TLDR
Must-try pies with unique flavors & textures. Rave-worthy Sweet Corn Custard Pie & Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie. A dessert lover's dream!
Reddit Sentiment for FOUR & TWENTY BLACKBIRDS(based on 72 Reddit opinions)
Details
This beloved bakery is a go-to spot for exceptional pies, with many customers raving about their unique flavors and textures. From the Sweet Corn Custard Pie to the Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie, there's a flavor to satisfy every palate. The quality of their baked goods is consistently praised, making it a highly recommended destination for dessert lovers [1], [2], [3].
Food Overview
The bakery is renowned for its pies, with the Sweet Corn Custard Pie receiving particular acclaim for its balanced sweetness and unique cornmeal texture [1]. Other highly recommended options include the Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie [4] and the Lemon Chess Pie [5]. While the crust is a point of discussion, with some finding it divisive [6], [7], many still consider it the best part of their pies [8]. There's also mention of a seasonal Sweet Corn Cream Pie that is highly anticipated [9].
Caveats
There are mixed opinions regarding the pie crust, with some finding it divisive. Additionally, there was concern and discussion about the restaurant's potential partnership with Wonder, with some users advising to order directly from the establishment.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About FOUR & TWENTY BLACKBIRDS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Nyc Food That Transports Well For 6 Hour Roadtrip
"This user recommended the pies from Four and Twenty Blackbirds, stating they are fantastic and travel well."
PositiveFrom post: Kentucky Derby Pie Derby Party Food
"This commenter stated that Four and Twenty Blackbirds sells chocolate pecan pies."
PositiveFrom post: Kentucky Derby Pie Derby Party Food
"This commenter mentioned that Four and Twenty Blackbirds has a derby special pie available at the moment."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"A commenter emphatically stated that Four and Twenty Blackbirds is divine."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"The commenter expressed a desire to return to Four and Twenty Blackbirds with a larger group to try more of their offerings, noting the need to accept some food waste to do so."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"A commenter reminisced about visiting Four and Twenty Blackbirds with their children and sharing slices, finding the experience to be great."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"A salted custard tart from Four and Twenty Blackbirds, purchased from Cheese Plate Brooklyn, was rated 10/10 and described as absolutely amazing."
PositiveFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user mentions that Four & Twenty Blackbirds' whole pies are sold at Mast Market on the UWS and that they used to buy slices from the cafe at Central Library, suggesting the product remains consistent."
NeutralFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user states that Four & Twenty Blackbirds serves better pie in their shop and that the owners intended it as a neighborhood pie shop. They don't foresee it closing unless sold, which they also don't expect soon."
PositiveFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user is concerned about the availability of pie slices, as the only current option besides wholesale is the brick-and-mortar store, which would force them to use the Wonder app if it closed."
NegativeFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user discovered Four & Twenty Blackbirds through Wonder after ordering their coffee pie on a whim. They were impressed by the quality and are now eager to try more pies from the establishment."
PositiveFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user states that Four & Twenty Blackbirds has been doing wholesale for a while, which is how they stay in business, and that the quality remains great."
PositiveFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"Following up on the wholesale discussion, this user asks if the person still likes pie, and the original poster clarifies they do, even the ones they helped make in bulk."
NeutralFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user, who worked at Four & Twenty Blackbirds' production facility, confirms they have a large wholesale operation for frozen pies in addition to their retail shop. They mention selling many apple pies wholesale and are not concerned about the brand unless it's sold."
PositiveFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user is unsure about the exact nature of the partnership but notes that whole pies are available at Green Grape Provisions and slices were previously sold at the Central Library cafe. They prefer to order directly from the Gowanus Four & Twenty Blackbirds location rather than using Wonder."
NeutralFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user advises against using delivery apps like Seamless and Grubhub, and encourages ordering directly from restaurants to support independent establishments in NYC."
NeutralFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user suggests that Four & Twenty Blackbirds has had a robust wholesale business for years as a way to remain in business."
NeutralFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user reiterates that if a pie flavor were exclusive to Wonder, it would be worse, and suggests ordering directly from Four & Twenty Blackbirds."
NeutralFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user notes that the featured pie flavor is still available on Four & Twenty Blackbirds' own website, but would be upset if Wonder made a flavor exclusive. They advise ordering directly from the restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: Did Four Twenty Blackbirds Sell Out To Wonder Too
"This user believes Four & Twenty Blackbirds is selling pies on Wonder, but is glad it's not a microwaved version. They express frustration that Wonder has the resources to partner with and potentially "sell out" local establishments."
Negative