TLDR
Sceney, upscale Italian spot in the Mercer Hotel. Perfect for birthdays, team dinners, or a sophisticated night out.
Instagram Posts References
Sartianos is showcased for its dirty martinis, with the image displaying two martinis garnished with olives. It is listed among the author's top 20 NYC destinations for this cocktail.
Sartiano's is featured for its substantial Veal Chop Parmigiana and a vodka martini. The parmigiana is a large portion, presented with cheese and sauce, and served with a side. The vodka martini is also listed as a beverage option.
The author celebrated their birthday at Saborino NYC and found it to be worthy of the hype. They enjoyed the spicy tuna arancini, describing them as 'little blasts of flavor and texture' and a must-order. The insalata louis was also praised for being delicious, flavorful, and perfectly executed, with the author overcoming their usual aversion to wedge salads due to its taste. The grilled trout piccata was a shareable main course with two pieces of fish, noted for its brothy consistency and sweet and salty flavor. However, the lobster triangoli, while known for being a signature dish, was the author's least favorite due to its rich, creamy, and heavy flavor profile. Despite this one dish, the author overall loved the experience and stated it was worth the money and the hype, expressing a desire to return.
The post highlights two dishes from Sartiano's. The first is a beautifully sliced steak, accompanied by a fresh green salad, suggesting a focus on quality cuts and simple, fresh accompaniments. The second dish is a large chicken parmesan, which is breaded and covered in marinara sauce and topped with dollops of melted mozzarella cheese and fresh herbs. The presentation of both dishes indicates a restaurant that offers both classic steakhouse fare and Italian-American comfort food.
Sartiano's was mentioned as catering a rehearsal dinner for Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce. The dinner reportedly included caviar cannellonis, highlighting the restaurant's ability to cater high-profile events with sophisticated dishes.
Sartiano's kale salad, featuring ingredients like quinoa, dried cranberries, and feta, was praised as one of the top ten dishes of the month.
Sartianos is featured as one of NYC's top 10 exclusive restaurants, ideal for celebratory gatherings. The post suggests it is a premier choice for events.
Details
Located in the Mercer Hotel, this sceney Italian destination is a premier choice for celebratory gatherings and high-profile events [1], [2]. Guests can choose between the casual upstairs cafe or the bar downstairs for an experience often described as worth the hype [3], [4]. The menu balances classic Italian-American comfort food with elevated, luxurious offerings like caviar-topped cannoli [5], [6].
Food Overview
The restaurant offers a diverse contemporary Italian menu that includes both hearty comfort dishes and unique, luxurious plates. Standout items include the spicy tuna arancini, insalata louis, and a well-regarded kale salad, though the lobster triangoli has been noted by some as overly rich [4], [9]. Main courses such as the veal chop parmigiana, chicken parmesan, and grilled trout piccata showcase a commitment to quality ingredients, often paired with cocktails like espresso or dirty martinis [5], [6], [10], [11].
Patrons generally consider the restaurant worthy of the hype, frequently highlighting it as an excellent venue for special occasions and birthday celebrations [4], [7]. While it is a popular destination, some visitors find the reservation process competitive, though walk-ins are accommodated in the cafe [3], [8].
Caveats
The lobster triangoli may be too heavy or creamy for some palates [4]. While generally popular, securing a reservation can be challenging, necessitating a focus on walk-ins for the cafe or booking well in advance for dinner [3], [8].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SARTIANO'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Im Bored Of Italian Food Italian Restaurant For
"Sartiano's is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Swanky Dinner For Moms 70th
"Sartiano's was listed as a potential Italian option for the occasion."
PositiveFrom post: Avoid The Alderman For Nye Complete Ripoff
"This user disagreed with the general sentiment that New Year's Eve at restaurants is always a disappointment, stating they had a great celebration at Sartianos the previous year."
PositiveFrom post: Where Is A Tough Dinner Res But Easy For Lunch
"Sartiano's is mentioned as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Nycs Best Espresso Martini
"Sartianos and Zero Bond were mentioned as having very good espresso martinis."
Positive