NY's go-to Jewish deli, serving legendary matzo ball soup & pastrami! A classic, no-fuss experience often preferred over more famous rivals.
A classic New York Jewish deli experience, this establishment is frequently recommended as a superior alternative to Katz's, particularly for those seeking a less chaotic atmosphere. Patrons rave about the matzo ball soup, often citing it as the best they've ever had, and the pastrami is a consistent favorite, though some note it may be machine-sliced and portions can vary. The deli also offers other traditional fare, including brisket and corned beef, with a focus on authentic, high-quality kosher preparations.
This Jewish deli is celebrated for its exceptional matzo ball soup and pastrami, frequently drawing comparisons to and often surpassing Katz's. While pastrami is a staple, some users note a preference for the brisket or corned beef. The establishment maintains strict kosher standards, influencing menu options and preparation methods.
"The matzo ball soup and pastrami are consistently highlighted as must-try dishes. Brisket, corned beef, and chicken in the pot are also frequently recommended for their quality."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the quality of the food, especially the matzo ball soup and pastrami, often recommending it as a top-tier Jewish deli experience. Many note a preference for its atmosphere and authenticity over more crowded establishments.
Important Note
While generally highly regarded, some patrons note that pastrami portions can be smaller than in the past, and the deli's strict kosher adherence means certain popular deli combinations (like a pastrami reuben with Swiss cheese) are not available.
"Prefers the corned beef over the pastrami at 2nd Ave Deli, which is unusual as they generally prefer pastrami."
Positive"States that 2nd Ave Deli has the best corned beef."
Positive"Likes the corned beef at 2nd Ave Deli, describing it as 'so classic'."
Positive"Orders brisket at 2nd Ave Deli and finds it good, though they haven't tried the corned beef."
Neutral"This user confirmed that a recent delivery order from 2nd Ave Deli had a significantly smaller sandwich portion than they recalled, though they also praised PJ.Bernstein's for large portions."
Negative"This user stated that their recent experience with 2nd Ave Deli's pastrami sandwich resulted in a smaller portion than remembered."
Negative"This user recommended Second Ave Deli, describing it as very warm, inviting, and great for conversation with excellent food."
Positive"Recommends 2nd Ave Deli as a dining option in the area."
Positive"Suggests 2nd Ave Deli as a good choice for a meal."
Positive"The user is considering 2nd Ave Deli for matzo ball soup as a comfort food option after a doctor's appointment in the Kips Bay area."
Neutral"2nd Avenue Deli was mentioned in a list of delis that might serve pickle appetizers."
Neutral"This commenter mentions 2nd Ave. deli on the Upper East Side as a less crowded alternative to Katz's."
Neutral"This commenter mentions 2nd Ave. deli on the Upper East Side as a less crowded alternative to Katz's."
Neutral"For a more traditional knish experience, the fried one at 2nd Ave Deli is suggested as an alternative."
Positive"2nd Ave Deli is listed as one of several recommended establishments for an authentic New York experience."
Neutral"2nd Ave Deli, located on 1st Ave, is recommended as a New York food destination."
Positive"Also recommends the chicken in the pot from Second Avenue Deli, noting its large portion size when delivered."
Positive"Seconding matzah ball soup and also recommends the chicken in the pot from Second Avenue Deli for curative properties."
Positive"Strongly agrees with the recommendation of matzah ball soup."
Positive"Recommends 2nd Ave Deli for matzah ball soup, alongside Veselka and Sarge's."
Positive
