TLDR
Polarizing American breakfast spot in Brooklyn known for its debated biscuit sandwiches and highly-regarded scones. A trendy destination for those seeking unconventional cafe fare.
Details
Known for its unique American breakfast offerings, this Brooklyn spot attracts mixed reviews regarding its high price point and polarizing sandwich construction [1]. While some patrons appreciate the quality of their biscuits and scones [2], others find the dishes impractical or underwhelming given the cost [1, 3]. It remains a topic of spirited debate among locals for its unconventional approach to casual fare [1].
Food Overview
The menu features American cafe staples, with high praise for their scones [2] and biscuits [4]. However, the signature egg sandwiches have drawn criticism for being messy, overly heavy, or difficult to eat [1, 5], with some guests suggesting alternatives like the Portuguese muffin [6]. While the coffee is generally well-received [7], the overall food experience is often hindered by the high price-to-value ratio [3].
Caveats
Several diners caution that the restaurant can be expensive and may feel underwhelming to those expecting a traditional, convenient corner deli experience [1, 3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About POPPY'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user dislikes the restaurant due to high prices and the owner's defensive attitude."
NegativeFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user finds the food decent but feels the restaurant is way overpriced."
NeutralFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user loves the sandwich and thinks the biscuit is amazing."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user generally enjoys the egg sandwich on a biscuit but thinks the original poster's version used too much bread."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user dislikes the restaurant, citing it as expensive and underwhelming."
NegativeFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user thinks the restaurant tries too hard, though the coffee is good."
NeutralFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user suggests the sandwich is better on a Portuguese muffin."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user describes the sandwich appearance as comically heavy or messy."
NegativeFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The commenter makes a joke about the visual presentation of the omelette."
NegativeFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user enjoys the restaurant but notes that calling it a 'corner deli' is misleading."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfast Sandwich At Poppys Brooklyn 2 Eggs
"The user questions how to eat the sandwich, comparing it to an inverted benedict."
NegativeFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Scones In
"Mentioned as a recommendation for scones."
Neutral