Innovative American pies w/ unique flavors like sweet corn custard & chocolate pecan. A Brooklyn gem worth the trip!
This Brooklyn bakery is a haven for pie lovers, celebrated for its innovative and comforting American-style desserts. With a strong reputation built on unique flavors like Sweet Corn Custard and Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan, it offers a delightful escape for those seeking exceptional baked goods. Visitors often praise the quality and creativity, making it a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth.
The restaurant is renowned for its exceptional pies, with a particular emphasis on creative and seasonal American flavors. Standout recommendations include the Sweet Corn Custard Pie, Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie, and Chocolate Chess Pie. While overwhelmingly positive, one comment noted that a particular pie appeared small and thinly cut.
"Highly recommended are the Sweet Corn Custard Pie, Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie, Chocolate Chess Pie, and Black Bottom Oat Pie. Seasonal slices are also suggested."
Customers consistently praise the inventive and delicious pies, with many considering them among the best they've ever had. The Sweet Corn Custard Pie and Chocolate Chess Pie are frequently highlighted as standout items.
Important Note
One commenter mentioned that a pie appeared small and thinly cut, and another noted that certain items might be considered overpriced.
"The author gave Four and Twenty Blackbirds five stars, specifically praising their sour cherry pie."
Positive"Four and Twenty Blackbirds is outstanding for pie, recommended to have with coffee."
Positive"The commenter recommends the Lemon Chess pie from Four and Twenty Blackbirds."
Positive"The commenter suggests trying the black bottom oat or seasonal slice from Four and Twenty Blackbirds."
Positive"The commenter suggests pairing a visit to Four & Twenty Blackbirds with IKEA runs via ferry and bus."
Neutral"The commenter notes that Four & Twenty Blackbirds is worth the trip to Brooklyn."
Positive"The commenter recommends slices of pie like Lemon Chess or Chocolate Chess from Four & Twenty Blackbirds."
Positive"The commenter recommends the bittersweet chocolate pecan pie from Four and Twenty Blackbirds."
Positive"The user recommends this place for its lemon chess pie."
Positive"This user suggests Four and Twenty Blackbirds for their bittersweet chocolate pecan pie."
Positive"This commenter enjoyed the sweet corn cream pie at Four and Twenty Blackbirds and hopes it returns next summer."
Positive"This commenter feels Four and Twenty Blackbirds doesn't get enough love."
Positive"Four and Twenty Blackbirds is mentioned for pie."
Positive"Expressed enthusiasm for corn desserts and found the presented dish amazing, while also inquiring about sweet corn bingsu in the city."
Positive"Commented that the dish looks unique and expressed a desire to try it."
Positive"Stated their intention to visit the restaurant the following day."
Neutral"Commented that the dish looks delicious but also noted it appeared small and thinly cut, with the pie itself not seeming to be more than an inch tall."
Neutral"Shared a link to a recipe for the restaurant's Matcha Custard pie, indicating a positive experience or interest in it."
Positive"Simply expressed a strong liking for the restaurant."
Positive"Expressed a strong positive sentiment for the restaurant, specifically recalling fondly eating half of a chocolate chess pie."
Positive
