TLDR
Authentic Roman imports featuring expert carbonara and an unparalleled wine list in a moody, subterranean setting. A hard-to-get reservation that’s worth every bite.
Instagram Posts References
The author explicitly states Roscioli NYC is their 'absolute favorite' and features a picture of pasta, highlighting it as a must-visit for pasta lovers.
Roscioli is included in this curated selection of New York City's best Cacio e Pepe, implying a standout and memorable version of the classic Roman pasta.
Willa Moore reviews Roscioli, a high-profile Roman import in Soho that delivers an authentic Italian experience through its masterfully prepared pasta, curated cheese selection, and atmospheric, multi-level dining room.
Details
Authentic Roman Italian dining brought directly to the city, this buzzy venue features a casual upstairs alimentari and a moody, candlelit subterranean dining room [1]. The menu emphasizes high-quality traditional preparations of pasta, cured meats, and premium cheeses [2]. Despite being notoriously difficult to secure a reservation, the rigorous commitment to culinary standards makes the experience a must-visit for enthusiasts of Italian cuisine [2].
Food Overview
The kitchen focuses on traditional Roman recipes, with the carbonara frequently cited as a textbook example of expert emulsification [2]. Other highly recommended items include the amatriciana, crispy meat-and-cheese filled rice balls, polpette, and the bread baskets [2], [4]. While the food is widely acclaimed, the menu consistently earns top marks for its dedication to quality without compromising for local trends [2].
Caveats
Securing a reservation can be notoriously difficult, requiring advance planning [2]. Some diners have suggested alternative options, indicating that the experience may not suit every visitor's preferences [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ROSCIOLI NYC
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Itinerary Check Tomorrow
"The visitor personally liked the food at Roscioli and was specifically searching for gricia."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Itinerary Check Tomorrow
"Advise avoiding Roscioli."
NegativeFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Itinerary Check Tomorrow
"Suggests replacing Roscioli with Borgo."
NegativeFrom post: Need A Good Italian Pasta Restaurant For This
"Listed as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Need A Good Italian Pasta Restaurant For This
"Listed as a recommendation."
Positive