Next.js logo

MADE IN NEW YORK PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (646) 484-6200

Address: 421 AMSTERDAM AVENUE 10024

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Old-school slice shop w/ pizza overflowing w/ cheese [1]. Recommended NY-style slice spot on UWS [2].

Reddit Sentiment for MADE IN NEW YORK PIZZA(based on 2 Reddit opinions)

50% Positive

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
The Best Restaurants on the Upper West Side
positive

This old-school slice shop on the Upper West Side serves a plain slice overflowing with cheese.

Bryan Kim, Willa Moore, Will Hartman & Sonal Shah • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

This old-school slice shop on the Upper West Side is celebrated for its pizza, particularly its plain slices that overflow with cheese [1]. It's a recommended spot for New York-style pizza in the area [2]. The restaurant offers a classic Italian and American dining experience, fitting in with the diverse culinary scene of the Upper West Side [1].

Food Overview

This establishment is an old-school slice shop specializing in pizza [1]. Their plain slices are noted for being generously topped with cheese [1]. It is recognized as a recommended spot for New York-style pizza on the Upper West Side [2]. The cuisine is a mix of Italian and American, typical of a classic slice shop [1].

Highlights / Recommended

"The plain pizza slices are a standout, known for being generously topped with cheese."

Customer Sentiment

Customers praise the pizza, especially the generous cheese on their plain slices [1]. The establishment is frequently recommended for authentic New York-style pizza [2].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MADE IN NEW YORK PIZZA

Recommendations for the best NY style pizza in?
This Reddit post recommends Made in NY Pizza as a great option for New York-style pizza on the Upper West Side.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Recommendations For The Best Ny Style Pizza In

"Lists Made in NY as a recommended pizza place on the Upper West Side."

Positive
Sep 21, 2025View Comment →