TLDR
Distinguished by St. Louis-style pizza with provel cheese, this Brooklyn favorite is a go-to for unique pies and kid-friendly buttered noodles.
Details
Known for its unique St. Louis-style pies featuring provel cheese, this Brooklyn destination has become a frequent repeat spot for many locals [1], [2]. While the menu includes well-regarded specialties like the 'white album' and 'kind brother' pizzas, the restaurant has faced recent scrutiny regarding service consistency and order accuracy [3], [4]. Despite these challenges, the oven-cooked wings remain a standout favorite among returning guests [5].
Food Overview
The menu centers on pizza, specifically the St. Louis-style variety topped with provel cheese, alongside hits like the 'white album' and 'kind brother' pizzas [1], [3]. While the pizza is often labeled as decent, feedback suggests the oven-cooked wings are a superior highlight [5]. Parents also appreciate the availability of buttered noodles as a kid-friendly option [6].
Highlights / Recommended
"The 'white album' and 'kind brother' pizzas are highly recommended by regulars [1]. For a lighter or non-pizza option, the oven-cooked wings are consistently praised [5]."
Customer Sentiment
Customer sentiment is notably mixed, with many patrons enjoying the food while others report significant frustration with service lapses and incorrect delivery orders [4]. Frequent mentions of poor host interactions and inconsistent table service have caused some diners to stop returning [5].
Caveats
Diners should be aware that delivery orders have been reported as frequently incorrect [4]. Additionally, those seeking a traditional NYC-style pizza may find this establishment's style distinct and not to their preference [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SPEEDY ROMEO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Slice Of Pizza In Prospect Heightsft
"This commenter is surprised Speedy Romeo hasn't been mentioned and stated it was decent the last time they visited a couple of years ago."
NeutralFrom post: Whats Your Nemesis Spot In Nyc
"The user feels that for the price, better pizza options exist than at Speedy Romeo's, although they acknowledge the oven-cooked wings are good."
NegativeFrom post: Whats Your Nemesis Spot In Nyc
"The oven-cooked wings at Speedy Romeo's are considered better than their pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Nemesis Spot In Nyc
"Speedy Romeo's pizza was tasty, but delivery orders were consistently incorrect to a comical degree."
NegativeFrom post: Whats Your Nemesis Spot In Nyc
"While Speedy Romeo's pizza is good, the service can be inconsistent, ranging from fine to terrible, with instances of servers forgetting orders. However, the user doesn't consider it a 'nemesis spot' due to the food quality."
NeutralFrom post: Whats Your Nemesis Spot In Nyc
"Speedy Romeo's pizza was decent but not exceptional, and a negative experience with a rude host led the user to stop returning."
NegativeFrom post: Brooklyn Food Recs Needed
"Speedy Romeo is listed as a restaurant recommendation, potentially in or near Fort Greene."
NeutralFrom post: Any Great Pizzerias In Brooklyn With A Decent
"This user commented that Speedy Romeo is not close to NYC-style pizza."
NegativeFrom post: Any Great Pizzerias In Brooklyn With A Decent
"The user listed Speedy Romeo as a recommendation for a pizzeria in Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza Thats Little Different
"Speedy Romeo is mentioned for still doing St. Louis style pizza with provel cheese."
NeutralFrom post: Buttered Noodles In Manhattan
"This commenter mentioned Speedy Romeo as having buttered noodles available as a kids' dish, which they frequently enjoy when their children order it."
PositiveFrom post: Go To Repeat Restaurant
"This restaurant is listed as a repeat spot in Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: In Your Opinion Where Is The Best Pizza Bianca In
"The commenter also mentioned the 'white album' or 'kind brother' at Speedy Romeos as being good, though different."
Positive