Cozy, old-school Irish pub w/ a fireplace, "real good" burgers & a famous spice bag.
Step into a cozy, Tudor-style Irish pub that feels like a lived-in piece of history. With creaking booths and walls adorned with old photos, this Gramercy institution offers a comforting atmosphere perfect for any day. It's renowned for expertly poured Guinness and a menu that includes a well-regarded spice bag and a classic, "real good" burger.
This Irish pub offers classic comfort food with a few standout recommendations. The burger is frequently praised as "real good," and the "spice bag" is a popular, highly recommended item. The "Full Irish" breakfast is a go-to for some, and corned beef is also noted as a good option. For a less common choice, the sausage and mashed potatoes are also recommended.
"Highly recommended dishes include the "real good" burger and the popular "spice bag." The "Full Irish" breakfast and corned beef are also noted as excellent choices."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment, frequently recommending the restaurant for its authentic Irish pub atmosphere, good food like burgers and spice bags, and quality Guinness.
Important Note
One comment suggests that the cupcakes, while previously popular, may have declined in quality in recent years.
"States that Molly's cupcakes are now considered 'meh' by nieces and nephews, a decline from previous years."
Negative"Affirms that Molly's is 'THE BEST'."
Positive"Asks if Molly's cupcakes are still good, having not visited in 10 years."
Neutral"This restaurant was recommended as a place that serves vinegar fries, with the note that it is an Irish establishment."
Positive"Recommends Molly's in Gramercy as a place with a good burger."
Positive"Molly’s Shebeen is mentioned as a place for Irish food."
Positive"Recommends Molly's, an Irish pub around 23rd street, for very good corned beef."
Positive"Molly's was listed as a place with a fireplace, suitable for someone seeking warmth."
Positive"This user recommended Molly's on 3rd, noting it has a wood-burning stove in the middle of the bar and good burgers."
Positive"This user recommended Molly's Shebeen."
Positive"This user recommended Mollys Shebeen."
Positive"This user recommended Molly's Shebeen for its great pints, Irish food, sawdust on the floor, and fireplace."
Positive"This user listed Molly Shebeen as a Christmas-themed bar/restaurant."
Neutral"Molly's Shebeen is mentioned as having a decent spice bag."
Neutral"This commenter highly recommends Molly's Shabheen in Gramercy for its Irish tavern vibe. They specifically praise the burger and spice bag as excellent options."
Positive"Mollys on 3rd Ave is a go-to for The Full Irish breakfast."
Neutral"This Irish bar is highly recommended for its "real good burger.""
Positive"Selected Molly’s Shebeen as their choice for one of the restaurant categories."
Positive"Recommends Mollys, an Irish restaurant with really good food."
Positive
