TLDR
Historic Irish pub with wood-burning fireplace and sawdust-floor charm. Famous for spice bags, hearty shepherd's pie, and a top-tier burger.
Instagram Posts References
Molly's Pub, a historic pub in Gramercy, is featured for its classic comfort food. The author was initially led to the establishment due to 'bad chicken pot pie intel' and found the pot pie to be exceptional, even surpassing other favorites. The pub's history dates back 130 years, and it has been serving drinks for a long time. The spice bag, with its substantial potato portion, was also highlighted as a must-order item. The post suggests this is just the first stop in a series of reviews.
Signage is up for Molly Teau, located on the east side of Broadway, just north of Union Square. The establishment appears to be a tea shop, with 'Eastern Modern Tea' mentioned on its signage.
Details
A historic Gramercy institution, this cozy Irish pub features a wood-burning fireplace and a lived-in atmosphere that makes it a perfect retreat on gloomy days [1], [2], [4]. Renowned for its classic pub fare, the menu offers standout items like an expertly poured Guinness, traditional shepherd's pie, and a highly recommended spice bag [2], [3], [5]. Patrons also consistently praise the burger and seasonal pies, cementing its reputation as a neighborhood fixture since the 1960s [3], [4], [6].
Food Overview
This establishment specializes in traditional Irish pub fare, with guests frequently ordering the signature spice bag, which features crispy chicken and a generous portion of potatoes [1], [2], [5]. Other highlights include the Guinness beef stew, various steak-based pies, and an outstanding six-ounce burger [3], [4], [6]. While the cupcakes are generally considered past their prime, the savory menu remains highly regarded [6].
Overall feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with regulars and visitors alike praising the authentic, cozy atmosphere and consistent, high-quality comfort food [3], [4], [6]. While the quality of cupcakes has seen a noted decline in recent years, this has not diminished the pub's status as a beloved neighborhood institution [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MOLLY'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: If You Could Only Pick One What Is Your Favorite
"The user enjoys their flourless chocolate cupcakes."
PositiveFrom post: Expats And Transplants Of Nyc What Is Your
"A pub that hits the spot when missing Irish food."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Find A Good Americanstyle Beef Stew
"This restaurant is located on the east side and is recommended for having a great Guinness beef stew."
PositiveFrom post: Any Restaurants Here That Serve Pie And Mash W
"The commenter enjoys the pies served here, specifically mentioning past availability of steak and kidney or steak and ale pies."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars
"Molly's near Gramercy Park is recommended."
Positive