TLDR
Authentic Roman import featuring a casual alimentari and elevated tasting menus. Renowned for top-tier pasta, extensive wine lists, and a moody, gorgeous cellar setting.
Instagram Posts References
The author explicitly states Roscioli NYC is their 'absolute favorite' and features a picture of pasta, highlighting it as a must-visit for pasta lovers.
Roscioli is included in this curated selection of New York City's best Cacio e Pepe, implying a standout and memorable version of the classic Roman pasta.
Details
A highly acclaimed Italian import directly from Rome, this spot has captured local hearts with its authentic Roman cuisine and exceptional wine program [4]. It offers a versatile dining experience featuring a casual upstairs alimentari and a refined downstairs tasting menu [1]. Guests consistently praise its commitment to quality, making it a standout destination for both pasta enthusiasts and those seeking a memorable meal [2], [13].
Food Overview
Specializing in traditional Roman fare, the kitchen is celebrated for its pasta, particularly the Amatriciana and Carbonara [1], [16], [20]. Other crowd favorites include the polpette, fried artichokes, raddichio salad, anchovies with three butters, black cod with capers, and the notably great bread baskets [12], [20]. The restaurant is also frequently recognized for having one of the city's best Cacio e Pepe dishes [1].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended dishes include the Amatriciana, Carbonara, polpette, fried artichokes, and the signature bread baskets [1], [12], [16], [20]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •amatriciana(2)
Customer Sentiment
Visitors are overwhelmingly enthusiastic about their experiences, frequently highlighting the authentic Roman food and excellent wine selection as reasons for high praise [5], [13]. It is widely considered a top-tier recommendation for diners looking for quality and atmosphere in NYC [9], [13].
Caveats
Reservations for lunch are noted as being significantly easier to secure than those for dinner [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ROSCIOLI NYC
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: West Village Takeout For Someone Who Usually Just
"Recommends trying their carbonara."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Top 3 Most Frequented Restaurants
"Highly recommended for various dishes like polpette and pasta amatriciana; they suggest the wine list is excellent and recommend the a la carte experience."
PositiveFrom post: Best 40th Bday Private Dinner Spot Or Experience
"Features a moody and gorgeous wine cellar room for private events."
PositiveFrom post: Need Dinner Rec Similar To Lei Wine Bar The Four
"Mentioned as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: What Do You Think Is The Best Homemade Pasta In
"This commenter mentions Roscioli for its Amatriciana."
PositiveFrom post: On The Hunt For For Good Or Interesting Bread
"Roscioli is mentioned for its bread basket."
NeutralFrom post: Best Italian Pasta Spot In Manhattan For Euro
"Roscioli is recommended for its Roman specialization, suggesting that restaurants focusing on specific Italian regions are committed to quality."
PositiveFrom post: Best Italian Pasta Spot In Manhattan For Euro
"Roscioli is listed among several other Italian restaurant recommendations."
PositiveFrom post: Best Italian Pasta Spot In Manhattan For Euro
"Roscioli is suggested as a place to try for Italian food, specifically for Roman cuisine."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Go Near Lincoln Center For A Late
"Roscioli offers late seatings and is a Roman Italian restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Small Localneighborhood Italian
"Roscioli is recommended as a dining option for Fridays and weekends."
NeutralFrom post: Last Visit Before 1st Baby Lower Manhattan Or
"Roscioli is recommended, particularly for its great bread baskets."
PositiveFrom post: Nice Dinner Date Around Central Park
"The user recommended Roscioli in the west village as their top NYC food recommendation, specifying it is Roman/Italian."
PositiveFrom post: Girls Trip
"Roscioli was suggested as a top Italian restaurant option."
PositiveFrom post: Private Dining With Diverse Cuisine Options
"Mentioned as a potential restaurant for a dinner party, suggesting it could accommodate diverse cuisine preferences."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Pasta For A Picky Eaters
"This user vouched for Roscioli, stating that their pasta was great, supporting the previous recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Pasta For A Picky Eaters
"In response to a comment about Roscioli's wine selection, this user enthusiastically agreed, stating it's one of the best in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Pasta For A Picky Eaters
"This user recommended Roscioli, stating it's amazing and easier to get a reservation for lunch than dinner. They also specifically recommended the Amatriciana dish."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Pasta For A Picky Eaters
"This user recommended Roscioli, mentioning that they are from Rome. They also suggested Rezdora as an Emilia-inspired osteria."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Pasta For A Picky Eaters
"This user recommended Roscioli, noting it's a branch of an actual Italian place from Rome. They highlighted the great quality and wine selection."
Positive