TLDR
Israeli bakery delights w/ amazing pastries, esp. pizza burekas & chocolate rugelach. A must-try for unique baked goods!
Details
Michaeli Bakery is a highly acclaimed spot that brings a taste of Israeli and Jewish baking traditions to New York City. From its humble beginnings, it has quickly garnered a reputation for its exceptional pastries and baked goods. Customers rave about the unique flavors and textures, with many calling their offerings a 'religious experience.'
Customers highly recommend the pizza burekas and chocolate rugelach, with the babka also being called the best in the city. The goat cheese, honey, and zaatar galil is also a standout item.
Caveats
The coffee at Michaeli Bakery is not highly recommended, with some suggesting better options are available nearby.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MICHAELI BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Dive Bar Breakfast In Manhattan
"This commenter recommended Michaeli Bakery on the Lower East Side, highlighting their amazing pastries, particularly the pizza burekas and babka, which they claim is the best in the city. They advised against ordering their coffee."
PositiveFrom post: Bakery Delivery In Manhattan W Savory Options
"This user recommended Michaeli Bakery."
PositiveFrom post: An Englishman Ate In New York
"Michaeli Bakery received a 9.9/10, described as a religious experience for its chocolate rugelach and bureka. The author found the rugelach to be the best they'd ever had, with exceptionally pillowy goodness."
PositiveFrom post: Pastry Filled With Poppy Seeds
"This user mentioned Michaelis as a place that offers rugelachs or poppy seed Babka, alongside other recommendations."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Quality Bakery In Or Near Fidi For
"This user suggested the cheesecake from Michaeli Bakery as an option close to FiDi."
Positive