Mixed reviews for this Italian spot: some love the orecchiette, but many find it overpriced w/ small portions & poor service.
This Italian eatery has sparked a lively debate among diners, with opinions sharply divided. While some patrons rave about specific dishes, such as the orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe, a vocal contingent expresses considerable disappointment. Common criticisms revolve around what are perceived as meager portions for the price point, an overall mediocre food quality, and subpar service. The ambiance is also noted as being unpleasantly loud by some. Despite its popularity, a segment of customers feel the restaurant fails to deliver value, with only its happy hour drinks receiving occasional praise.
The Italian cuisine at this restaurant receives mixed reviews. The orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe is specifically recommended by some customers. However, a recurring theme in negative feedback is that the food is considered mediocre and overpriced, with portions described as disappointingly small. Some diners have gone as far as to call it one of the worst meals they've had.
"The orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe is specifically mentioned as a recommended dish."
Customer feedback is highly polarized. While some praise specific dishes like the orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe, a significant portion of reviews express strong dissatisfaction. Common complaints include small portions for the price, mediocre food quality overall, poor service, and an unpleasantly loud atmosphere. Some feel the restaurant is overpriced and not worth the cost, with only happy hour drinks being considered a positive by a few.
Important Note
Several customers report that the portions are small for the price, and the overall experience can be negatively impacted by mediocre food, bad service, and a loud atmosphere. Some believe only happy hour drinks are worth it.
"The original poster considers Rosemary's a good option, finds its pictures cute, and notes its convenient location."
Positive"Rosemary's is suggested as a good dining option."
Positive"Expresses agreement with the positive sentiment towards the dish."
Positive"Agrees with the recommendation of Rosemary's."
Positive"Rosemary's has a great orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe."
Positive"The author stated that while they like the food at Rosemary's, they find it to be ridiculously overpriced."
Neutral"The author, an Italian American, refuses to go to Rosemary's due to it being overpriced with small portions."
Negative"The author recounted a stressful job interview experience at Rosemary's, describing a chaotic kitchen environment. While the pay was good, they found it not worth their sanity."
Neutral"The author strongly agreed with the negative sentiment towards Rosemary's, questioning why anyone would recommend it given other choices."
Negative"The author believes Rosemary's is only good for its happy hour drinks and considers everything else a waste."
Negative"The author characterized their experience at Rosemary's as having horrendous service, mediocre food, and bad drinks."
Negative"The author described their meal at Rosemary's as one of the worst they have ever had in New York City."
Negative"The author sarcastically commented on the noise level at Rosemary's, implying it's excessively loud."
Negative"In response to a comment about small portions, the author added that Rosemary's is also simply not good and has bad service."
Negative"The author recently visited Rosemary's and found the portions to be disappointingly small for the prices charged."
Negative"The author listed Rosemary's as a highly recommended place they disagree with, initiating a thread of similar negative experiences."
Negative"Rosemary's, an Italian restaurant, was put forward by the commenter as a dining suggestion in the West Village/Soho area. This was despite the original poster mentioning wanting to avoid Italian cuisine for this occasion."
Neutral