Huge, shareable Italian feast in Times Square - family-style portions that feed a crowd!
This iconic Italian-American restaurant is a go-to for groups and families seeking a lively dining experience in the heart of Manhattan's Theater District. Known for its generous, family-style portions, Carmine's offers a taste of classic comfort food that's perfect for sharing. While some may find it to be a tourist hotspot, many praise its festive atmosphere and reliably delicious, hearty dishes that evoke a sense of nostalgia.
This restaurant serves generous, family-style portions of classic Italian-American cuisine. Dishes like pasta are frequently highlighted as must-tries. While many appreciate the hearty, shareable meals, a few reviews suggest it caters heavily to tourists and might not be the top choice for discerning foodies.
"Pasta dishes are frequently mentioned as a highlight, and the 'Frozen Cosmo' is noted as a recommended drink."
Overall, customers have a positive view of the restaurant, often recommending it for its family-style portions and festive atmosphere, though some note it can be loud and touristy.
Important Note
The restaurant is often described as loud and a 'tourist trap'. Some reviews suggest the food quality might not be top-tier, and it can be quite pricey.
"Carmines is listed as a kid-friendly dining option, suitable for when the focus is on ensuring a child has a good time rather than fine dining."
Positive"Carmines is described as a great option for a picky eater, specifically mentioning a 12-year-old."
Positive"The commenter listed Carmine's as a recommendation for Italian food near the theater district that allows casual dress code."
Positive"This restaurant was recommended as a potential option for a large group dinner."
Neutral"Carmine's is considered a tourist trap but has good food and fun family-style service suitable for large groups."
Positive"Carmine's is recommended for the Times Square area, noting its family-style service for larger groups."
Positive"Carmine's is mentioned, with a suggestion to go to 9th Avenue where there are many restaurants."
Neutral"Carmine's is recommended as a suitable option for large groups."
Positive"This commenter believes Carmine's is the best choice for the request, despite being a bit of a tourist trap, due to its good food and fun family-style service for larger groups."
Positive"Carmine's or Patsy's are suggested as good options."
Neutral"This commenter prefers Carmine's over Tony's Di Napoli for red sauce Italian."
Positive"Carmines is suggested as a dining option."
Positive"Carmine's is a great choice, with large portions where one dish can serve 2-3 people. It's also conveniently located near transit lines."
Positive"Carmine's is suggested as a potential restaurant for a corporate dinner."
Positive"Carmine's was suggested for its family-style service, allowing guests to choose a few dishes."
Positive"This comment agrees with the suggestion of Carmine's, stating that either location can easily accommodate 15 people."
Positive"This comment suggests Carmine's as another option for groups, mentioning that both Lamella and Carmine's can be family-style."
Neutral"Carmines was suggested as a dining option."
Neutral"Carmine's is presented as a family-style NYC staple with huge portions, located conveniently between Hell's Kitchen and Times Square."
Neutral"Carmine's in Midtown is listed as a larger family-style Italian restaurant option."
Neutral
