TLDR
Flaky, buttery, and artisanal pies that set the gold standard in Brooklyn. A must-visit for classic and seasonal slices that define the neighborhood bakery experience.
Reddit Sentiment for FOUR & TWENTY BLACKBIRDS(based on 63 Reddit opinions)
Details
Renowned for its exceptional, flaky, and buttery pie crusts, this bakery is a staple for those seeking high-quality American desserts [12]. While some patrons appreciate the thin and delicate nature of the crust, others find its shard-like texture somewhat divisive [15], [16]. Despite concerns regarding potential changes due to wholesale partnerships, the shop remains a beloved destination for both seasonal and classic pie varieties [37], [43].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on masterfully crafted American pies, ranging from fruit-forward options to decadent tarts [43], [47], [57]. Highly recommended selections include sour cherry, pumpkin, apple, and seasonal favorites like sweet corn cream pie [8], [17], [30], [43], [56]. While the crust is widely celebrated for its buttery texture, some diners have noted occasional issues with filling consistency in specific fruit pies [16], [56].
Highlights / Recommended
"Patrons frequently recommend the sour cherry, pumpkin, salted caramel apple, and lemon chess pies [8], [17], [30], [43], [52]. The bittersweet chocolate pecan pie is also a standout favorite among regulars [1]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •sweet corn cream pie(2)
- •lemon chess pie(2)
- •apple pie(2)
- •peach pie(2)
Customer Sentiment
Overall feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with many customers describing the pies as divine and some of the best they have ever had [8], [10], [43], [56]. While the occasional concern arises regarding potential corporate partnerships or crust texture, the community consistently supports the bakery for its high quality and pleasant service [14], [34], [46], [54].
Caveats
Pre-orders for holiday pies can sell out extremely quickly, sometimes making walk-in availability limited on busy days [22], [23], [24]. Additionally, some visitors may find the signature thin, shard-like crust texture polarizing compared to traditional, thicker crusts [15], [16].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About FOUR & TWENTY BLACKBIRDS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Brooklyn Eats For Lovers Next Weekend Help Us
"Included in a list of food recommendations."
NeutralFrom post: Best Foodrestaurants With No Gluten Free Options
"Highly recommended for their pies."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"The shop currently has a large selection of pies available, including peach, berry, and cherry varieties."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"Mentions the shop as a recommendation in Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"Seconding the recommendation and noting pleasant customer service."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"The commenter mentions that peach pie has returned to the menu."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"Though the user hasn't tried the peach, they praise the pumpkin and apple pies as the best they have ever had."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"The shop is recommended, located in Gowanus, Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Food That Transports Well For 6 Hour Roadtrip
"This user recommended the pies from Four and Twenty Blackbirds, stating they are fantastic and travel well."
PositiveFrom post: Kentucky Derby Pie Derby Party Food
"This commenter stated that Four and Twenty Blackbirds sells chocolate pecan pies."
PositiveFrom post: Kentucky Derby Pie Derby Party Food
"This commenter mentioned that Four and Twenty Blackbirds has a derby special pie available at the moment."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"A commenter emphatically stated that Four and Twenty Blackbirds is divine."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"The commenter expressed a desire to return to Four and Twenty Blackbirds with a larger group to try more of their offerings, noting the need to accept some food waste to do so."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"A commenter reminisced about visiting Four and Twenty Blackbirds with their children and sharing slices, finding the experience to be great."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"A salted custard tart from Four and Twenty Blackbirds, purchased from Cheese Plate Brooklyn, was rated 10/10 and described as absolutely amazing."
PositiveFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user mentions that Four & Twenty Blackbirds' whole pies are sold at Mast Market on the UWS and that they used to buy slices from the cafe at Central Library, suggesting the product remains consistent."
NeutralFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user states that Four & Twenty Blackbirds serves better pie in their shop and that the owners intended it as a neighborhood pie shop. They don't foresee it closing unless sold, which they also don't expect soon."
PositiveFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user is concerned about the availability of pie slices, as the only current option besides wholesale is the brick-and-mortar store, which would force them to use the Wonder app if it closed."
NegativeFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user discovered Four & Twenty Blackbirds through Wonder after ordering their coffee pie on a whim. They were impressed by the quality and are now eager to try more pies from the establishment."
PositiveFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user states that Four & Twenty Blackbirds has been doing wholesale for a while, which is how they stay in business, and that the quality remains great."
Positive