TLDR
Nolita's go-to for Italian-American bakery delights & sandwiches. Discover delicious caprese sandwiches and a variety of baked goods.
Caveats
One customer questioned the freshness of the caprese sandwich and found the location inconvenient.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About VESUVIO BAKERY
A user found the caprese sandwich at Vesuvio Bakery to be very delicious. They also mentioned that its freshness was questioned and that the location was inconvenient.
This user described the cookies at Vesuvio as 'shocking,' implying a negative surprise, possibly in comparison to other bakeries. The comment also notes that the cookies are a bakery item.
A comment suggests that if Vesuvio Bakery is still open, their cookies tend to be a bit crunchy.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Crunchyhard Cookies Recs
"If Vesuvio is still around, their cookies were found to be a little crunchy."
PositiveNov 12, 2025View Comment →
From post: Best Caprese Sandwich In Manhattan
"The user found the caprese sandwich at Vesuvio Bakery very delicious but questioned its freshness and mentioned it was inconveniently located for them."
NeutralMay 10, 2025View Comment →
From post: Whatre The Top 5 Chocolate Chips Cookies In Order
"User mentions going into Vesuvio recently and finding the cookies 'shocking', implying they were surprisingly bad, possibly in comparison to the old City Bakery cookies."
NegativeApr 15, 2025View Comment →