MADE IN NEW YORK PIZZA

Last Updated: 4 months ago

Phone: (646) 484-6200

Address: 421 AMSTERDAM AVENUE 10024

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Fantastic pizza spot with standout Sicilian slices; a must-try for an authentic NYC slice experience.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 6 Reddit comments)

83% Positive17% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Details

For an authentic taste of New York pizza, look no further than this beloved spot on Amsterdam Avenue. Praised for its fantastic pizza, especially the Sicilian slices, it's a go-to for locals and visitors alike. While the pepperoni pizza is a definite must-try, don't hesitate to explore other offerings that contribute to its reputation as a solid pizza destination in the Upper West Side.

Food Overview

This establishment is highly recommended for its pizza, particularly the Sicilian slices which are noted as being good. The pepperoni pizza is highlighted as a standout, although other pizza offerings were described as just average. The cuisine can be broadly categorized as Italian-American.

Highlights / Recommended

"The Sicilian slices are particularly recommended, and the pepperoni pizza is noted as a great choice."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards this pizza place, with multiple recommendations for their pizza and specifically their Sicilian slices. While the pepperoni pizza received high praise, some feedback suggests other pizzas were just average.

Important Note

While the pepperoni pizza is excellent, some reviews suggest that other pizza options may be just average.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1j3gcvy/completely_overwhelmed_help_please/

A Reddit user highly recommends Made In NY Pizza, describing it as fantastic. This comment serves as a strong endorsement for the establishment's overall quality.

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1jhyqp1/favorite_sicilian_slices/

This post highlights the quality of Sicilian slices offered at Made In NY Pizza, with one user specifically recommending it for this specialty.

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1jjwxrm/nyc_best_pizza_slice/

Made In New York is recommended as a great option for experiencing a classic New York pizza slice, indicating a strong performance in this fundamental category.

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1jwg6ex/best_local_spots_in_uws/

This establishment is recommended as a local spot for pizza on Amsterdam Ave, suggesting it's a well-regarded neighborhood favorite.

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1k0klvk/one_week_in_nyc/

While the pepperoni pizza at this location was highlighted as great, another user noted that the other pizzas tried were only average.