Under-the-radar pizza spot serving up unique Roman-style & grandma slices w/ crispy crusts & zesty sauce. A must-try for pizza lovers!
This spot offers a unique take on pizza, with many praising its Roman-style slices and the distinct quality of its crust and sauce. It's highlighted for its delicious grandma slices, often considered on par with other top-tier pizza joints, and its creative topping combinations. While generally well-received, some experiences can be hit or miss, and specific dietary options like paleo or gluten-free may not be readily available.
Specializing in Roman-style pizza and square slices, this establishment is frequently recommended for its delicious, crispy crusts and pleasantly acidic sauces. The grandma slices are noted as being exceptional, rivaling other famous pizzerias. While most feedback is positive, some find their experience to be inconsistent, and it's unclear if paleo or gluten-free options are available.
"The grandma slice and Roman-style pizza are frequently recommended. Diners also specifically enjoyed the chicory slice."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, often calling it a personal favorite and highlighting the quality of the crust and sauce. However, there are occasional mixed reviews and uncertainty about specialized dietary options.
Important Note
Some customers have found their experience to be a bit hit or miss. Information on paleo or gluten-free options is uncertain.
"Commenter suggested Unregular Pizza as having something similar to what the original poster is describing, noting it's Roman-style pizza with interesting toppings."
Positive"Commenter stated that Unregular Pizza visually resembles the pizza in the original post, emphasizing that its bottom is fluffy like bread and not a crust, and that it's made fresh."
Positive"The commenter found the chicory slice at Unregular Pizza to be delicious, but overall felt their experience was a bit hit or miss."
Neutral"Unregular Pizza is mentioned as a good option for thick crust square slices if one is near Union Square."
Positive"Unregular Pizza is listed as a Roman pizza al taglio option in NYC, noted as a more modern take."
Neutral"The reviewer tried the grandma slice at Unregular Pizza in Union Square and loved it, placing it on par with Bleecker Street Pizza and above John's of Bleecker for their personal taste."
Positive"The reviewer tried this random place because the pizza looked good. The pizza was indeed very good, with a crispy crust and pleasantly acidic sauce."
Positive"A user lists Unregular Pizza as a good option for pizza."
Positive"A user highly recommends Unregular Pizza, stating it's one of their personal favorites."
Positive"Recommends Unregular Pizza for slices."
Positive"Lists Unregular as a good pizza option in Midtown, though notes better options exist outside the area."
Positive"Recommends Unregular Pizza near Union Square as great and under the radar, though unsure about paleo/gluten-free options."
Positive
