24-hr NYC diner w/ insane, over-the-top creations & classic comfort food. Think monster milkshakes, stacked burgers & pancakes that impress.
This 24-hour American diner offers a nostalgic experience with a menu packed with indulgent comfort food. From towering smash burgers to creatively topped pancakes and milkshakes, it's a spot for those seeking over-the-top creations. It's also noted for its satisfying breakfast options and a surprisingly great French dip-style sandwich.
This American diner is known for its extensive menu of comfort food, with standout items including "insane creations" like a deep-fried brunch wrap with eggs, bacon, and pancakes, generously topped pancakes, massive footlong hot dogs, and elaborately decorated milkshakes. Customers also recommend the "Hot Roast Beef sandwich" (similar to French dip) and simple, delicious pancakes. While many dishes are praised for their indulgence, one reviewer found the chicken fingers and salad to be "meh."
"The "Hot Roast Beef sandwich" is highlighted as a surprisingly great French dip-style option. Additionally, the pancakes are praised for being simple yet delicious, and the diner's "insane creations" like the brunch wrap and milkshakes are recommended for an indulgent experience."
Customers generally have positive experiences, particularly praising the unique and indulgent dishes. However, some find it to be just an 'okay' diner experience.
Important Note
One reviewer found the diner experience and food to be mediocre, describing it as "meh" and "not their scene."
"User mentions Diner 24."
Neutral"User mentions Diner 24."
Neutral"Diners can be surprisingly helpful for healthy eating as they often allow for custom orders, such as omelets."
Positive"This commenter suggests that any solid NYC diner would offer fish prepared in several ways, often served with vegetables and rice. They fondly recalled a specific Fillet of Sole with Lemon from an old-school UES diner."
Positive"The user simply stated 'Any diner' in response to the original post about Thanksgiving food."
Neutral"This commenter mentioned that diners, along with Jewish delis, commonly serve sliced turkey, gravy, and starch year-round."
Neutral"The user broadly stated that most diners offer a turkey dinner with stuffing, implying it's a common year-round option."
Neutral"This user recommended Diner 24, citing a perfect score from a TikTok diner reviewer."
Neutral"Diner 24 is suggested as a dining option."
Neutral"This restaurant is recommended as a dining option located within a 10-minute walk from Gramercy Park."
Neutral"The original poster clarifies that Diner 24 was not their choice and they would not go there on their own, agreeing that their picks aren't 'bucket list' places, but rather reflect their frequent visits and budget considerations."
Negative"This user refers to Diner 24, suggesting that the original poster's choices might not all be 'bucket list' destinations but rather everyday spots."
Neutral"The author went to Diner 24 with family and found it 'meh' and 'not my scene,' noting it as a mac & cheesesteak kind of place, and only had chicken fingers and a salad."
Neutral"Mentions having a surprisingly great French dip-style sandwich (listed as 'Hot Roast Beef sandwich' on the menu) at Diner 24."
Positive"A commenter praised the pancakes at the 24-hour diner on 22nd St (off 3rd Ave) as the best they've ever had, describing them as very simple but delicious."
Positive"A commenter recommended a 24-hour diner on 22nd St, noting they were impressed with its breakfast, simple approach, nostalgic aesthetic, and reasonable prices despite initial skepticism due to crowds."
Positive
