Next.js logo

4 CHARLES PRIME RIB

Updated

Phone: (312) 718-3209

Address: 4 CHARLES STREET 10014

$$$$Mains mostly $39.99–$139.99

TLDR

An exclusive, intimate West Village steakhouse famed for its legendary double-wagyu cheeseburger and prime rib. A notoriously hard-to-book dining experience that consistently delivers upscale, indulgent comfort food.

Reddit Sentiment for 4 CHARLES PRIME RIB(based on 164 Reddit opinions)

49% Positive42% Neutral9% Negative

Reddit Sentiment Over Time

Unique Posts Over Time

Tags

american 89steakhouse 21new american 2burger 53steak 36prime rib 21View All

Neighborhoods

West Village

Instagram Posts References

The post focuses on the 10oz Double Wagyu Cheeseburger from 4 Charles Prime Rib. It is made with Snake River Farms wagyu, American cheese, a farm egg, and thick-cut bacon, finished tableside with a drizzle of egg yolk. The burger has been officially verified as one of the best in NYC by Mike Eats NYC Burgers, and the author ranks it among their personal favorites, with a detailed review available in their link in bio.

The author visited 4 Charles for lunch, arriving before opening to secure a table and experiencing a wait of just over an hour. They were initially seated inside but then moved outside, receiving a complimentary round of drinks due to the seating change. The highlight of the meal was the highly praised burger, ordered with egg and no bacon. The elote corn was also a favorite, noted for its spicy sauce and lime flavor. While the truffle mac and cheese was considered solid, it was not spectacular. For dessert, the chocolate cream pie was ordered, and the server generously provided a complimentary strawberry ice cream, which was deemed an excellent pairing. The author describes the overall meal and experience as one of the best they've had recently, commending the restaurant group Hogsalt for their expertise.

The author visited 4 Charles Prime Rib, a restaurant known for being difficult to get a reservation at. They were thoroughly impressed with the food, highlighting the French dip, the burger, the shrimp scampi, and the chocolate pie. The service was also noted as exceptional, with the waiter's presentation of the burger being particularly memorable. Despite finding the truffle mac and cheese and elote good, the author stated they would not order them again on a future visit, but will definitely be returning for the other dishes, especially the French dip and the burger. The dessert, a chocolate pie, was also highly praised, living up to expectations.

The reviewer experienced 4 Charles Prime Rib, an 'infamous' establishment in New York City, securing a reservation by waiting in line before opening. The meal included a pricey but delicious Little Gem Salad with an 'insanely good' crab cake, a great Wagyu cheeseburger where the bacon was a bit chewy, a highly-rated truffle mac and cheese that was creamy and not overly cheesy, and a prime rib French dip with a distinct chili flavor that reminded the reviewer of Chinese braised beef, though they ultimately preferred a similar sandwich from Au Cheval. The overall experience was positive, appreciating the food despite some minor critiques on texture and a preference for a competitor's French dip.

4 Charles is celebrated as an iconic establishment in NYC, acclaimed for its exceptional food and outstanding service. The post highlights the 'iconic burger' as an absolute must-try, alongside the rich truffle mac and cheese. It also mentions that the restaurant occasionally accommodates walk-ins for those who arrive sufficiently early, offering a chance to experience this highly sought-after dining spot.

Described as the 'best restaurant in NYC', 4 Charles Prime Rib is praised for its burger and French dip sandwich, both noted as the best items on the menu. The post features an image of a decadent burger with bacon and a fried egg, and another image showing the burger's interior.

The author dined at 4 Charles Prime Rib late at night and found the restaurant to be beautiful with very pleasant staff. The meal included a fresh but basic salad, a highly praised truffle mac and cheese with a crispy top, and a wagyu cheeseburger (with options for egg and bacon) which was considered very good with thinner patties. The author disagreed with the notion that the French dip is better than the burger, citing Houston's/South Beverly Grill as having the superior French dip. The chocolate pie was a standout, described as visually stunning and tasting as good as it looked. While acknowledging the burger's quality and potential to be the best in New York, the author concluded that it's a great place to visit once but not somewhere they would actively seek reservations for again.

4 Charles is described as arguably one of the hardest reservations to get in NYC. Reservations are available on Resy and are released approximately 21 days in advance at 9 AM. It receives a high rating of 9/10.

This restaurant is known for its prime rib and upscale dining experience. The image features a decadent burger topped with bacon and a fried egg, suggesting a luxurious take on comfort food.

This post spotlights 4 Charles Prime Rib, specifically praising their French Dip sandwich as the "best in the entire world." The author notes that while many visit for the burger, the French Dip is their absolute favorite and among their top three bites ever. The restaurant is portrayed as highly sought after, with reservations being extremely difficult to obtain, though the experience is deemed entirely worth the effort.

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

4 Charles Prime Rib
positive

Bryan Kim reviews 4 Charles Prime Rib, a West Village steakhouse celebrated for its legendary atmosphere and arguably the best burger in NYC. Despite its small size and tough reservation policy, the restaurant delivers a magnificent dining experience.

Bryan Kim • Aug 11, 2025
Read More →
Infatuation

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is mentioned alongside others.

Mentioned In
The Best Steakhouses in New York City
positive

A coveted, tiny West Village gem offering exceptional beef dishes like bone-in filets and dry-aged rib eyes, alongside a standout french dip and prime rib.

Bryan Kim • Oct 24, 2022
Read More →
Infatuation
Mentioned In
The NYC Restaurants Where It’s Still Impossible to Get a Table
very positive

4 Charles Prime Rib remains one of the city's most sought-after fine-dining spots, offering Korean-influenced courses in an intimate setting. The meticulous attention to detail results in pristine, satisfying, and inventive cuisine.

Bryan Kim • Jun 15, 2022
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Renowned for its exclusive, intimate atmosphere that mimics a private club, this establishment is a West Village destination for elevated American steakhouse fare [1]. While widely celebrated for its high-quality beef and signature dishes, securing a reservation remains notoriously difficult for most patrons [2], [3]. Despite the challenges in booking, many guests find the experience and exceptional quality of the food to be entirely worth the effort [3], [4].

Food Overview

The restaurant serves a high-end, a la carte American steakhouse menu featuring premium options like bone-in filets, dry-aged ribeyes, and various cuts of roast prime rib [1], [2]. The 10oz Double Wagyu Cheeseburger is a highly polarizing but popular highlight, often praised for its quality but occasionally criticized for being overly topped [1], [4]. Other standout items include the French dip sandwich, which many consider among the best in the city [3], [4], and truffle mac and cheese, though sides like elote corn have received mixed feedback regarding their flavor and consistency [1], [5].

Customer Sentiment

Customer sentiment is highly polarized between intense appreciation for the restaurant's top-tier food quality and significant frustration regarding the extreme difficulty of securing a reservation [2], [4]. While service is frequently described as lovely and professional, many diners feel that the effort and cost associated with obtaining a table often outweigh the benefits [3], [5].

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    burger$38.99
    81 mentionsMenu: 10oz Double Wagyu Cheeseburger
    Widely considered one of the best burgers in NYC, it features Ame...
  • 02
    French dip$39.99
    34 mentionsMenu: Prime Rib French Dip
    Highly recommended and considered a benchmark, this French dip is...
  • 03
    prime rib$79.99
    16 mentionsMenu: English Cut
    While some consider it a 'must-order' and a standout dish, others...
  • 04
    chocolate pie
    9 mentions
    This dessert is consistently highly praised, often called the bes...
  • 05
    truffle mac and cheese$25.99
    8 mentionsMenu: Truffle Mac & Cheese
    This side dish is frequently highlighted as a favorite and 'must-...
  • 06
    steak$150.99–$159.99
    8 mentionsMenu: Wagyu New York Strip Steak
    Steaks are generally considered high-quality, though one review f...

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About 4 CHARLES PRIME RIB

This thread provides various strategies for securing a table as a walk-in, including arriving hours before opening and the benefits of being a solo diner.
A discussion highlighting the roast rib of beef and the ongoing debate regarding the restaurant's signature burger toppings.
Users debate the merits of the establishment, specifically comparing its burger and prime rib to other local hotspots.
A conversation exploring the exclusivity of the restaurant and whether the food quality justifies the intense difficulty in obtaining a booking.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Favorite 3 Nyc Steakhouses Here Are Mine Tell Me

"Steaks are just fine, recommends the burger and French dip instead."

Neutral
Oct 19, 2026View Comment →

From post: Favorite 3 Nyc Steakhouses Here Are Mine Tell Me

"Not yet visited."

Neutral
Oct 19, 2026View Comment →

From post: Favorite 3 Nyc Steakhouses Here Are Mine Tell Me

"Steak is forgettable, but the sides and other dishes are worth visiting for."

Neutral
Oct 19, 2026View Comment →

From post: Favorite 3 Nyc Steakhouses Here Are Mine Tell Me

"User had a fun experience, though noted the food was above average but not life-changing."

Positive
Oct 19, 2026View Comment →

From post: Favorite 3 Nyc Steakhouses Here Are Mine Tell Me

"User finds it overhyped, noting that the steak is comparable to other places and the sides are mediocre."

Negative
Oct 19, 2026View Comment →

Often mentioned with 4 Charles Prime Rib

More in West Village

See all

More American in NYC

See all