NYC's best? Unique New Am. dishes like sticky toffee pudding & grilled swordfish. A truly special dining experience.
This Brooklyn gem is celebrated for its exceptional New American cuisine, consistently delivering a top-tier dining experience that many consider the best in the city. Diners rave about standout dishes like the grilled swordfish and the decadent sticky toffee pudding, with the house sourdough bread also earning high praise. While reservations can be challenging, the unique flavors and attentive service make it a must-visit.
The New American cuisine here is highly acclaimed, with dishes like the grilled swordfish, veal medallions, and the standout sticky toffee pudding frequently mentioned as must-tries. The house sourdough bread is also a consistent favorite. While most feedback is overwhelmingly positive, a few comments suggest that some dishes can be underwhelming or that portions might be small for the price.
"Highly recommended dishes include the grilled swordfish, veal medallions, and the sticky toffee pudding. The house sourdough bread is also a frequently praised item."
Customers overwhelmingly praise this restaurant, with many calling it their favorite in the city and citing it as the best dining experience they've had. Standout dishes and excellent wine selection are frequently mentioned, though some note challenges with reservations and occasional service inconsistencies.
Important Note
Reservations can be very difficult to secure, and some diners have experienced issues with service or found certain dishes to be underwhelming or overpriced.
"Four Horsemen is mentioned as a highly anticipated restaurant with attainable reservations."
Positive"The commenter expressed difficulty in getting a table, recalling a positive solo walk-in experience years ago but being unable to return due to booking issues."
Neutral"The commenter expressed a negative sentiment towards the restaurant, calling it overrated."
Negative"The commenter inquired if the wine list consisted of natural wines, expressing that it might be a deal-breaker for them."
Neutral"The commenter is planning a visit in a few weeks and is asking about reservation methods, as they have found no availability."
Neutral"The commenter felt hungry after their meal, implying the portions were small. They later mentioned ordering plenty but still stopped for pizza afterwards."
Negative"The commenter expressed strong disapproval of the $56 chicken dish price, calling it preposterous."
Negative"The commenter believes the restaurant deserves three Michelin stars."
Positive"This commenter described the restaurant as having great food, wine, and vibes, calling it the perfect restaurant."
Positive"The commenter had their best meal in NYC at this restaurant and specifically mentioned dreaming about the fig leaf panna cotta."
Positive"The commenter noted the price of a specific dish, the chicken, which was $56. They also mentioned a dish with crab for $34."
Neutral"The commenter was inquiring about the availability of merchandise, specifically if there was any in-store merchandise different from what's online."
Neutral"The commenter praised the bread served at the restaurant, stating it was worth going again just for that."
Positive"This commenter considers The Four Horseman their favorite restaurant globally and initially wanted to gatekeep it due to increasing difficulty in getting reservations, but believes people should know about it."
Positive"The commenter is eager to visit the restaurant soon and is seeking tips on how to secure a table, having had no luck so far."
Neutral"A humorous and enthusiastic comment about the restaurant."
Positive"The original poster had a phenomenal experience at The Four Horseman and added it to their list of starred restaurants. They enjoyed the menu's frequent changes and plan to return for dinner soon."
Positive
