TLDR
An authentic, strictly kosher NYC deli known for superior matzo ball soup and reliable pastrami that serves as an excellent, less-crowded alternative to other famous institutions.
Details
A staple of the New York deli scene, this establishment is widely celebrated for its authentic Jewish-American classics and welcoming atmosphere [13], [29]. While many diners view it as a premier alternative to more crowded tourist spots for high-quality pastrami and comfort food [1], [14], [31], it is specifically praised for its signature soups and traditional deli offerings [8], [38]. Patrons consistently value the establishment for both its sit-down dining experience and its reliable quality [29], [36].
Food Overview
This strictly kosher deli offers a range of traditional dishes including pastrami, corned beef, and brisket [4], [25], [27]. It is most frequently praised for its "chiffon-like" matzo ball soup, which many consider the best in the city, and its center-cut tongue sandwich [8]. While its pastrami is highly regarded, some diners note that its kosher status precludes items like reubens and that certain dishes have faced scrutiny regarding portion consistency [4], [22], [24].
The matzo ball soup and center-cut tongue sandwich are consistently highlighted as standout items [8]. The corned beef and brisket are also frequently recommended for their classic, high-quality flavor profiles [25], [26], [27].
Overall feedback is highly positive, with diners frequently praising the restaurant's warm, inviting atmosphere and high-quality traditional deli offerings [29], [31]. While some patrons occasionally report concerns regarding portion sizes or pickle quality, it remains a highly recommended destination for both tourists and locals [22], [23], [44].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01pastrami18 mentions
- 02matzoh ball soup5 mentions
- 03matzo ball soup4 mentions
- 04pastrami sandwich3 mentions
- 05brisket2 mentions
- 06soups2 mentions
Caveats
As a strictly kosher establishment, the kitchen does not serve dairy and meat together, meaning popular items like reuben sandwiches are unavailable [4], [24]. Some diners have noted that portions of certain sandwiches can be inconsistent, and the quality of pickles has received mixed feedback [22], [44].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About 2ND AVE DELI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Shoutout To Jj Deli On Trinity Pl In Fidi A
"The restaurant is suggested as a contender for high-quality deli food in the context of the pastrami debate."
NeutralFrom post: Two Brazilians Eating Their Way Through Nyc Part
"Mentioned as a superior alternative to Katz's for pastrami."
PositiveFrom post: This Might Be One Of The Best Pastrami Sandwiches
"The user prefers this over Pastrami Queen."
PositiveFrom post: This Might Be One Of The Best Pastrami Sandwiches
"The user identifies this as their personal favorite."
PositiveFrom post: This Might Be One Of The Best Pastrami Sandwiches
"The user expresses a love for this place."
Positive