Mixed reviews on sushi quality and safety; some find it good for delivery, others report food poisoning and declining standards.
Mikado presents a mixed bag for diners, with some hailing it as a reliable source for good sushi and efficient delivery. However, a substantial number of reviews suggest a decline in quality, with mentions of mediocre taste, excessive roll size, and even serious concerns about food safety leading to food poisoning. While some appreciate the value, others feel there are better options available for the price, making it a divisive choice in the NYC dining scene.
Mikado offers Japanese cuisine, with a particular focus on sushi and rolls. While some patrons find the sushi to be consistently good and suitable for delivery, others describe it as mediocre, with large rolls that are difficult to eat and a taste that doesn't match the presentation. There are significant concerns raised about food quality and safety, with multiple reports of food poisoning.
"While specific dishes aren't consistently highlighted, users generally refer to 'sushi' and 'rolls' when recommending or discussing the restaurant."
Customer reviews for Mikado are highly polarized, with some praising it as consistently good and excellent for delivery, while others report extremely negative experiences including severe food poisoning and a significant decline in quality over time.
Important Note
Multiple customers have reported severe food poisoning after eating at Mikado, with incidents occurring at both the 14th St and Atlantic Ave locations. There are also concerns about a significant decline in food quality over time, with some users suggesting better alternatives are available.
"This user eats at the Park Slope location and finds it to be a nice option in the area, but not particularly special."
Neutral"This person ate at Mikado and found the rolls to be excessively large, making them difficult to eat."
Neutral"This user suggests that the storefront of Mikado is potentially horrifying, implying cleanliness or aesthetic issues."
Negative"This commenter noted that Mikado's tableware appears to be sourced from Home Goods, implying a lack of unique or high-quality presentation."
Neutral"This user finds the 14th St location to be their go-to for lunch specials and is seeking recommendations for similar nearby spots."
Neutral"This commenter disagrees with the 'Subway of sushi' comparison, suggesting that pre-made sushi from market coolers is a more accurate comparison for low-quality sushi."
Neutral"This commenter reported getting severe food poisoning from the 14th St location, with others in their group also falling ill."
Negative"The commenter states that Mikado used to be a good value but the price has increased significantly while the quality has decreased."
Negative"This user finds Mikado to be good, inexpensive sushi for delivery, comparing it to Bondi Sushi. They have ordered from both Brooklyn and Manhattan locations."
Positive"This user's wife experienced food poisoning from Mikado on 14th St, leading to an ER visit and identifying the restaurant as the likely cause."
Negative"This commenter questions why one would choose Mikado for sushi in NYC, given the abundance of better and more affordable options."
Negative"While finding the portions at the Atlantic Ave location good, this user experienced severe food poisoning after a recent delivery order from there."
Negative"The commenter used to like Mikado for its price a few years ago but believes the quality has significantly declined since then."
Negative"This commenter questioned the original poster's previous positive review of Mikado, noting a perceived inconsistency in their opinions. They also commented on the photo quality possibly affecting the perception of the food."
Neutral"This user typically visits Mikado for their happy hour specials, finding the pricing to be acceptable."
Neutral"This user enjoys the Park Slope location, finding it more festive than other neighborhood spots with large rolls. They consider it a good option, though not life-changing."
Positive"This user agrees that Mikado is only 'ehhhh' at best. They noted that while the presentation can look appealing, the taste does not match the visual."
Negative"This commenter finds the sushi from Mikado to be genuinely bad, despite its appearance."
Negative"The author found the sushi and maki set to be mediocre, comparing it to the Subway of sushi and noting filler in the box. They felt there were better options in Manhattan for the price."
Negative"This user recommended Mikado for lunch."
Positive
