Next.js logo

THE FOUR HORSEMEN

Updated

Phone: (718) 599-4900

Address: 295 GRAND STREET 11211

TLDR

Michelin-starred Williamsburg staple offering creative small plates and an expert-curated wine list in a lively, house-party atmosphere.

Reddit Sentiment for THE FOUR HORSEMEN(based on 102 Reddit opinions)

40% Positive34% Neutral25% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

1 Michelin Star
NYT Top 100

Tags

american 8new american 4wine bar 3bread 8oysters 8wine 6View All

Neighborhoods

Williamsburg

Instagram Posts References

Four Horsemen is a natural wine bar and small plates establishment that releases reservations 30 days out via Resy at 7:00 AM ET. An insider tip suggests showing up at 4:45 PM, Monday-Thursday, to name in for a table at 5 PM, guaranteeing a spot.

The Four Horsemen is featured for a corn dish, presented as one of the author's favorite corn dishes.

The Four Horsemen is a New York City restaurant that hosted students as part of the Food Education Fund's Dine Out program. This program provides students with a foundational understanding of the restaurant business through immersive experiences.

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

How to Get the Toughest Restaurant Reservations in New York
positive

A long-standing Williamsburg destination known for its exceptional food and wine, with scratch-made breads and pastas.

Deanna Ting; Ellie Plass • Aug 10, 2026
The Four Horsemen is a James Beard Outstanding Restaurant Finalist
very positive

James Beard Outstanding Restaurant finalist, The Four Horsemen, is a Williamsburg staple known for its extensive wine list and eclectic, evolving menu. Co-founder James Murphy's influence is felt in the restaurant's music selection and overall vibe, which balances fine-dining attention to detail with an electric, house-party atmosphere.

unattributed • Jun 5, 2026
The NYC Wine Hit List, Spring 2026 Edition: Stars, Il Buco, Liar Liar, and More
positive

Vicki Denig celebrates The Four Horsemen, a decade-old Williamsburg institution that remains a benchmark for inclusive, eclectic wine lists and understated cooking.

Vicki Denig • Mar 12, 2026

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is mentioned alongside others.

Mentioned In
Everywhere You'll Want to Eat in Williamsburg, Brooklyn
positive

An exploration of Williamsburg's elite dining scene highlights The Four Horsemen as one of the neighborhood's most respected rockstar restaurants.

Gabrielle Macafee • Jul 30, 2026
Mentioned In
Everywhere You'll Want to Eat in Williamsburg, Brooklyn
positive

An overview of Williamsburg's dining scene highlights The Four Horsemen as one of the neighborhood's most respected rockstar restaurants.

Gabrielle Macafee • Jul 30, 2026
Mentioned In
New York's Ultimate Cheat Sheet for Getting Into the City's Most In-Demand Restaurants
positive

The Four Horsemen is a renowned Williamsburg destination for food and wine, with reservations available 30 days in advance. Walk-ins can secure a spot by arriving early, especially at the bar.

infatuation • Jun 22, 2026
Mentioned In
The Wine Hit List: Spring 2026
positive

Vicki Denig revisits The Four Horsemen in Williamsburg, a decade-old wine bar celebrated for its inclusive wine list that bridges classic and postmodern styles, and chef Nick Curtola's understated cooking.

Vicki Denig • Mar 12, 2026
Mentioned In
New York’s Wine Hit List: Fall 2025
positive

A decade-old Williamsburg staple, The Four Horsemen, led by chef Nick Curtola and formerly wine director Justin Chearno, offers an inclusive wine list bridging classic and postmodern styles.

Vicki Denig • Oct 30, 2025
Mentioned In
Expanded Wine Hit List: 20 Entries to Match Our Expanded Resy Hit List
positive

A decade-old Williamsburg staple, The Four Horsemen, co-founded by James Murphy, maintains its strength with a Michelin star and a wine program by the late Justin Chearno that balances classic and postmodern selections.

Vicki Denig • Aug 1, 2025
Mentioned In
The 27 Best Restaurants In Williamsburg
positive

This trendy wine bar, co-owned by a musician, offers a carefully curated wine list and creative small plates in an intimate setting.

Willa Moore • Jan 21, 2022
Read More →
Infatuation
Mentioned In
The 38 Best Restaurants in New York City
positive

A celebrated Williamsburg wine bar and restaurant that masterfully balances a high-end natural wine program with Michelin-worthy food.

Melissa McCart; Nadia Chaudhury • Jul 11, 2017

Details

A staple of the Williamsburg dining scene, this Michelin-starred [3] spot balances a refined, house-party atmosphere with highly creative, seasonally evolving cuisine [1]. Chef Nick Curtola leads a kitchen celebrated for its innovative small plates, including signature dishes like oeuf mayonnaise with squid ink and osetra caviar [1]. The restaurant has earned long-standing acclaim for its inclusive and expert-curated wine program [2], solidifying its place as a premier destination for both food and wine enthusiasts [5].

Food Overview

The menu features a frequently changing selection of refined, New American small plates [9], [10], with high marks for the house-made bread [1] and the Berkshire pork chop paired with pickled strawberries [1]. While many dishes like the seafood rice and squid dishes are frequently praised [1], some recent diners have found specific items like risotto and salads underwhelming or poorly executed [14].

Customer Sentiment

While many diners describe the restaurant as an exceptional, top-tier dining experience [1], others express frustration with rising prices, small portion sizes, and significant difficulty in securing reservations [6].

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    sticky toffee pudding
    6 mentions
  • 02
    seafood rice
    4 mentions
  • 03
    oeuf mayonnaise
    3 mentions
  • 04
    house bread
    2 mentions
  • 05
    rock shrimp rice
    2 mentions
  • 06
    risotto
    2 mentions

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About THE FOUR HORSEMEN

A detailed account of a successful walk-in experience, highlighting recommended dishes like the Berkshire Porkchop and the Chocolate Olive Oil Cake while offering advice on the waitlist strategy.
This post captures a mixed perspective, with the original author feeling underwhelmed by certain dishes while other community members defend the restaurant's quality and service.
A helpful discussion thread providing insider tips on how to successfully walk into the restaurant for a meal, including optimal arrival times for the bar seating.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Under The Radar Holy St Howdidyoufindthis Dinner

"A Brooklyn restaurant mentioned by a local."

Neutral
Sep 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cuisinesdishes In Nyc That I Cant Find In Toronto

"Mentioned for having a great wine list."

Positive
Sep 10, 2026View Comment →

From post: Place With Hard Reservations But Doable Walk Ins

"The user has had success walking in by arriving close to the restaurant's opening time."

Positive
Aug 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Snagged Il Cavallini For Tonight What Are The

"The user considers this restaurant superior to Il Cavallini."

Positive
Aug 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Are Some Unusual Things That Restaurants In

"The restaurant offers interesting food combinations that are well-executed, specifically a boiled egg and squid ink dish."

Positive
Aug 14, 2026View Comment →

Often mentioned with The Four Horsemen

More in Williamsburg

See all

More American in NYC

See all