Next.js logo

BAKED BY LUIGI, NYC PIZZA

Last Updated: 2 months ago

Phone: (631) 624-3646

Address: 221 EAST 23 STREET 10010

TLDR

Worth the trip for classic NYC pizza, especially Sicilian slices. Some controversy surrounding owner's views.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 7 Reddit comments)

57% Positive29% Neutral14% Negative

Tags

italian 2pizza 6View All

Neighborhoods

Kips Bay

Details

This NYC pizza joint is a must-try for pizza enthusiasts, consistently drawing praise for its delicious pies. Many patrons consider it a top-tier option, even suggesting it's worth making a dedicated trip for, particularly for its Sicilian slices. While the general consensus on the food is overwhelmingly positive, a significant concern has been raised regarding the owner's personal views, which have led some to vocally discourage others from visiting.

Food Overview

The pizza at this establishment is highly regarded, with multiple mentions of it being a standout choice and worth a special trip. It's described as a classic NYC slice, with specific recommendations for Sicilian slices. One review, however, found the pizza to be just okay.

Highlights / Recommended

"Sicilian slices are specifically recommended."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the pizza, with many recommending it and considering it worth traveling for. However, there is a strong caveat regarding the owner's controversial political and social views, which some customers feel strongly about and advise against patronizing the establishment.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

One user specifically recommends Luigi's, indicating it's a favored spot for Sicilian slices.
Multiple users express strong positive opinions about Luigi's pizza, with one user even suggesting it's worth traveling out of the way for. Another user simply states their liking for the pizza.
A user strongly advises against visiting Luigi's due to the owner's controversial political and social views, describing them with strong negative language.

Recent Mentions

From post: My Pizza List 3 Days Next Week

"Luigi's is strongly advised against visiting due to the owner's controversial political and social views, including being a 'Trump supporting, racist POS and Covid denier'."

Negative
Jun 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: Brooklyn Dop In Park Slope The Best Pizza That No

"The user states they are personally a fan of Luigi's."

Positive
May 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: Brooklyn Dop In Park Slope The Best Pizza That No

"The user considers Luigi's pizza to be just okay, describing it as a classic NYC slice."

Neutral
May 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: Brooklyn Dop In Park Slope The Best Pizza That No

"The user expresses liking for Luigi's pizza."

Positive
May 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: Brooklyn Dop In Park Slope The Best Pizza That No

"The user implies that Luigi's is worth traveling out of the way for, suggesting it offers a superior pizza experience."

Positive
May 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: Favorite Sicilian Slices

"Recommended Luigi’s"

Positive
Mar 23, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Late Night Pizza By Barclays Center

"Further"

Neutral
Mar 2, 2025View Comment →