Massive family-style Italian feasts in a lively, loud, and festive atmosphere. Perfect for groups seeking generous portions of comfort food.
This beloved Italian institution is a go-to spot for group dining, serving up enormous, family-style portions of classic Italian-American comfort food. Expect a lively, festive atmosphere that, while sometimes loud, is perfect for celebrations and gatherings. It's a place where generous servings and a communal dining experience are paramount, making it a solid choice for those seeking hearty, shareable meals.
This Italian restaurant is known for its family-style dining with massive, shareable portions of classic Italian-American dishes. While many praise the food, especially pasta, some consider it a bit heavy or geared towards tourists. The 'Frozen Cosmo' is a uniquely recommended drink.
"The restaurant is celebrated for its family-style Italian-American cuisine with large portions perfect for sharing. The 'Frozen Cosmo' is a specifically recommended drink."
Customers generally have positive experiences, often recommending it for groups and families due to its generous, family-style portions and festive atmosphere. However, some note it can be loud and a bit touristy.
Important Note
The restaurant can be quite loud, which may not be ideal for intimate conversations. It's also noted by some as being a bit touristy.
"Carmine's is presented as a family-style NYC staple with huge portions, located conveniently between Hell's Kitchen and Times Square."
Neutral"Carmine's in Midtown is listed as a larger family-style Italian restaurant option."
Neutral"Carmine's is described as touristy with fatty, glutinous, oversized portions that cater to visitors seeking "authentic Italian.""
Negative"Carmine's is mentioned as having really good, home-style food served family-style in giant portions. They have a location between Hell's Kitchen and Times Square."
Positive"This commenter suggested Carmine's for an immersive murder mystery dinner, which offers a unique dining experience."
Positive"This user recommended Carmine's as a good option for a large family group with young children. They highlighted that the restaurant accepts reservations and serves family-style Italian food."
Positive"Carmine's in Times Square is recommended for a great family Italian meal."
Positive"Carmine's is described as a delighted and very kid-friendly restaurant where loudness is acceptable."
Positive"Defending the earlier suggestion, the user states that while Carmine's is touristy, the food is not 'slop' and the ambiance is loud but festive, noting good experiences over 20 years and its convenience for Broadway shows."
Neutral"Carmines is suggested for its convenient location in Times Square, good food and service, and festive, albeit loud, ambiance. Portions are large and meant for sharing, and it is considered pricey."
Neutral"The commenter lists Carmine's as a place tourists might go."
Neutral"Carmine's was recommended as a family-friendly restaurant that can cater to children."
Positive"Carmine's was recommended as a suitable family restaurant."
Positive"The original poster explicitly states that they are not interested in Carmine's for their large group birthday dinner, suggesting it does not fit their specific requirements for the occasion."
Negative"Carmine's is recommended as a restaurant that specializes in accommodating group dining. It is considered a good choice for those looking to book large parties."
Positive"The user laments 'Carmine's erasure' from the list, implying it should have been included."
Positive"In response to a suggestion for Carmine's, the replier warns that the restaurant is very loud, which could hinder conversation."
Negative"The commenter suggests Carmine's for a group but notes that the food is not the greatest."
Negative"Suggests Carmine's as a classic spot for family-style Italian food, conveniently located in Midtown."
Positive"Carmines is a tourist spot but still legit good, family style."
Positive
