24/7 American diner w/ insane creations. Think over-the-top comfort food, monster milkshakes & brunch burritos.
Step into a classic American diner experience at this 24-hour establishment in Manhattan. Known for its over-the-top, indulgent comfort food, this spot offers a nostalgic vibe with a menu filled with 'insane creations.' From breakfast staples like pancakes to hearty sandwiches and massive milkshakes, it's a place that caters to late-night cravings and early morning appetites alike, with a focus on generous portions and satisfying flavors.
This American diner serves up classic diner food with an extravagant twist. Recommended dishes include the 'insane' Brunch Wrap with eggs, bacon, pancakes, and maple butter, as well as highly decorated milkshakes and triple-stacked smash burgers. Other praised items are pancakes and a surprisingly great French dip-style sandwich (Hot Roast Beef sandwich). Some feedback indicates it can be a 'mac & cheesesteak kind of place,' with one user finding it 'meh.'
"Highly recommended are the indulgent Brunch Wraps, described as monster creations, and the 'insanely decked out' milkshakes. The Hot Roast Beef sandwich is also noted as surprisingly great."
Customers generally have a positive view of this diner, appreciating its nostalgic atmosphere and unique, indulgent comfort food offerings. While some find it 'meh,' others rave about specific dishes and the overall satisfying experience.
Important Note
One user described the experience as 'meh' and 'not my scene,' suggesting it might not appeal to everyone's taste or preferred dining environment.
"In response to a deleted comment, this user expressed curiosity about Diner 24, stating they hadn't tried it but knew it existed."
Neutral"This user mentioned Diner 24 as a new-ish place in Gramercy."
Positive"A brief, negative response to the recommendation of Diner 24's milkshakes, calling them 'dumb'."
Negative"Recommends Diner 24 for its 'insanely decked out' milkshakes, which were also pretty good."
Positive"The commenter suggests trying a diner, as they typically have soups and might be more willing to blend food upon request."
Positive"User mentions Diner 24."
Neutral"User mentions Diner 24."
Neutral"Diners can be surprisingly helpful for healthy eating as they often allow for custom orders, such as omelets."
Positive"This commenter suggests that any solid NYC diner would offer fish prepared in several ways, often served with vegetables and rice. They fondly recalled a specific Fillet of Sole with Lemon from an old-school UES diner."
Positive"The user simply stated 'Any diner' in response to the original post about Thanksgiving food."
Neutral"This commenter mentioned that diners, along with Jewish delis, commonly serve sliced turkey, gravy, and starch year-round."
Neutral"The user broadly stated that most diners offer a turkey dinner with stuffing, implying it's a common year-round option."
Neutral"This user recommended Diner 24, citing a perfect score from a TikTok diner reviewer."
Neutral"Diner 24 is suggested as a dining option."
Neutral"This restaurant is recommended as a dining option located within a 10-minute walk from Gramercy Park."
Neutral"The original poster clarifies that Diner 24 was not their choice and they would not go there on their own, agreeing that their picks aren't 'bucket list' places, but rather reflect their frequent visits and budget considerations."
Negative"This user refers to Diner 24, suggesting that the original poster's choices might not all be 'bucket list' destinations but rather everyday spots."
Neutral"The author went to Diner 24 with family and found it 'meh' and 'not my scene,' noting it as a mac & cheesesteak kind of place, and only had chicken fingers and a salad."
Neutral
