Next.js logo

FOUR & TWENTY BLACKBIRDS

Updated

Phone: (718) 499-2917

Address: 439 3 AVENUE 10016

TLDR

Iconic, buttery-crusted pies in seasonal flavors. A go-to NYC bakery for high-quality, handcrafted desserts.

Reddit Sentiment for FOUR & TWENTY BLACKBIRDS(based on 57 Reddit opinions)

63% Positive28% Neutral9% Negative

Tags

american 17pie 40dessert 20pies 7View All

Neighborhoods

Kips Bay

Details

Renowned for their exceptional, high-quality pies, this beloved Brooklyn bakery has cultivated a dedicated following thanks to their signature flaky, buttery crusts [5], [10]. While the shop operates as a neighborhood staple, their robust wholesale business ensures the consistency of their baked goods reaches a wider audience [32], [38]. Patrons consistently rave about the seasonal offerings and variety, often calling the experience divine [24], [46].

Food Overview

This bakery specializes in American-style pies, with a menu that frequently rotates based on seasonal availability. Popular flavors include salted caramel apple pie, pumpkin, and sour cherry, as well as unique creations like sweet corn cream pie and salted custard tart [1], [23], [44], [50], [52]. While nearly all feedback is glowing, one critique noted that a specific apple pie had an improperly parcooked filling that turned out mushy [9].

Customer Sentiment

Overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with many customers considering their pies the best they have ever tasted [3], [50]. Some minor debates occasionally arise regarding the specific texture of the thin crust, but the general consensus remains enthusiastic [6], [8].

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    sweet corn cream pie
    2 mentions
  • 02
    lemon chess pie
    2 mentions
  • 03
    apple pie
    2 mentions
  • 04
    salted caramel apple pie
    2 mentions
  • 05
    peach pie
    2 mentions

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About FOUR & TWENTY BLACKBIRDS

This thread provides a comprehensive look at the current pie selection, confirming favorites like apple and pumpkin, while noting the bakery's pleasant service.
A deep dive into the bakery's business model, addressing community concerns about their wholesale operations and partnerships with delivery platforms.
This discussion centers on the bakery's signature crust, highlighting the divide between fans of the thin, flaky style and those who prefer something different.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: If You Could Only Pick One What Is Your Favorite

"The user highly recommends their pies, specifically the fruit varieties."

Positive
Sep 13, 2026View Comment →

From post: Brooklyn Eats For Lovers Next Weekend Help Us

"Included in a list of food recommendations."

Neutral
Jul 27, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Foodrestaurants With No Gluten Free Options

"Highly recommended for their pies."

Positive
Jul 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole

"The shop currently has a large selection of pies available, including peach, berry, and cherry varieties."

Positive
Jul 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole

"Mentions the shop as a recommendation in Brooklyn."

Positive
Jul 17, 2026View Comment →

More in Kips Bay

See all

More American in NYC

See all