Next.js logo

CAFE BAR J.F

Updated

Phone: (718) 387-3434

Address: 50 WITHERS STREET 11211

TLDR

Formerly a beloved Peruvian staple known for its bright ceviches, inventive mezcal cocktails, and standout key lime pie.

Reddit Sentiment for CAFE BAR J.F(based on 8 Reddit opinions)

50% Positive25% Neutral25% Negative

Tags

peruvian 7peruvian food 3View All

Neighborhoods

Williamsburg

Details

Once a celebrated destination for vibrant Peruvian flavors in Brooklyn, this spot was highly regarded for its creative take on Latin American cuisine [3]. Guests particularly enjoyed the acidic ceviches and unique beverage pairings like the mezcal shooter with a leche de tigre chaser [3]. It was even noted for serving a key lime pie that reportedly bested many Florida classics [4]. Unfortunately, the restaurant is no longer in business [8].

Food Overview

The kitchen focused on Peruvian-inspired dishes, earning specific praise for its acidic ceviches [3]. The dessert menu was also a highlight, featuring a highly acclaimed key lime pie that drew comparisons to the best versions found in Florida [4].

Customer Sentiment

Patrons held this establishment in high regard for its high-quality food and unique menu offerings [3], [4]. Despite its popularity, there is general disappointment and confusion regarding its closure [6], [7].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About CAFE BAR J.F

A user highlights the restaurant's key lime pie, claiming it is superior to most options found in Florida.
A positive review praising the ceviche and the unique mezcal shooter with a leche de tigre chaser.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Do Yall Have Any Peruvian Restaurants You Swear By

"The restaurant is no longer in business."

Neutral
Aug 24, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Peruvian In The City

"This user expressed sadness and surprise upon hearing Llama Inn might have closed."

Negative
Apr 4, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Peruvian In The City

"This user reacted with 'pain' to the mention of Llama Inn, implying it might be closed or have issues."

Negative
Apr 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Peruvian In The City

"This user mentioned Llama Inn as a place that could have been in the conversation for best Peruvian food."

Neutral
Apr 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Key Lime Pie In Nyc

"This user, identifying as a 'big time key lime pie guy', stated that Llama Inn, a Peruvian restaurant, has a Key Lime Pie that surpasses most options available in Florida."

Positive
Nov 15, 2025View Comment →

More in Williamsburg

See all

More Peruvian in NYC

See all