewers ...
- 06Steak Frites5 mentionsThis entree is generally well-received, featuring a well-charred ...
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE CORNER STORE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Iso Insight On Smart Elegant Dress Code For The
"The commenter reports an unpleasant experience where the hostess was rude, implying that the staff expects patrons to dress up."
NegativeFrom post: Under The Radar Holy St Howdidyoufindthis Dinner
"Mentioned as a notable Manhattan restaurant by a local."
NeutralFrom post: Iso Insight On Smart Elegant Dress Code For The
"The commenter wore wide-leg slacks and flats for dinner and felt appropriately dressed, suggesting refined casual attire is acceptable."
PositiveFrom post: Iso Insight On Smart Elegant Dress Code For The
"The venue likely intends to discourage athletic wear, hats, and shorts, but dark jeans with heels are considered acceptable."
NeutralFrom post: Iso Insight On Smart Elegant Dress Code For The
"Maintains that the dress code is a generic policy and notes that the commenter successfully dined there in jeans, a white shirt, and sneakers."
Positive