TLDR
Unpretentious, wood-fired steakhouse classics in Williamsburg. Famous for high-value cuts, lamb saddle, and cozy, authentic vibes.
Details
A quintessential Williamsburg destination, this unpretentious steakhouse avoids formal norms in favor of quality, wood-fired cooking [2]. Known for its exceptional value, the menu features standout preparations like hanger steak and lamb saddle [1]. While widely considered a top-tier dining experience [3], [4], the atmosphere is known for being energetic and occasionally quite warm [5].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on expertly grilled meats, with the butcher's steak (hanger steak) being a frequently praised, high-value staple [1], [4]. Other highlights include the tender lamb saddle [3], giant prawns [3], and the highly popular spinach gratin [4]. Some diners have expressed mixed reviews regarding the ribeye quality [4] or the presentation of herb garnishes [3].
Highlights / Recommended
"The butcher's steak (hanger steak) and lamb saddle are widely considered essential orders [1], [3]. Complement your meal with the highly recommended spinach gratin [4]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •bo bo chicken(3)
- •sticky toffee pudding(3)
- •butcher's steak(3)
- •lamb saddle(3)
- •bacon(2)
- •steak(2)
- •steaks(2)
- •hangar steak(2)
- •butcher steak(2)
- •ribeye(2)
- •spinach gratin(2)
Caveats
Be prepared for potentially long wait times for dinner [5] and a very warm environment in the kitchen area [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ST. ANSELM
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Are We Buying Fancy Tinned Sardines
"The user recommends the grilled sardines served at this restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Shrimp Dish That Youve Had In
"The user mentions the giant grilled shrimp/prawn."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Do You Recommend If I Love
"An additional recommendation if the user is willing to head to Brooklyn for quality cooking."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"Emphasizes that it is very hot inside."
NeutralFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"Highly recommends the spinach gratin."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"The chef's counter is essentially a bar looking into the kitchen. Regular tables are recommended for an indoor experience, and their vegetable sides are highlighted."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"Prefers the counter to watch the food being cooked."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"This is a favorite steakhouse, though it isn't ideal for a romantic night vibe. The steak is excellent."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"Mentions that there is typically a 90-minute wait for dinner regardless of where you sit."
NegativeFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"The counter is great and the restaurant has air conditioning."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"The restaurant offers authentic farm-to-table summer specials that are available at regular tables as well as the counter."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"The restaurant is a classic Williamsburg spot that is authentic but rough around the edges, with a very hot kitchen area."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"The chef's table allows you to observe the cooks, though it isn't an elevated or uniquely special experience."
NeutralFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"The chef's table is physically very hot due to the open grill kitchen. It is better for drinking and having fun than for intimate conversation."
NeutralFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"The chef's table is great for the experience of watching the kitchen, but a regular table is better for a quieter, more intimate birthday."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"Sitting at the bar is enjoyable, and the food is great throughout the restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Going To St Anselm For My Partners Birthday After
"Enjoyed the chef's table for a birthday as it was fun to watch the cooking, though table availability is limited."
PositiveFrom post: Last Visit Before 1st Baby Lower Manhattan Or
"St. Anselm in Williamsburg is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Recs For Last Restaurant To Visit Before I Move
"St. Anselm is recommended as a place the commenter would miss if they moved from NYC, suggesting it's a notable establishment."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"St. Anselm is recommended for its Butcher's steak or Denver steak, described as relatively lean, small, and flavorful with familiar garlic butter and grilled char flavors, all under $40."
Positive