Modern sushi experience w/ expert preparation. Set menus showcase quality ingredients. A solid choice for sushi lovers.
Experience a unique approach to sushi with a focus on high-quality ingredients and a streamlined dining experience. Known for its expertly prepared dishes, this establishment offers a set menu that allows diners to fully appreciate the chef's selections. While some find it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal, others suggest exploring alternative options for a more elevated sushi experience.
This Japanese restaurant specializes in sushi, particularly known for its 'Trust Me' tasting menu. Many customers enjoy the quality of the fish and the overall experience, considering it a good value for money and a convenient option for walk-ins. However, a significant portion of reviewers find the sushi to be just 'fine' or 'mediocre,' suggesting that while it's a decent choice, it may not live up to the hype compared to other, more premium sushi establishments in New York City.
"The 'Trust Me' tasting menu is frequently mentioned as a positive experience. For those seeking hand rolls, its sister restaurant Kazunori is recommended."
Customer feedback is mixed, with some praising the quality and value, while others find it to be average and suggest better alternatives exist in the city.
Important Note
Some diners find the restaurant to be 'basic' and suggest that better sushi options are available in New York City, particularly at a similar price point.
"The original poster likes Sugarfish but needs a place with more kid-friendly options like tamago and sweet potato rolls."
Positive"Sugarfish is mentioned as a potential casual option for sushi."
Positive"User omakase_me_pls lists Sugarfish as a go-to for takeout sushi."
Positive"User foodfunmenyc chooses Sugarfish because it doesn't take reservations, allowing for walk-ins despite a potential hour wait. They find it consistently good and affordable for sushi, with no tipping."
Positive"Commenter stumbled upon Sugarfish (Midtown East), loved it, got a 'Trust Me' course, and plans to return. Mentions price might be comparable or cheaper than Korami."
Positive"Likes Sugarfish, finding it a very good value and easy to get into compared to better spots. Appreciated that the omakase menus allowed them to try new things and believes one can still have a good meal there."
Positive"Agrees with skipping Sugarfish and recommends Sushi Ishikawa as their go-to sushi spot instead."
Negative"Advises skipping Sugarfish, calling the sushi very underwhelming."
Negative"Considers Sugarfish good but "basic af" and claims Sushi of Gari will change your life, implying Gari is far superior."
Neutral"Does not agree with recommending Sugarfish, suggesting Kazunori for a flexible no-reservation option, or other omakase places at similar prices that are much better. Considers Sugarfish not bad, but not up to par with other restaurants on OP's list."
Negative"Describes Sugarfish as "eh" (mediocre). Recommends its sister restaurant Kazunori for cheaper hand rolls with incredible price/value."
Negative"Advises passing on Sugarfish."
Negative"Advises passing on Sugarfish, calling it a chain that is not good enough to merit a stop during a limited trip to NYC."
Negative"Defends Sugarfish against critics, suggesting to go if never been. Also mentions its handroll spot Kazunori."
Positive"Considers Sugarfish to be "fine" but trendy, asserting that there is much better sushi available in New York City."
Neutral
