TLDR
A SoHo staple for decades, offering quality sandwiches & soups [1]. Solid lunch spot, not a destination, but reliable [2]. Known for their smoked turkey sandwich and a tasty half-sandwich option [1, 3].
Details
Olive's is a long-standing establishment in SoHo, New York City, known for its solid sandwiches and comforting soups [1]. While not always groundbreaking, the quality of their offerings, like the smoked turkey sandwich with bacon and avocado mayo on sourdough, is consistently good [1]. They also offer a popular half-sandwich option, though some find the bread crust challenging to eat [2, 3].
Food Overview
Olive's is recognized for its sandwiches and soups. The smoked turkey sandwich, featuring bacon, avocado mayo, lettuce, and tomato on sourdough, is noted as a tasty and solid choice, though not necessarily extraordinary [1]. They also offer a 'half sandwich' option, which has been appreciated, but the bread crust has been described as difficult to eat [3, 2]. Additionally, their cowboy and cowgirl cookies are recommended for dessert [4].
Customer Sentiment
Customers generally view Olive's as a reliable lunch option, appreciating the quality of their sandwiches and soups [1]. While some have found the bread crust difficult to eat, the overall sentiment is positive, with many acknowledging its longevity as a testament to its enduring appeal [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLIVE'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Can I Find Iced Sparkling Espresso
"This user suggested Olive's on Prince St, noting they have a good sparkling lemonade cold brew, which is similar to the desired drink."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Eats Tartine Court Street Grocers Menkoi
"In response to a comment about the bread crust, the author agreed it was difficult to handle, humorously noting that soaking it in soup made it easier to eat."
NeutralFrom post: Recent Eats Tartine Court Street Grocers Menkoi
"This commenter appreciated Olive's half sandwich option but found the bread crust too hard to eat comfortably, especially with a smaller portion."
NegativeFrom post: Recent Eats Tartine Court Street Grocers Menkoi
"Responding to a comparison with M&O sandwiches, the author stated that while they'd choose M&O for just a sandwich, Olive's is preferred for their soup-and-sandwich combo."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Eats Tartine Court Street Grocers Menkoi
"This commenter used to eat at Olive's often when working in SoHo and noted its longevity suggests quality. They consider it a solid lunch option for those in the area, though not a destination place."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Eats Tartine Court Street Grocers Menkoi
"Initially lukewarm on Olive's, the author found the food quality good, though not mindblowing. They enjoyed a split pea and ham soup with half an Olive's Hero (coppa, salami, provolone, olive tapenade, etc.) on sourdough, deeming it solid despite the SoHo premium."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Dessert Place And Order In Nyc
"The commenter recommends Olive's for its cowboy and cowgirl cookies."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Eats Elbow Bread Son Del North Olives
"Olive's serves a solid smoked turkey sandwich with bacon, avocado mayo, lettuce, and tomato on sourdough. While tasty, it wasn't described as mind-blowing."
Neutral