Charred & tender hanger steak, unpretentious vibe, great value. A go-to for expertly grilled meat & classic sides.
This Williamsburg steakhouse offers a refreshingly unpretentious take on the classic American steakhouse experience. Known for its expertly grilled hanger steak, which is praised for its tenderness and char, St. Anselm delivers exceptional value. The menu expands beyond traditional cuts to include items like lamb saddle and a variety of well-executed sides, making it a standout choice for both steak aficionados and those seeking a more casual yet high-quality meal.
This American steakhouse is lauded for its perfectly grilled hanger steak, often described as tender and flavorful. Other highlights include the Bo Bo chicken, lamb saddle, and various sides like spinach gratin and mashed potatoes. While most reviews are positive, one user found the ribeye to be disappointing.
"The hanger steak (also referred to as butcher's steak) is frequently praised as a must-try. Other recommended dishes include the Bo Bo chicken, lamb saddle, sticky toffee pudding, and sides like spinach gratin and mashed potatoes."
Customers overwhelmingly praise St. Anselm for its exceptional steak quality and value, with many considering it a favorite. While most feedback is positive, a few diners have noted inconsistent or poor service experiences.
Important Note
One diner reported a negative experience with consistently poor and bordering on rude service, including forgotten drinks and ignored requests. However, this is contrasted by other patrons who have had consistently good or friendly service over many years.
"St. Anselm is recommended for its Butcher's steak or Denver steak, described as relatively lean, small, and flavorful with familiar garlic butter and grilled char flavors, all under $40."
Positive"St. Anselm is recommended for its Butcher's steak or Denver steak, described as relatively lean, small, and flavorful with familiar garlic butter and grilled char flavors, all under $40."
Positive"St Anselm is recommended if venturing towards Williamsburg."
Neutral"St. Anselm is mentioned as a good place to dine alone at the bar."
Positive"St Anselm is highly recommended."
Positive"St. Anselm is suggested as a steak restaurant option."
Positive"St Anselm is recommended for its bar seating."
Positive"St. Anselm is the commenter's favorite steakhouse, ranking even above Keens."
Positive"St. Anselm in Williamsburg is mentioned as another enjoyable steakhouse in NYC."
Positive"Inquiry about when St. Anselm reopened."
Neutral"This user agrees that Keens was mediocre and that the quality of meat there was not good."
Negative"Both St. Anselm and Tete D'Or did not disappoint the commenter."
Positive"The commenter found the ribeye at St. Anselm to be lousy."
Negative"The commenter visited Keens recently and found the steaks mediocre, stating they could make better at home, but conceded the ambiance was better."
Negative"The commenter recommends St. Anselm and notes it's not to be missed."
Positive"The Butcher's steak at St. Anselm is described as having the best quality for its price in NYC."
Positive"The commenter is excited to learn St. Anselm is open again and plans to revisit."
Positive"The commenter agrees that St. Anselm's steak preparation is excellent and comparable to more expensive options."
Positive"This user points out that while St. Anselm's Butcher steak isn't a ribeye, its quality and preparation make it comparable to more expensive cuts at other steakhouses."
Positive
