Long-standing SoHo spot w/ classic heroes & amazing smoked turkey sammies. Solid lunch, great soup & sandwich combos.
This SoHo staple has been serving up deliciousness for a while, making it a solid lunch option for locals and visitors alike. While not necessarily a destination spot, it offers quality fare that stands the test of time. Reviewers praise the smoked turkey sandwich and the olive's hero, often enjoyed as a satisfying soup-and-sandwich combo.
This establishment is known for its sandwiches, particularly the smoked turkey sandwich which is frequently recommended. The 'Olive's Hero' is also a popular choice, often paired with soup for a satisfying meal. While the food is considered good and solid, some reviewers note it's not 'mind-blowing,' and one commenter found the bread crust difficult to eat.
"The smoked turkey sandwich is a standout, often praised for its ingredients. The 'Olive's Hero' sandwich, especially when combined with soup, is also a highly recommended and satisfying option."
Customers generally view this restaurant as a reliable and solid lunch option, with specific praise for their sandwiches and soup combinations, though some find it a bit pricey for the area.
Important Note
One diner found the bread crust on their sandwich to be too hard to eat comfortably. There's also a mention of a 'SoHo premium' which might indicate higher prices.
"In response to a comment about the bread crust, the author agreed it was difficult to handle, humorously noting that soaking it in soup made it easier to eat."
Neutral"This commenter appreciated Olive's half sandwich option but found the bread crust too hard to eat comfortably, especially with a smaller portion."
Negative"Responding to a comparison with M&O sandwiches, the author stated that while they'd choose M&O for just a sandwich, Olive's is preferred for their soup-and-sandwich combo."
Positive"This commenter used to eat at Olive's often when working in SoHo and noted its longevity suggests quality. They consider it a solid lunch option for those in the area, though not a destination place."
Positive"Initially lukewarm on Olive's, the author found the food quality good, though not mindblowing. They enjoyed a split pea and ham soup with half an Olive's Hero (coppa, salami, provolone, olive tapenade, etc.) on sourdough, deeming it solid despite the SoHo premium."
Positive"The commenter recommends Olive's for its cowboy and cowgirl cookies."
Positive"Olive's serves a solid smoked turkey sandwich with bacon, avocado mayo, lettuce, and tomato on sourdough. While tasty, it wasn't described as mind-blowing."
Neutral"The smoked turkey sandwich from Olive's in SoHo is highly recommended."
Positive"The user mentioned trying Olive for Korean fried chicken, implying it's a known option in their experience."
Neutral
