Next.js logo

NOODLE PUDDING

Updated

Phone: (201) 410-1296

Address: 38 HENRY STREET 11201

View on Google Maps

TLDR

A quintessential, cash-only neighborhood classic in Brooklyn Heights offering top-tier red sauce Italian fare and nostalgic, old-school vibes.

Reddit Sentiment for NOODLE PUDDING(based on 13 Reddit opinions)

85% Positive15% Neutral

Tags

italian 9italian-american 3italian 6pasta 5red sauce 3View All

Neighborhoods

Brooklyn Heights

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

Noodle Pudding Is NYC’s Ideal Neighborhood Restaurant
positive

Noodle Pudding is a quintessentially friendly Brooklyn Heights Italian spot that has been a neighborhood fixture since 1995, offering generous portions and a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for groups.

• Jul 1, 2026
Read More →
Eater
The 26 best Italian restaurants in NYC
positive

Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights is a rewarding dining experience, known for its excellent rice balls, carpaccio, and pasta, though it has payment and reservation restrictions.

Amber Sutherland-Namako & Morgan Carter • Sep 17, 2024
Read More →
Infatuation

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is mentioned alongside others.

Mentioned In
positive

A cash-only Italian spot in Brooklyn Heights that allows reservations for larger groups, known for martinis and a festive atmosphere.

Bryan Kim • Nov 5, 2024
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

A Brooklyn Heights staple since 1995, this beloved spot offers a warm, nostalgic atmosphere where large windows open onto the street and fan art adorns the walls [2]. It is widely celebrated as an outstanding Italian restaurant that captures a genuine old-school New York vibe [4], [6]. Diners consistently praise the high-quality menu, which features excellent daily specials and thoughtful, seasonal preparations [2], [7].

Food Overview

This restaurant specializes in classic, red-sauce Italian cuisine, with a menu frequently lauded for its generous portion sizes and fresh flavors [2]. Highly regarded items include rice balls, carpaccio, and various expertly prepared pasta dishes [1]. Diners appreciate unique seasonal offerings like spaghetti with bread crumbs and ramps when available [5].

Highlights / Recommended

Highly recommended dishes include the burrata on country bread, meatballs in red sauce, and the bucatini all'cacio e pepe featuring zucchini and an egg yolk [2]. Guests also enjoy the creamy tiramisu and a notoriously well-prepared very-dirty gin martini [2].

Customer Sentiment

Patrons overwhelmingly recommend this spot for its friendly service, communal atmosphere, and excellent overall value [2], [7]. Feedback is consistently positive, though visitors should be prepared for the restaurant's cash-only policy [2], [8].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About NOODLE PUDDING

Best affordable Italian restaurant NYC?
This thread features a strong consensus recommending this spot for its authentic red sauce Italian cuisine, reasonable prices, and classic neighborhood atmosphere.
Dinner suggestions cobble hillish area?
A helpful discussion identifying the restaurant as an outstanding Italian destination while emphasizing the importance of arriving prepared for a cash-only, no-reservation policy.
Seasonal ramp dishes?
This post highlights the restaurant's commitment to seasonal ingredients, specifically noting their spaghetti dish prepared with ramps.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Under The Radar Holy St Howdidyoufindthis Dinner

"Cash-only local favorite in Brooklyn Heights."

Neutral
Sep 18, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Are Some Decent Restaurants With Cheap House

"The original poster mentioned Noodle Pudding as an example of a restaurant with good house wine pours at a low price point, specifically mentioning $5 house pours of Montepulciano."

Positive
Jun 5, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where To Get Dinner Near St Anns Warehouse In

"Noodle Pudding is suggested as a dining option in Brooklyn Heights."

Positive
May 19, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where To Get Dinner Near St Anns Warehouse In

"Noodle Pudding is recommended."

Positive
May 19, 2026View Comment →

From post: Last Visit Before 1st Baby Lower Manhattan Or

"Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights is recommended for pasta and good vibes at a fair price, noting it is cash only."

Positive
May 16, 2026View Comment →

More in Brooklyn Heights

See all

More Italian in NYC

See all