TLDR
World-class Japanese cocktails housed in a cozy, historic Gramercy carriage house. An upscale, intimate destination perfect for sophisticated sips.
Details
Tucked away in a historic Gramercy carriage house, this world-class Japanese cocktail bar offers an exceptionally upscale and sophisticated atmosphere [4]. The venue is widely celebrated for its cozy, living-room-like upstairs study that provides an unmatched, intimate vibe [6][9]. While the drinks are frequently lauded for their quality, the experience is considered a premium, high-end destination that often requires advanced planning [5][14].
Caveats
The bar is relatively expensive and commonly requires advance reservations to avoid long wait times or meet minimum spend requirements [5][12][14].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MARTINY'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Can You Guys Help Me Decide On Some Cocktail Bars
"The commenter suggests Martiny's as a top choice for cocktails but notes that reservations are recommended due to potential long waits."
PositiveFrom post: Cocktail Lounges Or Bars In Flatironchelsea Open
"This user notes that Martiny's had a high minimum for a reservation, implying it was a factor in their decision."
NegativeFrom post: Girls Trip
"Martiny's was suggested as a nice cocktail spot, particularly for those hanging out downtown."
NeutralFrom post: Cocktail Lounges Or Bars In Flatironchelsea Open
"This user suggests Martiny’s on 17th street as a great option for drinks."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Favorite Midrange Price Japanese
"Based on feedback, Martiny's is now a priority for the commenter due to its excellent quality and vibe, especially the upstairs seating."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Favorite Midrange Price Japanese
"Martiny's is described as excellent with great quality and service. Sitting upstairs provides a cozy, living-room-like feel."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Favorite Midrange Price Japanese
"Martiny's is on the commenter's list to review and is mentioned as a place they'd like feedback on."
NeutralFrom post: Have 1000 For 2 Where Do I Go
"Suggests Martiny's for drinks and bites as a starting point."
NeutralFrom post: Ev Bars Open Tonightxmas Eve
"Martiny's is open and is an excellent, albeit expensive, bar that usually requires reservations. The commenter noted it is the opposite of a dive bar."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Places In Nyc That Match This Winter
"This user described Martiny's, especially the upstairs study, as very cozy and potentially the coziest high-end bar in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurants Built Into Townhouses
"Martiny's was described as a world-class Japanese cocktail bar located in an old carriage house in Gramercy, fitting the townhouse criteria."
PositiveFrom post: How Did I Do On My Big East Coast Bar Tour
"The author rated Martinys 9.5, giving it a perfect 11 for vibe and a respectable 8 for drinks, though they noted they are not a gin or martini enthusiast. They loved the perfect midnight vibe with background jazz and a classy, modern atmosphere, finding their whiskey drinks a bit too 'creative'. They also had a positive interaction with a knowledgeable regular."
PositiveFrom post: Drinks Before Gramercy Tavern
"This user recommended Martiny's as a cocktail bar option."
PositiveFrom post: Drinks Before Gramercy Tavern
"This user recommended Martiny's as a cocktail bar option near Gramercy Tavern."
Positive