World-class Japanese cocktail bar w/ incredible martinis & whiskies. Reservations often needed for this sophisticated, cozy vibe.
This Japanese-inspired cocktail bar is renowned for its exceptional drinks and sophisticated ambiance, making it a top choice for pre-dinner cocktails or a classy night out. While some find the prices steep, the quality of the beverages and the elegant atmosphere, complete with jazz music and a cozy study, justify the cost for many patrons. It's a refined experience that stands apart from more casual establishments.
The focus here is on high-quality cocktails, particularly martinis and whiskies, with many patrons recommending them. While not a dining-focused establishment, the drinks are considered exceptional and worth the premium price. Some reviews note that while the cocktails are creative, they might be a bit too much for those not accustomed to adventurous flavors, though classic off-menu options are also available.
"The bar is highly recommended for its martinis and whiskies, with many suggesting trying their classic or off-menu cocktail selections."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the bar for its exceptional cocktails and sophisticated atmosphere, with many highlighting the staff and the overall experience as top-notch. However, a recurring point is the high price point, which some find justified by the quality, while others consider it expensive.
Important Note
Reservations are often required, and the prices for cocktails are on the higher side.
"Martiny's is open and is an excellent, albeit expensive, bar that usually requires reservations. The commenter noted it is the opposite of a dive bar."
Positive"This user described Martiny's, especially the upstairs study, as very cozy and potentially the coziest high-end bar in the city."
Positive"Martiny's was described as a world-class Japanese cocktail bar located in an old carriage house in Gramercy, fitting the townhouse criteria."
Positive"The author rated Martinys 9.5, giving it a perfect 11 for vibe and a respectable 8 for drinks, though they noted they are not a gin or martini enthusiast. They loved the perfect midnight vibe with background jazz and a classy, modern atmosphere, finding their whiskey drinks a bit too 'creative'. They also had a positive interaction with a knowledgeable regular."
Positive"This user recommended Martiny's as a cocktail bar option."
Positive"This user recommended Martiny's as a cocktail bar option near Gramercy Tavern."
Positive"This user prioritizes Martiny's as a must-visit."
Positive"Martiny's drinks were not quite to this user's taste, but they found the vibe to be the best of all the places visited, calling it a perfect bullseye."
Positive"This user suggests cutting Martiny's and going to Shinji's instead, stating Shinji's is more experimental."
Negative"Martiny's is listed as an absolutely essential bar to keep."
Positive"Martiny's is recommended by this user."
Positive"Martiny is listed as a recommendation."
Neutral"Martiny's is recommended as a bar to check out, especially if one arrives right when places open."
Positive"Martiny's was recommended as a great place for a martini and a good vibe."
Positive"Martiny's is described as a great option for a good vibe, potentially a quieter one, in response to a query about downtown spots."
Positive"The original poster highlights Bar Benfiddich's event at Martiny's as one of the exciting BCB guest shifts."
Neutral"Martiny's drinks were good but $27 each."
Negative"Martiny's prices keep people away."
Negative"Recommends Martiny's."
Positive"Likes Martiny's but acknowledges some might find it overpriced."
Positive
