TLDR
World-class cocktails & Japanese-inspired bar. Exquisite drinks, great staff, and a sophisticated vibe that justifies the price.
Details
This Japanese-inspired bar is a haven for cocktail aficionados, consistently praised for its expertly crafted drinks and exceptional staff. Known for its sophisticated atmosphere, it's often mentioned as a top spot for pre-dinner drinks or a refined night out. While some find the prices steep, many agree the quality and experience, particularly the ambiance and unique offerings, justify the cost.
Caveats
Some patrons find the cocktails to be quite expensive, and reservations may be required, especially during peak times. One user also had a negative experience, finding it underwhelming.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MARTINY'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Cocktail Lounges Or Bars In Flatironchelsea Open
"This user notes that Martiny's had a high minimum for a reservation, implying it was a factor in their decision."
NegativeFrom post: Girls Trip
"Martiny's was suggested as a nice cocktail spot, particularly for those hanging out downtown."
NeutralFrom post: Cocktail Lounges Or Bars In Flatironchelsea Open
"This user suggests Martiny’s on 17th street as a great option for drinks."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Favorite Midrange Price Japanese
"Based on feedback, Martiny's is now a priority for the commenter due to its excellent quality and vibe, especially the upstairs seating."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Favorite Midrange Price Japanese
"Martiny's is described as excellent with great quality and service. Sitting upstairs provides a cozy, living-room-like feel."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Favorite Midrange Price Japanese
"Martiny's is on the commenter's list to review and is mentioned as a place they'd like feedback on."
NeutralFrom post: Have 1000 For 2 Where Do I Go
"Suggests Martiny's for drinks and bites as a starting point."
NeutralFrom post: Ev Bars Open Tonightxmas Eve
"Martiny's is open and is an excellent, albeit expensive, bar that usually requires reservations. The commenter noted it is the opposite of a dive bar."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Places In Nyc That Match This Winter
"This user described Martiny's, especially the upstairs study, as very cozy and potentially the coziest high-end bar in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurants Built Into Townhouses
"Martiny's was described as a world-class Japanese cocktail bar located in an old carriage house in Gramercy, fitting the townhouse criteria."
PositiveFrom post: How Did I Do On My Big East Coast Bar Tour
"The author rated Martinys 9.5, giving it a perfect 11 for vibe and a respectable 8 for drinks, though they noted they are not a gin or martini enthusiast. They loved the perfect midnight vibe with background jazz and a classy, modern atmosphere, finding their whiskey drinks a bit too 'creative'. They also had a positive interaction with a knowledgeable regular."
PositiveFrom post: Drinks Before Gramercy Tavern
"This user recommended Martiny's as a cocktail bar option."
PositiveFrom post: Drinks Before Gramercy Tavern
"This user recommended Martiny's as a cocktail bar option near Gramercy Tavern."
PositiveFrom post: Which Bars To Cut
"This user prioritizes Martiny's as a must-visit."
PositiveFrom post: Which Bars To Cut
"Martiny's drinks were not quite to this user's taste, but they found the vibe to be the best of all the places visited, calling it a perfect bullseye."
PositiveFrom post: Which Bars To Cut
"This user suggests cutting Martiny's and going to Shinji's instead, stating Shinji's is more experimental."
NegativeFrom post: Which Bars To Cut
"Martiny's is listed as an absolutely essential bar to keep."
PositiveFrom post: Which Bars To Cut
"Martiny's is recommended by this user."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Beautiful Bar
"Martiny is listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: My 2week Nyc List Thoughts
"Martiny's is recommended as a bar to check out, especially if one arrives right when places open."
Positive