TLDR
Michelin-starred, wine-focused New American staple in Williamsburg, celebrated for its seasonal plates and vibrant, music-forward house party energy.
Reddit Sentiment for THE FOUR HORSEMEN(based on 83 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The Four Horsemen is a New York City restaurant that hosted students as part of the Food Education Fund's Dine Out program. This program provides students with a foundational understanding of the restaurant business through immersive experiences.
James Beard Outstanding Restaurant finalist, The Four Horsemen, is a Williamsburg staple known for its extensive wine list and eclectic, evolving menu. Co-founder James Murphy's influence is felt in the restaurant's music selection and overall vibe, which balances fine-dining attention to detail with an electric, house-party atmosphere.
Details
A Michelin-starred Williamsburg destination known for its electric atmosphere and eclectic, seasonally evolving New American menu [3]. The restaurant balances fine-dining attention to detail with a lively, house-party vibe, supported by a world-class wine program [3, 5]. While it remains a critical favorite and James Beard finalist, some diners find the portion sizes small and the pricing increasingly expensive [3, 40].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on understated, high-quality New American cuisine with frequent seasonal changes [3, 8]. Highly recommended dishes include the house-made bread, oeuf mayonnaise with osetra caviar, and various seafood offerings like mussels and seafood rice [3, 16, 30, 31, 40]. Some patrons, however, have criticized the value and size of specific items like oysters and spring greens [40].
Highlights / Recommended
"The house-made bread is frequently praised as a must-order, alongside the oeuf mayonnaise, Berkshire pork chop, and various seasonal seafood dishes like mussels and seafood rice [3, 8, 30, 31, 40]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •sticky toffee pudding(6)
- •oeuf mayonnaise(3)
- •seafood rice(3)
- •house bread(2)
- •rock shrimp rice(2)
Caveats
Securing a reservation is notoriously difficult, often requiring booking exactly 30 days in advance, though walk-ins can sometimes be accommodated at the bar if you arrive early [7, 8]. Some diners have noted that portion sizes can feel small and prices quite high, which may impact the overall value proposition for some guests [25, 40].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE FOUR HORSEMEN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Asked about the total bill amount for the meal at The Four Horsemen."
NeutralFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Expressed that not ordering the bread at The Four Horsemen is unthinkable."
PositiveFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Made a lighthearted comment suggesting that the high prices at The Four Horsemen are necessary for the band (presumably affiliated) to make money."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Single Best Restaurant Dish In Nyc In
"The seafood rice at The Four Horsemen is mentioned as a recommended dish."
PositiveFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Specified ordering a glass of Sommer 2003 Sauvignon Blanc for $18 at The Four Horsemen."
NeutralFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Inquired about the drinks ordered at The Four Horsemen, noting its reputation for natural wine."
NeutralFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Criticized the subreddit's focus on price complaints for a Michelin-starred restaurant like The Four Horsemen, arguing that fine dining is expensive and suggesting broader political changes are needed for lower costs."
NeutralFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Agreed that while The Four Horsemen's food is phenomenal, the portions are now 'hysterically small' and prices are 'eye watering' for them, similar to their experience at I Cavallini."
NegativeFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Questioned the pricing at The Four Horsemen, specifically mentioning the $26 spring greens and $11 oysters."
NegativeFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Stated they ordered a glass of Sauvignon Blanc at The Four Horsemen, which was recommended by the server based on their preferences, and forgot which cocktail their friend ordered."
PositiveFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Stated that due to the perceived small portions and high prices at The Four Horsemen, they are priced out and do not wish to return."
NegativeFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Agreed with the previous commenter's sentiment about focusing on food over price complaints at The Four Horsemen."
PositiveFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Asked the original poster if they ordered wine at The Four Horsemen."
NeutralFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Criticized the Reddit sub for focusing on prices rather than the food at The Four Horsemen, stating that fine dining is inherently expensive and suggesting political solutions for lower restaurant costs."
NeutralFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Agreed that the butter used with the house bread at The Four Horsemen is top-notch."
PositiveFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Recounted a negative experience at The Four Horsemen where some food was so unappetizing it almost made them vomit."
NegativeFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Suggested trying the seafood rice at The Four Horsemen on a future visit."
PositiveFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Responded to a comment about chipped plates, suggesting it looks 'very wrong' and could be intentional in a place like The Four Horsemen."
NegativeFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"Asked if serving food on chipped plates is a standard practice at The Four Horsemen."
NeutralFrom post: The Four Horsemen 1 Michelin Walkin Dinner On A
"A regular at The Four Horsemen recommended trying the gnoccho if available."
Positive