TLDR
Highly-regarded biscuits and sandwiches in a casual setting. Beloved for their bake quality but often criticized for steep prices and messy presentation.
Details
This Brooklyn spot is celebrated for its high-quality biscuits and sandwiches, drawing locals looking for a quick bite [1]. However, the experience often polarizes diners, who frequently cite issues with value, messy presentation, and high price points [1]. While the coffee is a reliable staple, some find the overall atmosphere and pricing to be underwhelming [1].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American staples, featuring standout biscuits and sandwiches [1]. While many enjoy the food, customers have expressed disappointment with the bread-to-filling ratios and the construction of certain items like the omelette and sandwiches, which some find overly heavy or difficult to eat [1]. Coffee is noted as a highlight [1].
The biscuits are frequently praised as amazing [1], and the sandwich is recommended when served on a Portuguese muffin rather than a biscuit [1].
Visitor experiences are highly mixed, with strong praise for the food quality contrasted by frequent complaints regarding the high pricing and underwhelming value [1]. Some guests have also noted frustrations with the owner's defensive attitude and the overall practicality of the menu items [1].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01sandwich2 mentions
Caveats
Several diners feel the restaurant is overpriced [1], and others note that the presentation of dishes can be messy or structurally impractical [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About POPPY'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Wedding After Party Bites
"Suggested as a potential catering option in the Carroll Gardens/Downtown Brooklyn area, with uncertainty regarding late-night hours."
NeutralFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user dislikes the restaurant due to high prices and the owner's defensive attitude."
NegativeFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user finds the food decent but feels the restaurant is way overpriced."
NeutralFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user loves the sandwich and thinks the biscuit is amazing."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user generally enjoys the egg sandwich on a biscuit but thinks the original poster's version used too much bread."
Positive