TLDR
Unhyped neighborhood fave. Reliable, consistent pizza slices perfect for a quick bite. A local go-to for classic Italian-American pizza.
Details
This neighborhood gem offers a consistent and reliable slice of pizza, earning its place as a beloved local favorite. It's the kind of unhyped spot that locals cherish, perfect for a quick, satisfying bite without any pretense. If you're in the mood for classic Italian-American pizza, this pizzeria delivers a dependable and tasty experience.
Caveats
The pizzeria closes at 10 PM. A former resident noted the nearby Regal cinema, which has since closed.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MY LITTLE PIZZERIA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Pizza Suggestions Boerum Hill
"Recommends My Little Pizzeria on Court Street near Atlantic Ave for a good, solid slice of pizza that isn't fancy or requiring reservations."
PositiveFrom post: Sals Pizza Boston
"This user mentioned My Little Pizzeria in Brooklyn as a place that satisfied their craving for a pizza similar to Sal's in Boston. They noted it has a good crust, though they haven't found a place with a fluffy crust yet."
PositiveFrom post: Ginos Italian Ices
"The user is confident that My Little Pizzeria on Court St. in Brooklyn Heights continues to sell Gino's Italian Ices."
NeutralFrom post: Something Quick To Grab And Go In Brooklyn
"Recommends 'My little pizzeria' near Borough Hall station for a pretty good and consistent slice of pizza, noting it closes at 10 PM."
PositiveFrom post: Shoutout To The Unhyped Independent Neighborhood
"A user called My Little Pizzeria 'absolutely goated' and shared fond memories of going there after movies at the nearby Regal cinema (now closed)."
Positive