TLDR
Upscale Italian dining near the Met featuring an opulent atmosphere and refined pasta dishes; perfect for formal, special-occasion meals.
Bryan Kim reviews Sistina, an upscale Italian restaurant on the Upper East Side, highlighting its opulent ambiance and strong pasta dishes, making it a charming choice for special occasions.
Details
Located near the Metropolitan Museum of Art, this upscale Upper East Side destination is renowned for its opulent, luxurious dining room and intimate, classic atmosphere [1]. While the menu leans on the expensive side, the experience is elevated by generous offerings like complimentary bread and truffle butter [1]. It is frequently highlighted as an ideal choice for special occasions or formal events where elegant attire is welcomed [1].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on elevated Italian classics, with high praise for the veal-based dishes and handmade pastas [1]. Standout items like the pappardelle with veal ragu are considered some of the city's best [1], though other appetizers like the eggplant parmigiana are criticized by some for high pricing relative to their quality [1].
Highlights / Recommended
"The pappardelle with veal and mushroom ragu is highly recommended as a city-leading pasta dish [1]. The veal scaloppini, served with a tart, buttery sauce and thick-cut prosciutto, is also a top choice [1]."
Customer Sentiment
Diners often praise the exceptional pasta and the ability to comfortably accommodate formal, black-tie attire in an intimate setting [1], [2]. However, some visitors note reservations regarding the high price point and find the aesthetic or overall appeal hit-or-miss depending on personal preference [3], [4].
Caveats
The restaurant is quite expensive, with appetizers like eggplant parmigiana costing around $45 [1]. Some visitors may find the atmosphere or overall dining experience unexciting compared to other options in the neighborhood [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SISTINA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Funsexy Restaurant Where Ballgowngala Wear Wont
"The commenter states that they recently dined here in black-tie attire and nobody felt out of place."
PositiveFrom post: Girls Trip
"Sistina was mentioned as not being too exciting for dinner on the Upper East Side, with alternative suggestions provided."
NeutralFrom post: Girls Trip
"The original poster included Sistina for dinner in their itinerary."
NeutralFrom post: Iso Fancy Restaurant Wearing Ballgown Attire
"Sistina is recommended as a restaurant where the commenter has dined in black tie attire without issue, noting its small dining room and great food."
PositiveFrom post: Near The Met
"Sistina was recommended for those seeking upscale Italian dining near the Met Museum."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Some Good Italian Restaurants To Take 7
"Sistina is mentioned as being on the edge of being a recommendation due to its price point and regional cuisine diversity, but it has great pastas and an excellent vibe."
NeutralFrom post: What Are Some Good Italian Restaurants To Take 7
"The commenter agrees that Sistina gives off a 'girly' vibe."
NeutralFrom post: What Are Some Good Italian Restaurants To Take 7
"Sistina is described as distinctly 'girly' and decent."
NeutralFrom post: Italian Restaurants Near The Met
"This user highly recommends Sistina, stating it is amazing."
Positive