Exceptional pies w/ unique flavors like Sweet Corn Custard. Highly praised for desserts, esp. pies like Black Bottom Oat & Chocolate.
This bakery is celebrated for its exceptional pies, with a particular standout being the Sweet Corn Custard Pie, lauded for its balanced sweetness and unique cornmeal texture. Other highly recommended options include the Black Bottom Oat Pie, Chocolate Pie, and seasonal specials. While some find it a bit pricey, many agree the quality and unique flavors make it a worthwhile indulgence.
This establishment is a highly acclaimed bakery specializing in pies. The Sweet Corn Custard Pie is a standout, praised for its balanced sweetness and pleasant cornmeal texture. Other popular choices include the Black Bottom Oat Pie and Chocolate Pie. While generally receiving high marks, a few commenters noted that it can be a bit pricey, and one mentioned a divisive crust quality, though this seems to be an outlier opinion.
"Highly recommended pies include the Sweet Corn Custard Pie, Black Bottom Oat Pie, Chocolate Pie, and seasonal offerings like pumpkin pie. The bittersweet chocolate pecan pie and lemon chess pie are also frequently mentioned."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pies, with specific mentions of unique flavors and textures. While some note it's on the pricier side, the consensus is that the quality justifies the cost.
Important Note
Some users find the pies to be on the pricier side. There's a minor debate among commenters regarding the quality and texture of the pie crust.
"This comment suggests Four and Twenty Blackbirds for pie as a catering option."
Neutral"The commenter suggests arriving at 6 AM to secure a day-of pie from Four and twenty blackbirds, expressing a strong desire for their pies."
Positive"The commenter visited Four and twenty blackbirds an hour prior and found only slices of salty honey and a few pecan pies left, with more expected for the next day's opening."
Neutral"Four and twenty blackbirds has pies available for pickup, though the commenter notes there might be a line."
Positive"Mentioned that Four and Twenty Blackbirds had already closed their Thanksgiving ordering window."
Negative"Stated that Four and Twenty Blackbirds' pre-order was sold out, leaving only the option to try for a walk-in on the day."
Negative"Seconded the recommendation for Four and Twenty Blackbirds."
Positive"Recommended as a bakery for desserts, though pre-orders may be closed."
Neutral"This bakery is mentioned for Thanksgiving preorders, suggesting they would be a good option for desserts."
Positive"This user suggests Four Twenty Blackbird as an option for apple pie."
Neutral"This user lists Four and Twenty Blackbirds as a 'bougie bakery' with pies typically around $45, positioning it as a more affordable option than the $75+ pies initially discussed."
Positive"This commenter recommends Four & Twenty Blackbirds in Park Slope/Gowanus for their pies, noting that whole pies are usually around $45."
Positive"This user recommended Four and Twenty Blackbirds as a place to get pumpkin pie. They also mentioned Hanis for pumpkin bread loaf and Little Pie Company."
Positive"In response to a critique of the crust at Four and Twenty Blackbirds, this commenter expresses a liking for the thinness and buttery texture. They also mention trying Bubby's and finding the crust greasy and the apple filling mushy."
Positive"This commenter clarifies their previous point, stating that while they are a fan of Four and Twenty Blackbirds, they find the crust to be the weakest part. They describe it as potentially too thin and flaking like shards, though they acknowledge it might vary by pie."
Negative"This commenter expresses surprise at the idea of Four and Twenty Blackbirds' crust being divisive, considering it the best part of their pies. They inquire further about what makes it divisive."
Positive"This commenter is a fan of Four and Twenty Blackbirds but finds their crust to be a divisive aspect. They believe the crust might not meet the original poster's specific preferences if Petee's was found lacking."
Neutral"This commenter recommends Four and Twenty Blackbirds, noting their pie crust is often recommended on the sub and is described as flaky, crunchy, and buttery."
Positive"This user recommends the pie from Four and Twenty Blackbirds."
Positive"The user recommends Four and Twenty Blackbirds for buying a pumpkin pie, stating it's the best they've ever eaten but is more expensive than $7."
Positive
