TLDR
Delectable bagels that spark fervent debate, from 'go-to' favorites to 'worst in the city' critiques.
Details
This spot is a true contender in the bustling NYC bagel scene, igniting passionate discussions among locals. While many praise their offerings, with some even calling it a go-to favorite, others have voiced strong criticisms, deeming their bagels among the city's least appealing. It’s a place where opinions are as diverse as the toppings, making it a must-try for those wanting to form their own verdict on this polarizing bagel joint.
Food Overview
The primary focus is on bagels, which receive wildly divergent feedback. While many customers find them to be excellent and a reliable favorite, a notable portion of reviews criticize the quality, with some considering them among the city's worst. The cuisine is generally described as deli and American.
Caveats
Be aware that customer opinions on the bagels are sharply divided, with a significant negative sentiment expressed by some patrons regarding their quality.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About TAL BAGELS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where To Go After Absolute Bagels Closed
"The commenter states that Tal's on 1st/21st is their go-to, wondering if other locations might not be as good."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Go After Absolute Bagels Closed
"The commenter agrees with the negative assessment of Tal's bagels."
NegativeFrom post: Where To Go After Absolute Bagels Closed
"The commenter states that Tal's offers one of the worst bagels they've had in the city."
NegativeFrom post: Where To Go After Absolute Bagels Closed
"The commenter implicitly recommends Tal's as a bagel option."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Go After Absolute Bagels Closed
"The commenter implicitly recommends Tal's as a bagel option."
PositiveFrom post: Upper West Side Bagels
"A user includes Tal's in a list of good bagel places."
Positive