TLDR
St. Louis-style pizza with provel cheese and standout oven-cooked wings in Brooklyn. A distinctive alternative to the typical NYC slice.
Details
Known for its unique St. Louis-style pizza served with provel cheese [3], this Brooklyn establishment remains a frequent recommendation for those seeking a different pizza experience [4], [13]. While the oven-cooked wings consistently earn praise [7], [8], [10], [11], experiences with the restaurant are often polarized due to concerns over value [10] and inconsistent service [7], [8]. Despite some critiques regarding its departure from traditional NYC-style pizza [5], it remains a staple for many locals [1].
Food Overview
The kitchen specializes in St. Louis-style pies topped with provel cheese [3], [13], which some diners find to be a refreshing change while others note it does not align with classic NYC-style expectations [5]. Oven-cooked wings are a frequent highlight and often receive higher praise than the pizza itself [10], [11]. Families also appreciate menu staples like the buttered noodles for children [2].
Highlights / Recommended
"The oven-cooked wings are widely recommended by patrons [7], [10], [11], and the St. Louis-style pizza serves as the restaurant's signature dish [3], [13]."
Customer Sentiment
Feedback is notably mixed, with loyal fans appreciating the consistent menu offerings [1], [2] while others report frustration over service reliability and delivery errors [7], [8], [9]. Some patrons feel that the overall value does not always meet expectations for the price point [10].
Caveats
Potential diners should be aware that delivery orders have been reported as frequently incorrect [9], and those specifically seeking authentic NYC-style thin crust may find the St. Louis-style approach disappointing [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SPEEDY ROMEO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Different Pizza Styles Chicago
"Recommended as a spot for St. Louis style pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Best Slice Of Pizza In Prospect Heightsft
"This commenter is surprised Speedy Romeo hasn't been mentioned and stated it was decent the last time they visited a couple of years ago."
NeutralFrom post: Whats Your Nemesis Spot In Nyc
"The user feels that for the price, better pizza options exist than at Speedy Romeo's, although they acknowledge the oven-cooked wings are good."
NegativeFrom post: Whats Your Nemesis Spot In Nyc
"The oven-cooked wings at Speedy Romeo's are considered better than their pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Nemesis Spot In Nyc
"Speedy Romeo's pizza was tasty, but delivery orders were consistently incorrect to a comical degree."
Negative