Juicy Peruvian rotisserie chicken w/ aji verde sauce & vibrant ceviche. NYC staple w/ amazing prices.
This Peruvian rotisserie chicken spot is a beloved New York institution, praised for its consistently juicy and flavorful chicken, often served with a signature aji verde sauce. Diners also rave about their ceviche, salads, and sides like plantains. It's a go-to for a reason, offering great value and a taste of authentic Peruvian cuisine.
The star of the show is the Peruvian rotisserie chicken, consistently described as juicy and flavorful, often paired with a signature aji verde sauce. Other popular dishes include various ceviche options and avocado salads. While generally well-received, there are minor mentions of inconsistency in side dishes like plantains.
"The rotisserie chicken, especially with the aji verde sauce, is a must-try. Other highly recommended items include ceviche, avocado salad, salchipapas, and plantains."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the restaurant for its delicious and well-prepared Peruvian rotisserie chicken, often highlighting the flavorful sauces and good value. While most feedback is positive, some mention occasional inconsistencies in side dishes.
Important Note
One user expressed confusion about the restaurant's focus, questioning why a place known for chicken also serves ceviche. Another commenter was surprised by the lack of a specific Peruvian yellow sauce, only finding green and garlic options.
"Pio Pio is recommended for chicken and their garlic sauce."
Positive"This restaurant is listed as a recommendation."
Positive"Pio Pio is described as a New Yorker staple that remains popular and holds up well over time, offering amazing prices and great food."
Positive"The commenter mentions that Pio Pio's green sauce is also noteworthy."
Positive"Pio Pio is consistently loved, especially for its green sauce, although the maduros can occasionally be inconsistent."
Positive"Seconding the recommendation for Pio Pio, stating it is solid."
Positive"This user disagrees with a comparison of Claudy's to Pio Pio, stating that Pio Pio has much better distinct Peruvian roast chicken flavors."
Negative"Pio Pio is recommended for rotisserie chicken."
Positive"Pio Pio is listed as a recommendation for rotisserie chicken in Manhattan."
Neutral"Pio Pio is recommended as the best rotisserie chicken in the city, also mentioning their green sauce."
Positive"This user seconds the recommendation for Pio Pio 8, noting it's one of the few places in the area that can easily handle larger group sizes."
Positive"This user suggests Pio Pio 8 as a possible restaurant that might be able to accommodate a group of 5-10 people."
Neutral"The user finds Pio Pio's lunch special to be an excellent value, as it provides enough food to stretch into multiple meals."
Positive"Pio Pio is highlighted as a favorite for Peruvian chicken, especially for delivery and leftovers."
Positive"This user expresses confusion and mild frustration that Pio Pio, a place known for chicken, also serves ceviche, feeling it lacks a clear focus."
Negative"This user recommends Pio Pio for its avocado salad, in addition to its more commonly known chicken dishes."
Positive"A user suggests that Pio Pio is primarily known for its chicken with green sauce, implying it might not be the best choice for ceviche."
Neutral"The original poster found the mixto ceviche tasty enough but was disappointed by the small quantity."
Neutral"The author recommends Pio Pio for delivery as it travels well. They highlight the Peruvian chicken, green sauce, salchipapas, and plantains."
Positive"The user was shocked that Pio Pio did not have the Peruvian yellow sauce they were looking for, only offering clear garlic or green sauces instead."
Negative
