Huge family-style Italian feasts w/ tons of food meant for sharing! Kid-friendly, festive, and v. popular for groups.
This Italian-American institution is famous for its massive, family-style portions designed for sharing. Expect generous servings of classic red-sauce dishes, perfect for feeding a crowd. While some may find it a bit touristy, many rave about the hearty, flavorful food and the lively atmosphere, making it a go-to for celebrations and group gatherings.
The restaurant specializes in Italian-American cuisine with a strong emphasis on family-style, shareable portions. Dishes are known for being plentiful, with many recommending the pasta, chicken parm, and other classic red-sauce favorites. Some reviews note that the food can be a bit heavy or geared towards a less discerning palate, while others firmly defend its quality and value for group dining.
"The restaurant is known for its family-style portions of classic Italian-American dishes. Pasta dishes, chicken parm, and ragu are frequently mentioned positively."
Customers generally praise the generous portions and family-style experience, making it ideal for groups and celebrations. While some acknowledge it can be touristy, the overall sentiment leans positive, with many finding the food hearty and satisfying.
Important Note
Some find the restaurant to be overly touristy and the atmosphere can be quite loud, which might not be ideal for intimate conversations.
"This user listed Carmine's as a potential option for family-style Italian dining."
Positive"This user recommended Carmine's for a bachelorette party, highlighting its huge family-style portions which are great for large groups."
Positive"Carmine's is a popular choice for large families due to its family-style portions, though it can be noisy."
Positive"Carmine's in Times Square is recommended."
Neutral"Carmine's is suggested as a dining option."
Neutral"The commenter feels Carmine's isn't a good value, noting that a single portion of seafood pasta costs around $50, which could buy several pasta dishes elsewhere with similar food volume."
Negative"The commenter used to be able to finish an order of ravioli solo, even after eating a lot of bread, stunning their dining companions and waiters. They acknowledge this has changed with time."
Positive"The commenter's family visited Carmine's, and the commenter was able to eat the leftovers for several days."
Positive"The commenter recommended Carmine's or Tony's for Italian food, or a vegetarian Indian buffet like Bukhara."
Neutral"The commenter simply suggested Carmine's."
Neutral"Carmine's was suggested as a dining option that might fit the user's budget for a group of six, implying it's a cost-effective choice for family-style Italian."
Neutral"This commenter suggested Carmine's as an alternative to Tony's Di Napoli, but also noted that either restaurant might be a waste of food and money for only two people."
Negative"This commenter suggested Carmine's for its nostalgia."
Positive"This commenter mentioned Carmine's Italian Seafood with aRIP, indicating it was a great fit for the request for red sauce Italian."
Neutral"This user suggested Carmines for meatballs, implying it's a place where one can get a large portion."
Positive"The user suggested Carmine's as a potential option for a large group dining in midtown."
Neutral"Carmine's is recommended for its large, family-style portions, suggesting it's great for groups. The ragu and lasagna are specifically mentioned as good options, and the commenter notes the restaurant has a lot of cheese, which might be a plus for some."
Positive"Carmine's offers huge portions that can feed four people and is described as a great 'business dinner' spot."
Neutral"The user expresses enthusiasm for Carmine's, finding it looks very good and is willing to try a large portion even with just two people."
Positive"The commenter explains that Carmine's portions are family-style and can feed about 3 people, making it potentially viable for two if they can pack leftovers. They consider it a quintessential NYC Italian place."
Positive
