Details
This Italian eatery is a popular spot, known for its authentic flavors and bustling atmosphere. It's a go-to for fresh, seasonal dishes, particularly its pasta offerings, which are often highlighted by diners. While many praise the quality and taste of the food, some find the portions small for the price.
Caveats
Some diners have found the portions to be small for the price, and there are significant negative reviews regarding service and overall food quality.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ROSEMARY'S
A user specifically recommends the orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe, with other users agreeing that it's a great dish.
This thread contains numerous negative experiences, with users calling out the restaurant for small portions, high prices, bad service, and overall poor quality, with one user calling it 'one of the worst meals they have ever had'.
One user specifically notes that the drinks at happy hour were the only good thing, and everything else was a waste.
A user described a stressful job interview experience, noting a chaotic kitchen and ultimately deeming the pay not worth the sanity.
The restaurant is suggested as an Italian dining option in the West Village/Soho area.
The restaurant is considered a good option for a meeting, noted for its convenient location and cute pictures.
This post mentions the restaurant as a nice Italian option with a pleasant and family-friendly atmosphere.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Nice Italian Restaurant To Bring My 1
"Rosemary's East offers Italian cuisine and is noted for its pleasant and family-friendly atmosphere."
PositiveOct 23, 2025View Comment →
From post: Help Me Find A Restaurant To Meet My Boyfriends
"The original poster considers Rosemary's a good option, finds its pictures cute, and notes its convenient location."
PositiveJun 10, 2025View Comment →
From post: Help Me Find A Restaurant To Meet My Boyfriends
"Rosemary's is suggested as a good dining option."
PositiveJun 10, 2025View Comment →